Gotcha! Ultra-realistic robot proves there's more than one way to scare a fish

Gotcha! Ultra-realistic robot proves there's more than 1 way to scare a fish
Credit: NYU Polytechnic School of Engineering

In the world of the tiny zebrafish, the predatory red tiger oscar is the stuff of nightmares. And while the species has no natural reason to fear robots, researchers at the NYU Polytechnic School of Engineering have published the first study showing that, in a side-by-side comparison, a robotic predator can spook zebrafish just as well as the real thing. Their results may help advance understanding of fear and anxiety in animal populations, including humans.

The study, along with an image of the strikingly lifelike robotic model, is the cover story of the forthcoming June issue of the journal Zebrafish.

Zebrafish are a highly versatile species that are increasingly taking the place of more complex animals in behavioral studies. They have been used to explore social behavior, as well as aspects of cognition, anxiety, and fear.

However, all experiments using live animals have limitations. Their behavior can be unpredictable, and factors such as environment and fatigue can impact results. Maurizio Porfiri, professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering at the NYU School of Engineering, creates bio-inspired robotic models that serve as fully predictable, controllable stimuli alongside live animals. His experiments have shown the advantages of using robots in studies of fish behavior, including repeatability and consistency.

For this first-ever comparative test of fear, Porfiri and his team devised an experimental tank divided into three compartments. The first was left empty, the second was occupied by a live zebrafish, and the third compartment was for one of three different experimental stimuli: a live red tiger oscar, a computer animation of a swimming oscar, or the replica. They also performed a control trial in which the zebrafish simply swam in the tank with no stimulus.

The zebrafish exposed to the live red tiger oscar and those exposed to the robotic replica showed unequivocal fear responses. They spent far less time in the area of the tank where the real oscar fish or the robot was placed. Importantly, the researchers also noted that the avoidance response of zebrafish toward the robot was more consistent than toward the live red tiger oscar.

Credit: NYU Polytechnic School of Engineering

"Avoidance isn't the only way we can tell a zebrafish is scared," said Porfiri. "When these fish are afraid, they also swim differently, and we were surprised to find that the robotic fish could produce an even stronger fear-related response than the actual live predator."

The zebrafish showed little or no response to the animated images of a red tiger oscar. Because previous studies have shown the effectiveness of such animations in impacting zebrafish behavior, Porfiri suspects that this particular animation was not perceived as especially threatening.

The researchers believe that this is the first study to directly compare the response of zebrafish to both live and robotic predators. Porfiri commented that the choice of predator, the red tiger oscar, played a significant role in the outcome of these experiments.

"The oscar fish is a known zebrafish predator, but it's not the most threatening one out there," Porfiri said. "We chose a predator that could be relied upon to scare the , but not to the point of complete avoidance that would mask what we were trying to uncover." This slightly moderated fear response allowed the team to examine the full scope of fear-related behaviors in these , as well as prove that they could induce them with both a robot and a live animal counterpart.

Explore further

Robots strike fear in the hearts of fish

More information: Zebrafish, … 0.1089/zeb.2014.1041
Citation: Gotcha! Ultra-realistic robot proves there's more than one way to scare a fish (2015, April 7) retrieved 19 August 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Apr 07, 2015
Of course the experiment assumes that the fish doesn't know the robot isn't a fish which may be an incorrect assumption. Animals are smarter than we think, probably even fish.

Apr 07, 2015
No, you're inferring that the experiment implies they understand the difference. The experiment simply showed that a robotic fish produced a response that a video did not. The robotic fish was seen as more of a threat than the video was. The zebrafish need not be concerned about whether the robotic fish was a fish or a robot, just that the robot was more 'real' than a video.

Apr 07, 2015
we were surprised to find that the robotic fish could produce an even stronger fear-related response than the actual live predator
LOL, these experts probably believe that the fish cannot hear..

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more