Peer-reviewed paper says all ivory markets must close

August 7, 2014
An ivory stockpile that was destroyed by the US Fish and Wildlife service last year. Credit: Julie Larsen Maher/WCS

The message is simple: to save elephants, all ivory markets must close and all ivory stockpiles must be destroyed, according to a new peer-reviewed paper by the Wildlife Conservation Society. The paper says that corruption, organized crime, and a lack of enforcement make any legal trade of ivory a major factor contributing to the demise of Africa's elephants.

Appearing in the August 7th online edition of the journal Conservation Biology, the paper says that if we are to conserve significant wild populations of elephants across all regions of Africa, all domestic and international ivory markets need to be closed. In addition, government stockpiles of ivory, currently scattered around the world, need to be destroyed since they are known to be significant sources of ivory leaking into the illegal trade. According to the paper's author, corruption undermines all aspects of controls as long as a legal market remains.

"If we are to conserve remaining wild populations of elephants, we must close all markets because, under current levels of corruption, they cannot be controlled in a way that does not provide opportunities for illegal ivory being laundered into legal markets," said the paper's author, Elizabeth Bennett, WCS Vice President for Species Conservation.

The paper looked at the index of 177 assessed countries, noting that half of the 12 countries in Africa that contain elephants are in the bottom 40 percent. Six of the eight countries identified by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) as most implicated in ivory trafficking globally are in the bottom half of the most corrupt countries in the world.

The paper comes at a time of growing opposition to ivory bans by some groups claiming that carefully regulated ivory sales would help protect elephants and contribute to conservation through sales of ivory stockpiles and other legal sources.

Bennett refutes this saying that saying that financial incentives to break the law and reap profits far outweigh those of abiding by it, as poachers and traffickers can rapidly pay their way out of trouble. Once illegal ivory has entered into the legal trade, it is difficult or impossible for enforcement officers to know what is legal and what is not.

Bennett says that with good enforcement on the ground, the tide of poaching can be slowed. For example, forest elephants in Central Africa occur in densities seven times higher in sites with ecoguards than without them. However, the costs of such site-based protection in terms of funds and human lives will continue to increase and be unsustainable as long as ivory profits continue to escalate giving ever-increasing incentives to kill elephants illegally and traffic in their ivory.

Says Bennett: "In the long term, the only sustainable solution is for the demand for – the ultimate driver of the system – to be reduced. Until that happens, if are to survive, we need to close existing legal markets."

Explore further: Thai ivory boom 'fuelling Africa elephant crisis'

More information: … /cobi.12377/abstract

Related Stories

Smuggled elephant ivory price triples

July 3, 2014

The price of ivory taken from African elephants slaughtered for their tusks has tripled in the past four years in China, the world's biggest market, conservationists said on Thursday.

Study: 20,000 elephants poached in Africa in 2013

June 13, 2014

(AP)—More than 20,000 elephants were poached last year in Africa where large seizures of smuggled ivory eclipsed those in Asia for the first time, international wildlife regulators said Friday.

Thailand faces trade ban over ivory failings

July 11, 2014

Thailand faces an international wildlife trade ban unless it reins in its illegal ivory sector, which is a magnet for traffickers, global regulator CITES said on Friday.

Global effort needed to stem elephant slaughter

July 9, 2014

Elephants will be wiped out in some parts of Africa unless more countries get involved in efforts to prevent poaching and ivory smuggling, according to wildlife regulator CITES.

Recommended for you

New discovery challenges long-held evolutionary theory

October 19, 2017

Monash scientists involved in one of the world's longest evolution experiments have debunked an established theory with a study that provides a 'high-resolution' view of the molecular details of adaptation.

Water striders illustrate evolutionary processes

October 19, 2017

How do new species arise and diversify in nature? Natural selection offers an explanation, but the genetic and environmental conditions behind this mechanism are still poorly understood. A team led by Abderrahman Khila at ...

Gene editing in the brain gets a major upgrade

October 19, 2017

Genome editing technologies have revolutionized biomedical science, providing a fast and easy way to modify genes. However, the technique allowing scientists to carryout the most precise edits, doesn't work in cells that ...

Gut bacteria from wild mice boost health in lab mice

October 19, 2017

Laboratory mice that are given the gut bacteria of wild mice can survive a deadly flu virus infection and fight colorectal cancer dramatically better than laboratory mice with their own gut bacteria, researchers report October ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Aug 07, 2014
One possible way to address this problem would be to develop the materials and 3D printer technology to create materials indistinguishable from ivory. If that was available and cheap, the cost of ivory would plummet and the market for real ivory should dry up.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 08, 2014
Spot the flaws. First, closing legal markets is not going to happen this year or next--too many people own historical ivory and they are not going to be denied its marketable value without a fight. Second, illegal markets will pop up dark internet or otherwise --people like owning ivory like taking illegal drugs or having exotic endangered pets. Like all prohibitions, "ivory prohibition" is fine in theory but defeated by inconvenient realities in practice. Third, peer review here only means three other people agreed with the article's opinions--its not quality control.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 08, 2014
Peer-reviewed paper says all ivory markets must close
Aren't all ivory markets illegal and as such closed already? Did it help with something?
5 / 5 (1) Aug 08, 2014
I really doubt the poachers are going to stop because it's "illegal" hasn't stopped em so far.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 08, 2014
No different than any other prohibition. We'll simply have more people in prisons than we ALREADY do and roughly the same amount of ivory on the market...
Whydening Gyre
not rated yet Aug 08, 2014
As long as they don't illegalize old silverware, I'll stay in business...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.