Lead in hunting bullets is dispensable – study proves suitability of alternatives

Lead in hunting bullets is dispensable – study proves suitability of alternatives
Deforming copper bullet (TSX). (A–D) Cavities at increasing energies. No clouds of fragments. Credit: Felix Gremse

A new study concerning terminal ballistics of lead-containing and lead-free bullets shows that both materials are equally suitable for hunting in accordance with animal welfare. Lead-free bullets even leave smaller fragment clouds than leaded ones.

Scientists of the University Hospital RWTH in Aachen, the German Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW) and the University of Applied Sciences Eberswalde (HNEE) analysed the characteristics of during impact, penetration or piercing of a target in a terminal ballistic experiment. The results have been published in the scientific online journal PLOS ONE. This study, which is supported by the Federal Ministry of Food and Agriculture and the Ministry for Agriculture, Environment and Consumer Protection of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, enhances the research on the effect of notably -free bullets. A detailed comparison revealed that lead-free bullets differ in their terminal ballistic behaviour. One type of lead-free bullets (deforming bullet) exhibited a terminal ballistic behaviour that was in accordance with the lead-containing reference bullet. The scientists further observed the diffusion of hundreds of tiny lead fragments during firing with lead-containing , whereas only a few fragments occurred while using lead-free bullets.

For their study the researchers compared the terminal ballistic data of four different commonly used hunting bullet types – one containing a lead-core and three made of homogenous copper alloy. The bullets were shot in a block of ballistic soap with a speed that represents typical hunting settings in the field. Each block of ballistic soap (25 cm x 25 cm x 40 cm; ~ 27 kg mass) was shot once and examined via two different measuring systems. After shooting, each soap block was scanned using computer tomography (CT) and evaluated with software developed by the RWTH Aachen. The CT visualised the resulting cavity as well as parameters like volume, depth of damage and deflection angle. Furthermore, bullet fragments can be counted and visualised three-dimensionally. Afterwards each block was cut lengthways by a usual standard procedure in order to be photographed and measured.

Lead in hunting bullets is dispensable – study proves suitability of alternatives
Deforming lead-containing bullet (NVU). (A-D) Cavities at increasing energies. Many metal fragments are visible (fragment clouds). Credit: Felix Gremse

The results of both methods correlated strongly. However, the computed tomography provides additional information while avoiding the elaborate cutting of the soap blocks. This way, the examination of new types of lead-free ammunition concerning their hunting practicability can be improved.

Lead is known to be poisonous since ancient times; today it is one of the best known environmental pollutants.

Lead-containing ammunition has a strong effect on humans, animals and the environment. At present, the input of lead into the environment through lead-containing ammunition (estimably several tons per year) is tremendous. Minor traces of lead abrasion or small fragments are already sufficient to be toxic for an organism. Especially for animals who are at the end of the food chain, like large birds of prey and scavengers, particularly the white-tailed sea eagles, lead poisoning is one of the most common causes of death. For humans a minor amount of lead can be toxic and lead to damages of the central nervous system. The intake of lead also causes developmental disorders, particularly in children.

"The results of our study are a further step of knowledge on the way to abandonment of lead in hunting ammunition. It is a process that is already been running since ten years and is mutually supported by policy-makers, hunters and research facilities", says Carl Gremse; scientific assistant at the University of Applied Sciences Eberswalde; Department of Wildlife Biology, Wildlife Management and Hunting Technology.

The applied results of research offer a solid knowledge base for political and private decisions concerning the application of lead-free hunting ammunition.


Explore further

More Grand Canyon condors die of lead poisoning

More information: Gremse F, Krone O, Thamm M, Kiessling F, Tolba RH, Rieger S, Gremse C (2014): "Performance of lead-free versus lead-based hunting ammunition in ballistic soap." PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0102015
Journal information: PLoS ONE

Citation: Lead in hunting bullets is dispensable – study proves suitability of alternatives (2014, July 22) retrieved 15 September 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2014-07-bullets-suitability-alternatives.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
0 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jul 22, 2014
Yes, lead free ammo can be made to work. Copper is quite expensive in comparison. Iron/Steel is prohibited by ATF, mainly to drive up the price of ammo, but to be fair maybe could cause more sparks in dry climates (not proven).
So, lets remove the lead and reduce the federal taxes to keep the price the same or lower.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more