Blow for Australia government as carbon tax repeal fails

July 10, 2014 by Martin Parry
A demonstrator shouts slogans during a protest against a carbon tax in Sydney on July 1, 2012

Australia's conservative government on Thursday suffered a setback when the upper house Senate voted against abolishing a carbon tax, the central platform of its election win last year.

Prime Minister Tony Abbott went to the polls in September vowing that the divisive pollution levy would go, arguing the cost was being passed to consumers, resulting in higher utility bills.

The tax was imposed by the former Labor government on major polluters from 2012 in a bid to reduce carbon emissions.

The government was confident it had the numbers in the Senate for its repeal bill to go through, but at the last minute powerbroker Clive Palmer ordered his three senators to vote against it.

It was defeated by 37 votes to 35.

The Palmer United Party sided with Labor, the Greens and another minor party, claiming the government had not adequately dealt with its insistence that savings from the tax's axing were passed on to consumers.

Palmer had added a late provision to the amendments he demanded to support the repeal, that if savings were not passed on by July 1, 2015 energy, gas and electricity producers would have to pay stiff penalties.

"That wasn't well received," Palmer, a mining tycoon best known for his plan to build a replica of the Titanic, said of the government's reaction.

Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott at the US Department of State in Washington, DC on June 12, 2014

Before the vote, Abbott, who once said evidence blaming mankind for climate change was "absolute crap", had heralded it as "the day when the is finally scrapped".

Ministers vow to fight on

His ministers vowed to fight on and re-introduce their bill to the lower house on Monday after further talks with Palmer.

"We remain calmly, methodically, determined to continue to proceed until the carbon tax is repealed," Environment Minister Greg Hunt said.

"We are determined to honour the will of the Australian people."

Senate leader Eric Abetz added that the failure of the bill was down to "a technical issue" and he was confident it could be sorted out.

"The Palmer United Party are committed to the repeal of the carbon tax, as is the government, so I believe that next week we can resolve the issues that were of a technical nature," he said.

The government says axing the tax would save the average household Aus$550 ($517) a year and strengthen the economy, which is among the world's worst per capita polluters due to its reliance on coal-fired power and mining exports.

Under the carbon tax, the country's biggest polluters pay for the emissions they produce, giving them an incentive to reduce them.

The Abbott administration—the first post-war Australian not to have a science minister—favours a "direct action" plan that includes financial incentives for polluters to increase their energy efficiency.

The Climate Action Tracker, an independent monitor of countries' carbon pledges and actions, has claimed this method will increase Australia's emissions by 12 percent in 2020 instead of reducing them by five percent from 2000 levels as per its own target.

Australian Conservation Foundation chief executive Kelly O'Shanassy welcomed the failure of the bill and urged that it be rejected again if re-introduced next week.

"Our price on pollution is working; in fact it is working spectacularly well, and we hope that with the time they now have, our representatives in parliament think deeply about why they would scrap a working law," she said.

Explore further: Repeal of Australia's carbon tax moves closer

Related Stories

Repeal of Australia's carbon tax moves closer

November 21, 2013

A bill to abolish an Australian carbon tax designed to combat climate change cleared parliament's lower house Thursday with the new conservative government saying "it doesn't work".

Australia PM moves to repeal climate tax

November 13, 2013

Australia's new conservative Prime Minister Tony Abbott Wednesday moved to abolish a carbon tax designed to combat climate change as his first major economic reform since taking office.

Thousands rally in Australia for climate action

November 17, 2013

Thousands of people on Sunday rallied across Australia calling for stronger action on climate change, days after new conservative Prime Minister Tony Abbott moved to abolish a carbon tax.

New Australian PM abolishes climate watchdog

September 19, 2013

Australia's new conservative government on Thursday abolished an independent climate change commission set up by the previous Labor administration, as part of its plans to streamline bureaucracy.

Australia to scrap carbon tax for trading scheme

July 14, 2013

Key greenhouse gas emitter Australia on Sunday announced it will scrap its carbon tax in favour of an emissions trading scheme that puts a limit on pollution from 2014, a year earlier than planned.

Recommended for you

Diamonds show Earth still capable of 'superhot' surprises

September 22, 2017

Diamonds may be 'forever,' but some may have formed more recently than geologists thought. A study of 26 diamonds, formed under extreme melting conditions in the Earth's mantle, found two populations, one of which has geologically ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.7 / 5 (3) Jul 10, 2014
Can I be the first to Congratulate the folks down under for using your great wisdom to do the right thing.

4.2 / 5 (5) Jul 10, 2014
Can I be the first to Congratulate the folks down under for using your great wisdom to do the right thing.

Your congratulations are premature. It's a polluter that wants a minor change in the repeal and he his going to get it. The repeal will happen soon. It will take an election with a new ruling party to re-instate a carbon tax.
5 / 5 (2) Jul 14, 2014
Well to be honest, I've always thought that it was time for the US congress to implement a carbon tax and a carbon exchange system. A carbon tax that goes into the transportation fund might not be a bad idea.
1 / 5 (1) Jul 14, 2014
It will take an election with a new ruling party to re-instate a carbon tax.

Not likely. It would be political suicide to propose a "great big new tax". The majority of Australians value their "standard of living" and not the health of the greater external environment.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.