Human rights report card released

April 28, 2014 by Glynis Smalley, Monash University

Real freedom, gender-based violence, terrorism laws, and asylum seekers' rights are all considered in a report released today on vital human rights issues in Australia and around the world.

The 2014 Castan Human Rights Report, by Monash University's Castan Centre for Human Rights Law, highlights the Centre's research and its relevance to some of the most important human rights issues facing society.

A key finding of the report is that freedom in Australia is being undermined.

Director of the Castan Centre Professor Sarah Joseph said the recent narrow debate on the "right to be a bigot" had camouflaged the real effects of changes to legislation.

"The 'bikie laws', police move-on powers, copyright laws, and even threats to remove government funding from artists are all reducing society's freedom," Professor Joseph said.

Senior law lecturer Dr Heli Askola said that the recent spate of cases of domestic violence shows that the existing laws are not going far enough to protect the most vulnerable in our society.

"Australia's 'National Plan to Reduce Violence against Women' has the potential to create change, however it must be backed up with sufficient funding and better implementation," Dr Askola said.

Current terrorism laws in Australia also need closer consideration, according to the Centre's Dr Patrick Emerton.

"ASIO's excessive powers to make 'predictive judgments' about potential terrorists – such as 'adverse assessments' of bona fide refugees – threaten human rights," Dr Emerton said.

"For this reason ASIO's powers must be brought into line with human rights norms."

The report takes up the issue of ' rights.

Dr Azadeh Dastyari has identified at least seven international laws breached by current asylum seeker and refugee policies and practices.

"Contrary to theAustralian government's oft-repeated assertion that it respects asylum seekers' rights, the current situation doesn't reflect this," Dr Dastyari said.

"Asylum seekers cannot have their detention reviewed by the courts. Conditions on Nauru and Manus Island breach the prohibition on cruel or degrading treatment and the detention of children on Nauru breaches Australia's international obligations to act in the best interests of the child.

"By treating those arriving by boat differently to other asylum seekers, Australia is violating its obligation not to punish refugees for their mode of arrival."

Dr Dastyari said that in addition to these violations, practices such as push-backs to Indonesia and the removal of legal aid increased the chances that genuine refugees would be returned to harm and were in clear violation of Australia's non-refoulement obligations.

The inaugural report provides in-depth analysis and commentary on a range of other crucial human rights issues including a better asylum seeker model; Australia's growing prison crisis; LGBTI rights; foreign aid; business and human rights; in closed environments; and reproductive rights.

Explore further: Explainer: The legal implications of 'tow-backs'

More information: The full report is available online: … ghts-report-2014.pdf

Related Stories

Explainer: The legal implications of 'tow-backs'

January 20, 2014

Australia has been engaging in "tow-backs" of asylum-seeker boats. This has involved intercepting boats carrying asylum seekers at sea, before they reach Australia, and forcing them to return to Indonesia.

Call to free vulnerable from offshore detention

December 10, 2012

(Medical Xpress)—High rates of self-harm and mental distress among asylum seekers in long-term detention has renewed calls for the review of Australia's offshore processing.

A rare insight into human kindness

February 18, 2014

Lucy Fiske was at a conference in Jakarta about a year ago when she met a young woman on her way to Bogor on the Indonesian island of Java. With other Indonesians, the woman planned to act as a human shield for refugees who ...

Recommended for you


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Apr 28, 2014

These may be worthy left wing issues but violations of "human rights norms" they are not.

For Professor Sarah Joseph to talk about "threats to remove government funding from artists" reducing "freedom" is a joke--the Director of the Castan Centre may not know this but "government funding" is the other side of taxation.

To slight of mouth, "rights" with left wing politics risks the welfare of people whose only protection are their internationally recognized human rights.
not rated yet Apr 28, 2014
Real freedom, gender-based violence, terrorism laws, and asylum seekers' rights...

Real freedom? As opposed to unreal freedom? Sounds like newspeak...and yes this study is extremely political and extremely left leaning. So from THAT perspective and that perspective alone it's a good read.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.