Simulations re-create X-rays emerging from the neighborhood of black holes

February 18, 2014 by Aaron Dubrow, National Science Foundation
Animations of supercomputer data take you to the inner zone of the accretion disk of a black hole.

Black holes may be dark, but the areas around them definitely are not. These dense, spinning behemoths twist up gas and matter just outside their event horizon, and generate heat and energy that gets radiated, in part, as light. And when black holes merge, they produce a bright intergalactic burst that may act as a beacon for their collision.

Astrophysicists became deeply interested in black holes in the 1960s, but the idea of their was first intimated in a paper by Karl Schwarzschild published after Einstein introduced general relativity in 1915.

Knowledge about black holes—these still-unseen objects—has grown tremendously in recent years. Part of this growth comes from researchers' ability to use detailed numerical models and powerful supercomputers to simulate the complex dynamics near a black hole. This is no trivial matter. Warped spacetime, pressure, ionizing radiation, magnetized plasma—the list of phenomena that must be included in an accurate simulation goes on and on.

"It's not something that you want to do with a paper and pencil," said Scott Noble, an astrophysicist at the Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT).

Working with Jeremy Schnittman of Goddard Space Flight Center and Julian Krolik of Johns Hopkins University, Noble and his colleagues created a new tool that predicts the light that an accreting black hole would produce. They did so by modeling how photons hit gas particles in the disk around the black hole (also known as an accretion disk), generating light—specifically light in the X-ray spectrum—and producing signals detected with today's most powerful telescopes.

In their June 2013 paper in the Astrophysical Journal, the researchers presented the results of a new global radiation transport code coupled to a relativistic simulation of an accreting, non-rotating black hole. For the first time, they were able to re-create and explain nearly all the components seen in the X-ray spectra of stellar-mass black holes.

The ability to generate realistic light signals from a black hole simulation is a first and brings with it the possibility of explaining a whole host of observations taken with multiple X-ray satellites during the past 40 years.

"We felt excited and also incredibly lucky, like we'd turned up ten heads in a row," Noble said. "The simulations are very challenging and if you don't get it just right, it won't give you an accurate answer. This was the first time that people have put all of the pieces together from first principles in such a thorough way."

The simulations are the combined results of two computational codes. One, Harm3d, re-creates the three-dimensional dynamics of a black hole accreting gas, including its magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), which charts the interplay of electrically conducting fluids like plasmas and a powerful .

"The magnetic field is important in the area outside the black hole because it whips the gas around and can dictate its dynamics," Noble said. "Also, the movement of the field can lead to it kinking and trigger a reconnection event that produces an explosive burst of energy, turning magnetic field energy into heat."

Though the MHD forces are critical near the black hole, it is the X-rays these forces generate that can be observed. The second component, a radiative transport code called Pandurata, simulates what real photons do.

"They bounce around inside the gas, they reflect off the disk's surface, and their wavelengths change along the way," he explained. "Eventually, they reach some distant light collector—a numerically approximated observer—which provides the predicted light output of our simulation."

The researchers' simulations were run on the Ranger supercomputer at the Texas Advanced Computing Center, built with support from the National Science Foundation, which also funded the group's research.

The simulations were the highest resolution thin disk simulations ever performed, with the most points and the smallest length-scales for numerical cells, allowing the researchers to resolve very small features. Varying only the rate at which the black holes accrete gas, they were able to reproduce the wide range of X-ray states seen in observations of most galactic black hole sources.

With each passing year, the significance of black holes—and their role in shaping the cosmos—grows.

Nearly every good-sized galaxy has a at its center, said Julian Krolik, a professor of physics and astronomy at Johns Hopkins University. For periods of a few to tens of million years at a time, black holes accrete incredible amounts of gas ultimately released as huge amounts of energy—as much as a hundred times the power output of all the stars in a black hole host galaxy put together.

"Some of that energy can travel out into their surrounding galaxies as ionizing light or fast-moving jets of ionized gas," Krolik continued. "As a result, so much heat can be deposited in the gas orbiting around in those galaxies that it dramatically alters the way they make new stars. It's widely thought that processes like this are largely responsible for regulating how many stars big galaxies hold."

In this way black holes may act as cosmic regulators—all the more reason to use numerical simulations to uncover further clues about how black holes interact with gas, stars and other supermassive .

Said Noble: "To see that it works and reproduces the observational data when the observational data is so's really remarkable."

Explore further: Black hole that doesn't emit x-rays discovered near massive star

More information: "X-Ray Spectra from Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Accreting Black Holes." Jeremy D. Schnittman, Julian H. Krolik, Scott C. Noble. 2013 ApJ 769 156. DOI: 10.1088/0004-637X/769/2/156

Related Stories

How fast do black holes spin?

February 14, 2014

There is nothing in the Universe more awe inspiring or mysterious than a black hole. Because of their massive gravity and ability to absorb even light, they defy our attempts to understand them. All their secrets hide behind ...

Black holes do not exist as we thought they did

February 14, 2014

On January 24, the journal Nature published an article entitled "There are no black holes." It doesn't take much to spark controversy in the world of physics... But what does this really mean? In a brief article published ...

Taking the pulse of a supermassive black hole

December 5, 2013

( —Rare heartbeat-like pulsations detected from a supermassive black hole may grant scientists better insight into these exotic objects, according to two University of Alabama astronomers who co-authored a recent ...

RX J1532.9+3021: Extreme power of black hole revealed

January 23, 2014

( —Astronomers have used NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory and a suite of other telescopes to reveal one of the most powerful black holes known. The black hole has created enormous structures in the hot gas surrounding ...

Recommended for you

Scientist proposes new definition of a planet

January 23, 2018

Pluto hogs the spotlight in the continuing scientific debate over what is and what is not a planet, but a less conspicuous argument rages on about the planetary status of massive objects outside our solar system. The dispute ...

Asteroid 2002 AJ129 to fly safely past Earth February 4

January 22, 2018

Asteroid 2002 AJ129 will make a close approach to Earth on Feb. 4, 2018 at 1:30 p.m. PST (4:30 p.m. EST / 21:30 UTC). At the time of closest approach, the asteroid will be no closer than 10 times the distance between Earth ...

A new bound on axions

January 22, 2018

An axion is a hypothetical elementary particle whose existence was postulated in order to explain why certain subatomic reactions appear to violate basic symmetry constraints, in particular symmetry in time. The 1980 Nobel ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.