Parental income now a strong predictor of student success

February 20, 2014 by Christina Pazzanese, Harvard University
A Harvard Graduate School of Education panel discussion on income inequality featured HGSE Professor Paul Reville (from left), Chicago Tribune columnist Clarence Page, and Martha Minow, dean of Harvard Law School. Credit: Rose Lincoln/Harvard Staff Photographer

The chasm between the rich and poor has distressed world leaders as both a moral failure and a growing threat to global economic and political stability. In a bold statement last fall, Pope Francis sharply criticized what he saw as the excesses of capitalism, while President Obama called the historic level of wealth disparity and lack of economic mobility in the United States "the defining challenge of our time."

Just as income trend lines for affluent and poor Americans have dramatically diverged over the last 40 years, so too have the educational achievement rates of their children. Today, residential segregation by income means that public schools with high rates of low-income students face spiraling challenges to prepare children for a workforce that demands high-level skills.

Research shows that while the correlation between parental education and child achievement has remained fairly stable since the 1960s, the relationship between parental income and child achievement has tightened, with income—rather than race—now a strong predictor of student success.

In "Restoring Opportunity: The Crisis of Inequality and the Challenge for American Education" (Harvard Education Press), Richard J. Murnane, Thompson Professor of Education and Society at Harvard Graduate School of Education (HGSE), and Greg J. Duncan, distinguished professor at the University of California, Irvine's School of Education, examine how income inequality affects students and schools.

The book focuses on three innovative institutions that have taken steps to counteract the achievement burdens that wealth disparity places on schools and students: a pre-K school in Boston, a high school in Brooklyn, and a University of Chicago charter school. All have high academic standards, provide substantial and ongoing support for students and teachers, and maintain common-sense systems of accountability. While unusual, the authors say, the philosophies and practices at these schools could serve as models for change at other schools with similar populations.

"It can be done. It is not impossible to educate even high concentrations of low-income children well," Murnane said Thursday evening during an Askwith Forum in HGSE's Longfellow Hall.

Duncan and Murnane spoke about their work and offered some strategic interventions they called "sensible accountability" that schools can adopt. The talk also featured a panel discussion with Martha Minow, Ed.M. '76, the Morgan and Helen Chu Dean and Professor at Harvard Law School; Clarence Page, a Pulitzer Prize-winning syndicated columnist for the Chicago Tribune; and Paul Reville, the Francis Keppel Professor of Practice of Educational Policy and Administration at HGSE and the former Massachusetts secretary of education.

Given the increasingly complex skills that students must master to succeed in today's workforce, Duncan and Murnane suggest, schools need to deliver better instruction and learning opportunities, and be rightfully held to higher achievement standards. But too often, teachers and school leaders are not getting the adequate training and support to make those goals a reality.

"At the very time that we're upping the ante on schools and what they have to do, we're creating conditions in those schools that make them harder and harder to teach those skills," Duncan said.

Numerous past efforts to address the inadequacies of many public schools, such as more per-pupil spending or the creation of charter schools, have failed to consistently slow the trends of the last few decades.

Just as average per-pupil spending in continues to vary widely among communities and states, so does the amount spent on student enrichment outside of school. In 1972-1973, wealthy parents spent $2,857 more per child than low-income parents to supplement learning; in 2005-2006, wealthy parents spent $7,993 more per child, according to the book.

While money and how it's spent matter, Minow noted, that's not enough. Research shows that rich and poor students spend equal time looking at computer screens, but their skills from that engagement are not equal, she said.

"The difference is not time on screens, the difference is access to adults and coaches, and are you in a community with other people who help you as you navigate, whether it's educational stuff or it's games or whatever," said Minow. "That's the difference, and that's reflected in those [parental] expenditures."

Minow and Page agreed that one major obstacle to implementing any new idea to improve education broadly is overcoming the public's disappointment with past reform efforts that simply haven't delivered on their promises.

"I think the danger is there's this constant effort in reform to find the magic bullet, the one thing that's going to fix things," Minow said, praising Duncan and Murnane's emphasis on "sustained intervention," not a quick fix. "Nothing is sustained; there's no long-term anything."

"The fact is that we're talking about some deeply rooted problems," Page said.

"Everybody wants better schools. There's a consensus nationally that we need to improve our schools, that we need to save education," he said. "There is also a universal disdain for paying for improving schools. However, if we show that change is possible, that change can happen, and can work," then he thinks we can find "consensus for change."

Explore further: Companies back fast Internet-in-schools initiative

More information: "Restoring Opportunity: The Crisis of Inequality and the Challenge for American Education." Greg J. Duncan. Publisher Harvard Education Press. Publication Date 2014-01-21. ISBN 9781612506340

Related Stories

Companies back fast Internet-in-schools initiative

February 2, 2014

The White House says it's lined up private support for President Barack Obama's pledge to connect 15,000 schools and 20 million students with high-speed Internet service over the next few years.

Urban schools improving faster than rest of US

December 18, 2013

Federal testing data shows that public school students in the nation's largest cities are improving their performance in reading and math faster than their counterparts in suburban and rural schools.

Recommended for you

New ancestor of modern sea turtles found in Alabama

April 18, 2018

A sea turtle discovered in Alabama is a new species from the Late Cretaceous epoch, according to a study published April 18, 2018 in the open-access journal PLOS ONE by Drew Gentry from the University of Alabama at Birmingham, ...

New study improves 'crowd wisdom' estimates

April 18, 2018

In 1907, a statistician named Francis Galton recorded the entries from a weight-judging competition as people guessed the weight of an ox. Galton analyzed hundreds of estimates and found that while individual guesses varied ...

Team discovers mysterious head of a pharaoh

April 17, 2018

Swansea University Egyptology lecturer Dr Ken Griffin has found a depiction of one of the most famous pharaoh's in history Hatshepsut (one of only a handful of female pharaohs) on an object in the Egypt Centre stores, which ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Feb 20, 2014
Amazingly coincidental; just yesterday I heard a local lame newsreader contradict this precise point. So precisely that I have to think she misunderstood this very reported article.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.