Climate change's longer growing season won't mean more carbon capture

February 25, 2014 by Stephen Chaplin
A view of Morgan-Monroe State Forest in late March 2000, prior to spring leaf-out of the canopy. In 2012, mild spring temperatures caused the forest to green-up over two weeks earlier than any time over the past decade. Despite this, a severe water shortage during summer resulted in the lowest amount of annual tree growth in the past decade. Credit: Morgan-Monroe AmeriFlux Project

Forests may stay green longer due to global climate warming, but it doesn't mean those same forests will actually grow more. In fact, new research in two papers published by scientists at Indiana University finds that even though trees may keep their leaves on longer during warm years, how much they grow depends on how much rain they receive.

And with drier conditions predicted to become more common across much of the Midwest, the degree to which forests can store carbon and slow climate change will be reduced.

When taken together, the two papers published today in Global Change Biology argue that continental-scale satellite data that measures canopy greenness is not an accurate tool for estimating forest photosynthesis and, in turn, tree growth.

"One would expect that having green leaves for a longer period of time would lead to more photosynthesis and, as a result, more carbon available for wood growth every year," said Edward Brzostek, a postdoctoral fellow in the IU College of Arts and Sciences' Department of Biology and first author on one of the papers. "What we find is the exact opposite: Tree growth is declining due to growth ending earlier and earlier each year because the site has been getting drier and drier each year."

Using tree growth data from Morgan-Monroe State Forest in Indiana, coupled with regional data from the U.S. Forest Service, Brzostek was able to estimate the potential impacts of at a regional scale using the record of growth for about 300,000 trees representing dozens of species.

"Many of the tree species that we found to be most sensitive to water stress are actually the ones that are poised to become increasingly dominant over the next several decades," said Richard Phillips, assistant professor in the Department of Biology at IU and co-author on both studies. "Sugar maple and tulip trees represent the future forest for many regions around the Midwest as oak trees continue to decline, but these trees are not well-adapted to deal with and thus will take up much less carbon in a drier world."

Chronic water stress could potentially reduce the carbon sink of deciduous forests in the U.S. by as much as 17 percent in coming decades, leading to a decrease in carbon capture that translates to an additional one to three days of global carbon emissions from fossil fuel burning each year, according to the paper, "Chronic water stress reduces and the carbon sink of deciduous hardwood forests."

In a companion study—"An improved approach for remotely sensing water stress impacts on forest C uptake"—IU researchers reported a promising new method for detecting the impacts of water shortages on forest growth across large regions.

Using national satellite data and detailed site data from Morgan-Monroe and from the University of Missouri Baskett Wildlife Research area in the Ozark region of central Missouri, the team found that forest canopies do not change greenness—or "brown down" like a residential lawn would with drought—as photosynthesis declines.

A better barometer of what was happening within forests was information gathered from the patchwork of grasslands and that exist in and around the majority of forests, said Daniel A. Sims, first author on the paper and an IU College of Arts and Sciences' Department of Geography postdoctoral fellow.

"Those ecosystems—those adjacent grasslands and fields—do 'brown down' with drought, and we were able to show that we could better predict the impacts of drought on photosynthesis in forests if we used those agricultural fields as 'eco-meters,'" Sims said. "The browning down of agricultural fields was directly correlated with at both Morgan-Monroe and in Missouri."

Leveraging agricultural fields as eco-meters could aid researchers in better understanding the interaction between tree species and drought response, in turn providing tools for developing plans for how forests can be managed to become more drought resilient, they said.

"What's most important is that both studies highlight water as an important constraint on the ability of forests to remove carbon from the atmosphere," Brzostek said. "Leaves may be staying green longer with warmer temperatures, but if our future climate is warm and dry instead of warm and wet, it is unlikely that forests can continue to offset our fossil fuel emissions at the same rate."

Explore further: Biodiversity protects tropical rainforests from drought

More information: "Chronic water stress reduces tree growth and the carbon sink of deciduous hardwood forests." Brzostek ER, Dragoni D, Schmid HP, Rahman AF, Sims D, Wayson CA, Johnson DJ, Phillips RP. Glob Chang Biol. 2014 Jan 13. DOI: 10.1111/gcb.12528.

Related Stories

Two-pronged approach to boost forest carbon storage

October 21, 2013

More carbon will sometimes be stored in forests if a bigger variety of tree species is planted along with key species - such as nitrogen fixing trees - that are known to contribute strongly to carbon storage, according to ...

Explainer: How much carbon can the world's forests absorb?

June 12, 2013

You are walking through the bush when you see an enormous tree trunk, tens of metres long, lying across the forest floor. Imagine you and several dozen friends lifting it by hand. Now you've literally grasped the significance ...

Forest model predicts canopy competition

February 20, 2014

Out of an effort to account for what seemed in airborne images to be unusually large tree growth in a Hawaiian forest, scientists at Brown University and the Carnegie Institution for Science have developed a new mathematical ...

Recommended for you

Mysterious deep-Earth seismic signature explained

November 22, 2017

New research on oxygen and iron chemistry under the extreme conditions found deep inside the Earth could explain a longstanding seismic mystery called ultralow velocity zones. Published in Nature, the findings could have ...

Scientists dispute missing dryland forests

November 21, 2017

Scientists are disputing the possibility that a significant portion of the world's forests have been missed in an earlier accounting of ecological diversity.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (6) Feb 25, 2014
I wonder where did they dust off this thesis that [life is] "not adaptable". Did they fail their undergraduate biology class?
5 / 5 (5) Feb 25, 2014
Obviously you don't understand the article. The trees are adapting but they are not capturing as much carbon. Not a healthy environment for them nor for us.
5 / 5 (5) Feb 25, 2014
Hard to adapt when you're dead! And it doesn't even say "not adaptable" it says "aren't adapted to" but could just have easily have said "can't adapt fast enough".

That's the problem with posting misrepresentations all the time TegiriNenashi - you usually get caught, and your credibility goes down each time you do. Its also why denialists are becoming less and less believable.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.