The ties that bind: Recreating Darwinian ligand evolution in vitro

January 24, 2014 by Stuart Mason Dambrot feature
Schematic of the AEGIS cell–SELEX used here. A GACTZP DNA library, consisting of randomized sequences and primer sites, was first incubated with the target cells. Unbound sequences were then removed by washing. Bound sequences having affinity to the target cells were collected. “Survivors” in the enriched collection were amplified using a FITC-labeled 5´-primer and a biotinylated 3´-primer by GACTZP six-nucleotide PCR (22). Enriched FITC-conjugated single-stranded DNA obtained from PCR products was used for the next round of selection. The binding affinity of survivors from 9th round up to 12th round of selection was monitored by flow cytometer. The survivors from 12th round selection were subjected to deep sequencing. Credit: Copyright © PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1311778111

( —A key feature of certain chemicals is their ability to bind to other molecules – a property that emerged through evolution – but current chemical theory lacks the ability to design binders from first principles. To resolve this dilemma, scientists at the University of Florida and the Foundation for Applied Molecular Evolution have recreated these Darwinian processes in vitro (that is, in the laboratory). Their approach extracts nucleic acids as binders from DNA/RNA libraries to evolve through a process called Systematic Evolution of Ligands by Exponential Enrichment, or SELEX. (A ligand is a substance, usually a small molecule, that forms a complex with a biomolecule to serve a biological purpose,) However, natural DNA/RNA has only four nucleotides as building blocks, and so often yields poor binding molecules. By integrating synthetic biology, sequencing tools, and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification, and additional DNA/RNA building blocks from an Artificially Expanded Genetic Information Systems (AEGIS), the scientists successfully demonstrated the first example of SELEX using AEGIS, producing a molecule that binds to cancer cells.

Prof. Steven A. Benner discussed the paper that he, Dr. Kwame Sefah and their co-authors published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences – starting with the main challenges they faced. One such challenge was overcoming the limitation of chemical theory by directly designing binders through in vitro recreation of the Darwinian processes that nature uses to molecular binders. "Current chemical theory is quite able to do broad brush design," Benner tells Indeed, Benner notes, the scientists used current chemical theory to design the additional nucleotides in their AEGIS technology. "However," he continues, "both at the highest level of quantum mechanics as well as the more practical level of molecular dynamics, the assumptions in models of reality are not good enough to allow energy output to be accurate to better than, say, 5 kcal per mole – the difference between success and failure in, as an example, a pharmaceutical."

Conversely, Benner adds, while Darwinism is incapable of doing what he calls big design, it is capable of fine tuning. The whole idea behind this strategy, he explains, is to construct by coarse design a system that is better able to support Darwinism and the laboratory environment. "This publication," he points out, "represents the first case in which this combination has been fully successful." (Benner notes that development of this technology was funded by the Defense Threat Reduction Agency, which consolidates a variety of US Defense Department functions to deal more effectively with the threats posed by nuclear, chemical, or biological weapons.)

A second challenge, says Benner, was demonstrating the first example of SELEX using AEGIS to produce a molecule that binds to cancer cells. "Molecular biological and genetic engineering tools, which have advanced so far over the past half-century, and which have led to several Nobel Prizes, have been advanced for use with natural genetic systems, not our artificially expanded systems. Therefore, we needed to develop analogous molecular biological tools for AEGIS. These included tools to manufacturer the AEGIS components, chemistry to synthesize AEGIS oligonucleotides, enzymes to do AEGIS PCR amplification, procedures to sequence AEGIS DNA, and so on." Incremental research and improvements in technology have allowed AEGIS DNA to be manipulated almost the same level as natural DNA is by classical molecular biology.

To address these challenges, the scientists had to develop chemical pipelines to synthesize AEGIS components on multi-gram scales; develop DNA and RNA polymerase to make DNA and RNA that contain AEGIS components; and create tools to restrict decomposition of DNA containing AEGIS components.

Benner points out that because SELEX, as originally proposed by Larry Gold two decades ago, follows a simple recipe, their findings could possibly generate receptors, ligands, and catalysts having sequence diversities nearer to that displayed by proteins. Specifically, that recipe entails:

1. Synthesizing a library of xNA (xeno-nucleic acid, or synthetic DNA) molecules, typically containing 1011-1014 members.

2. Placing the library in contact with the target in order to separate molecules in the library that bind to the target from molecules that do not. (To select catalysts, xNA libraries are put in an environment where an ability to catalyze a reaction separates them from xNA molecules that cannot.)

3. Survivors are enriched in a pool of xNA molecules that bind to the target (or catalyze a reaction), and then amplified in a (PCR).

4. After a sufficient number of rounds of selection, individual aptamers (oligonucleic acid or peptide molecules that bind to a specific target molecule) are recovered, sequenced, re-synthesized and characterized as molecular species having defined molecular structures.

"As with many new technologies," Benner explains, "SELEX was initially regarded as having high potential, and aptamers were hoped to eventually rival antibodies as binders. This potential has been fulfilled in part. xNA aptamers are known for many targets, including carbohydrates, small molecules, and peptides." In fact, he adds, some aptamers have already entered the clinic – although only after extensive modification of the aptamers originally selected.

"However, as SELEX evolved as a field," Benner continues, "it became clear that the binding diversity and catalytic power of xNA aptamers built from standard nucleotides (G, A, C, and T/U) were not able to match the diversity and power of proteins, including antibodies. At the same time, targets for the best aptamers had a natural propensity to bind to xNA, yielding aptamers with nanomolar dissociation constants." Dissociation constants are a specific type of equilibrium constant that measure the propensity of a larger object to reversibly separate, or dissociate, into smaller components. Ligands having nanomolar (nM) dissociation constants bind more tightly to a particular protein than those with micromolar (μM) dissociation constants. (A molar is a measure of amount-of-substance concentration.)

"For example, Benner illustrates, "aptamers selected to bind to nucleocapsid proteins, reverse transcriptase and HIV integrase had affinities of 2 nM, 0.3-20 nM, and 10-800 nM, respectively. In contrast, aptamers against small molecules were generally selected to have poorer affinities in the micromolar range. For example, dissociation constant values reported for aptamers selected to bind citrulline and arginine ranged from 0.3 to 65 μM, while the values for specific aptamers that bind ATP and xanthine were only 3.3 and 6 μM, respectively."

Benner point out that similar disappointment was also the rule for xNAzymes (xNA molecules that catalyze a preselected reaction). "While many xNAzymes have been reported, the best again performed well only for reactions of nucleic acids themselves, including phosphate hydrolysis, transesterification (the process of exchanging the organic group R″ of an ester with the organic group R′ of an alcohol), xNA ligation, and xNA polymerization. Even here, however, the rates of reactions were not impressive, and certainly not impressive when compared to natural enzymes that have evolved over millions of years to catalyze a specific reaction." He adds that they also did not perform orders of magnitude better than designed protein catalysts or antibody-based catalysts.

"In retrospect," Benner points out, "we might have expected xNA aptamers to not perform as well as proteins, since the latter are built from 20 different units and carry a wide range of chemical functionalities." These include positively-charged nitrogens (on lysine and arginine), anionic groups (aspartate and glutamate), hydrophobic groups (valine, leucine and others), polarizable groups (such as the tryptophan indole and the methionine thioether), catalytic units (including histidine), and metal coordinating groups (cysteine and histidine). In contrast, he adds, standard xNA nucleotides carry little of this functionality.

"Accordingly," Benner continues, "the Benner group and others added functionality to the four standard nucleotides in an attempt to get better performing xNA molecules – and this too has had some success." Examples include:

  • Prof. David Perrin and his coworkers1 made DNA where each of the four standard xNA building blocks (GACT) carried a different functional group; applying these to select for DNA catalysts, they saw an improvement in the catalytic power of the emerging DNAzymes (DNA molecules that have the ability to perform a chemical reaction, such as catalytic action)
  • SomaLogic modifies the 5-position of pyrimidines with benzyl, naphthyl, tryptamino, and isobutyl groups, inter alia, generating SOMAmers (Slow Off-rate Modified Aptamers); the company reports a set of these that detect ∼800 different human proteins in blood volumes as small as 15 microliters (μL), with affinities in the 0.1 picomolars (pM) - 1 μM range

Benner also tells that AEGIS–SELEX would be improved by the following investigations being developed in their laboratories:

  • Strains of E. coli cells that can propagate plasmids containing GACTZP DNA (a form of xNA), which he notes is the core of their current activities
  • A technology for directly sequencing single molecule Z:P pairs
  • Polymerases with still higher levels of fidelity and efficiency

Moving forward, Benner tells, the scientists are developing E. coli strains that can propagate plasmids containing GACTZP DNA, and are improving sequencing. "We also hope to also develop the chemistry and enzymology of the xNA S:B pair, as well as the xNA K:X and V:J pairs, in this order."

Benner notes that there are other areas of research that might benefit from their study. "Nearly everything in medicine involves the binding of molecules to other molecules," he tells "This is true in the research laboratory, in clinical diagnostics, and even within patients. Medicine needs drugs that bind to therapeutic targets to cure diseases; diagnostics needs molecules that bind to markers to indicate the presence of the diseased state; and researchers need molecules that bind to functional molecules to track their movement within cells." For this reason, he says, binding to and between targets is key to essentially all work done under the auspices of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), even when that binding is not the explicit focus of that work.

"Accordingly," Benner concludes, "biomedical researchers, diagnosticians and clinicians have long sought a technology that delivers binding molecules and catalysts on demand. In this vision, the technology would deliver binders quickly, reliably and inexpensively, to any researcher who has in hand some of the target. AEGIS-SELEX will be, we hope, this technology."

Explore further: A tighter fit with artificial DNA

More information: In vitro selection with artificial expanded genetic information systems, PNAS Published online before print December 30, 2013, doi:10.1073/pnas.1311778111

1Toward the Combinatorial Selection of Chemically Modified DNAzyme RNase A Mimics Active Against all-RNA Substrates, ACS Combinatorial Science 2013 15 (4), 174-182, doi:10.1021/co3001378

Related Stories

A tighter fit with artificial DNA

July 19, 2013

An artificial base that enhances the protein-binding affinity and selectivity of DNA expands the DNA machinery.DNA aptamers are expected to play an important role in the diagnosis and treatment of various cancers and other ...

Enzymes allow DNA to swap information with exotic molecules

March 21, 2013

( —The discovery of the Rosetta Stone resolved a longstanding puzzle, permitting the translation of Egyptian hieroglyphs into Ancient Greek. John Chaput, a researcher at Arizona State University's Biodesign Institute ...

Engineers synthesize antibodies with carbon nanotubes

November 25, 2013

MIT chemical engineers have developed a novel way to generate nanoparticles that can recognize specific molecules, opening up a new approach to building durable sensors for many different compounds, among other applications.

DNA catalysts do the work of protein enzymes

March 19, 2013

( —Illinois chemists have used DNA to do a protein's job, creating opportunities for DNA to find work in more areas of biology, chemistry and medicine than ever before.

Recommended for you

Researchers find means by which mushrooms glow

April 27, 2017

(—A team of researchers from Russia, Brazil and Japan has uncovered the means by which two kinds of mushrooms glow in the dark. In their paper published on the open-access site Science Advances, the group describes ...

Barley genome sequenced

April 26, 2017

Looking for a better beer or single malt Scotch whiskey? A team of researchers at the University of California, Riverside may have you covered. They are among a group of 77 scientists worldwide who have sequenced the complete ...

New Zealand fish and chips hold human DNA clues

April 26, 2017

Before you pop that piece of battered fish in your mouth, be aware it might just hold the key to understanding the origins of a form of DNA memory critical to human development.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Jan 25, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
Jan 25, 2014
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
5 / 5 (3) Jan 26, 2014
Instead of simply criticizing the article, why not enlighten us to the truth?

I would be interested to read about the way things really are. Please give references.

Captain Stumpy
5 / 5 (2) Jan 28, 2014
Such bogus science and claims

references or PROOF of validity of this claim?
First there is no proof of evolution

references or links proving THIS claim?
nice of you to show us how you feel, but now do some homework and show some science instead of making baseless claims and down-voting with no science to support your position

if you go to this link


you will see more than 300 references that support evolution
feel free to dispute any one of them
i would link more, but i figure that 300 links should keep you busy reading for a while
then you can come back and try to refute the article
5 / 5 (2) Jan 28, 2014
300 references that support evolution

300? Googling "evolution evidence" yields 129 million results!


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.