Grey squirrels stop garden birds using feeders

January 20, 2014 by Tamera Jones, PlanetEarth Online
Grey squirrels stop garden birds using feeders
Grey squirrel.

The presence of grey squirrels at standard, hanging bird feeders cuts the number of birds visiting them by a huge 98 per cent, the latest study reveals.

So, if you're one of the third of households that provides food for birds during the winter, scientists suggest opting for squirrel-proof feeders, rather than standard models.

'We've clearly demonstrated that grey squirrels will affect garden birds' use of a feeder,' says Dr Karl Evans of the University of Sheffield, who oversaw the study, published in Ibis.

'Whether or not these findings have a long-term impact on common garden birds will depend on how quickly they can find an alternative food source. The effect will be most keenly felt by birds in areas that support lots of grey squirrels and that don't have many feeders,' he adds.

Evans and colleagues from the University of Sheffield presented garden birds in the city with three different bird feeders during November and December 2011.

One was a normal feeder filled with sunflower seeds. Another was the same, but included a piece of grey card the same size as a squirrel stuck to it - the control. Finally, the test feeder included a normal bird feeder with a stuffed attached to it - the squirrel feeder.

'For the control feeder, we wanted to put something else on the feeder to show that birds were not simply reacting to an object on the feeder that blocked some of the feeding ports,' explains Evans.

Evans and colleagues found that in almost all cases, the most common garden birds, including blue tits, great tits and chaffinches, stopped using the squirrel feeder, but carried on using the others. The only bird not deterred from using the squirrel feeder was the feisty little European Robin.

When the scientists weighed the amount of food left in each of the feeders, they found a 97 per cent drop in the amount of seeds taken from the squirrel feeder compared with the normal feeder, suggesting birds rarely fed at the squirrel feeder.

In a separate experiment, the researchers spent a total of two and half hours watching garden birds' use of a feeder when real grey squirrels were present on the feeder. Again, they found the same results.

The study is the first to show that grey squirrels discourage birds from using feeders.

Previous research has also shown that normal bird feeders tend to attract squirrels, making the situation worse.

'We've also found that areas across Sheffield that have bird feeders are more likely to have grey ,' says Evans.

'Effects are perhaps likely to be greatest during the winter, when birds are energy-limited and must feed regularly during the shorter daylight period to sustain survival,' write the authors in their report.

The non-native grey squirrel is common in the UK, especially in urban places. Having also been introduced to northern Italy in 1948 and 1966, they're now common there, and scientists predict they'll spread to France by 2026 to 2031 and to Switzerland by 2031 to 2041.

Explore further: Technology tracks birds visiting feeders

More information: Colin Bonnington, Kevin J. Gaston, Karl L. Evans, Assessing the potential for Grey Squirrels Sciurus carolinensis to compete with birds at supplementary feeding stations, Ibis Volume 156, Issue 1, pages 220-226, January 2014, Article first published online: 27 NOV 2013, DOI: 10.1111/ibi.12107

Related Stories

Technology tracks birds visiting feeders

January 6, 2012

To study bird feeding and breeding behavior, ornithologists used to tag birds with colored bands and then painstakingly track the birds' activity. But now, an existing technology repurposed for tracking birds by researchers ...

Formby's red squirrel population recovering

November 18, 2013

A study by the University of Liverpool has found that the red squirrel population along the Sefton coastline seems to be recovering from a serious outbreak of squirrelpox in 2008.

Red Squirrels showing resistance to squirrelpox

November 26, 2013

A study by the University of Liverpool has found that the red squirrel population along the Sefton coastline appears to be recovering from a serious outbreak of squirrelpox in 2008.

Canadian homes a kill zone for up to 22 million birds a year

September 14, 2012

(Edmonton) The thud of a bird hitting a window is something many Canadian home owners experience. Up until now, little research has been done to document the significant these collisions for Canada's bird populations. A University ...

Mystery hummingbird's species identified

December 26, 2011

A mystery that puzzled Chicago-area birders was solved when Field Museum scientists identified the unusual hummingbird living in an Oak Park, Ill., yard as a member of the rufous species rarely seen in the Midwest.

Early bird catches the worm...for dinner

October 10, 2013

( —Birds, such as great and blue tits, scout for food in the morning but only return to eat it in late afternoon to maximise their chances of evading predators in the day without starving to death overnight, Oxford ...

Recommended for you

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Jan 20, 2014
Problem with the "squirrel-proof" feeders -- maybe they can't get inside the feeders, but they can, and do, climb or leap on them, hang off them with one paw, shake them, then swipe out the seeds. They'll also do nearly anything to get to a suet feeder!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.