New type of black-hole quasar discovered

November 8, 2013 by Barbara K. Kennedy, Pennsylvania State University

Illustration of another theory, showing the gas of a quasar rotating around a black hole. Credit: York University
( —Like our Milky Way, every known large galaxy has at its center a supermassive black hole, some of which are surrounded by a super-bright disk of hot gas called a quasar—but now a research team that includes Penn State astronomers has discovered a surprising new class of quasars in distant galaxies that even the most current theories had not predicted.

"The gas in this new type of quasar is moving in two directions: some is moving toward Earth but most of it is moving at high velocities away from us, possibly toward the quasar's black hole," said study co-author Niel Brandt, Distinguished Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics at Penn State University. "Just as you can use the Doppler shift for sound to tell if an airplane is moving away from you or toward you, we used the Doppler shift for light to tell whether the gas in these quasars is moving away from Earth or toward these distant , which have a mass from millions to billions of times that of the Sun." Brandt explained. Matter around these black holes forms a quasar disc that is bigger than Earth's orbit around the Sun and hotter than the surface of the Sun. These quasars generate enough light to be seen across the observable universe.

The international research team, led by Patrick Hall of York University in Toronto, Canada, discovered the unusual quasars with data from a large , the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS-III). "Matter falling into black holes may not sound surprising," says Hall, "but what we found is, in fact, quite mysterious and was not predicted by current theories." Such gas is found in only about 1 out of 10,000 quasars, and only seventeen cases now are known. This discovery is detailed in a peer-reviewed paper in this month's issue of the journal Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, published by Oxford University Press.

In addition to Brandt, the Penn State coauthors of this paper include Graduate Student Nurten Filiz Ak and Distinguished Professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics Donald Schneider, who also is the Survey Coordinator and Scientific Publication Coordinator for SDSS-III. The two specific research components of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey that were used to make this discovery are the SDSS Legacy survey and the SDSS-III Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey.

"The gas in the disc must eventually fall into the black hole to power the quasar, but what is often seen instead is gas blown away from the black hole by the heat and light of the quasar, heading toward us at velocities up to 20 per cent of the speed of light," Hall said. "If the gas is falling into the black hole, then we don't understand why it's so rare to see infalling gas. There's nothing else unusual about these quasars. If gas can be seen falling into them, why not in other quasars?"

Hall said there is one other possible explanation for these objects. "It could be that the gas moving away from us is not falling into the black hole but is orbiting around it, just above the disc of hot gas, and is very gradually being pushed away from the black hole. A wind like that will show gas moving both toward us and away from us. To make an analogy: imagine an ant on a spinning merry-go-round, crawling from the center to the edge. You will see the ant moving toward you about half the time and away from you about half the time. The same idea could apply to the gas in these quasars. In either case, the in these quasars is moving in an unusual fashion."

Models of quasars and their winds will have to be revised to account for these objects. To help understand what revision is needed, the research team is observing these further using Canadian and American access to the Gemini-North telescope in Hawaii.

Explore further: Quasar gas clouds: Gone, with the wind

More information: Paper: … t/434/1/222.abstract

Related Stories

Quasar gas clouds: Gone, with the wind

October 1, 2012

(—The case of the missing quasar gas clouds has been solved by a worldwide team of astronomers, and the answer is blowin' in the wind.

Recommended for you

InSight Mars lander takes its first selfie

December 12, 2018

NASA's InSight lander isn't camera-shy. The spacecraft used a camera on its robotic arm to take its first selfie—a mosaic made up of 11 images. This is the same imaging process used by NASA's Curiosity rover mission, in ...

Calibrating cosmic mile markers

December 11, 2018

New work from the Carnegie Supernova Project provides the best-yet calibrations for using type Ia supernovae to measure cosmic distances, which has implications for our understanding of how fast the universe is expanding ...

Team finds evidence for carbon-rich surface on Ceres

December 10, 2018

A team led by Southwest Research Institute has concluded that the surface of dwarf planet Ceres is rich in organic matter. Data from NASA's Dawn spacecraft indicate that Ceres's surface may contain several times the concentration ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (16) Nov 08, 2013
There's a very simple explanation.

The Quasar may not be producing enough light to make sufficient radiation pressure to over come it's own gravity.

If Gas is falling directly into the black hole, instead of gradually in a decaying orbit, then the gas doesn't have as much time to heat up before it falls onto the Event Horizon, and therefore it doesn't produce as much radiation to push other gas away.

Some possible ways to explain this is that the galaxy was never "stable" and has been collapsing throughout it's history, which is to say the matter orbiting the BH doesn't have enough angular momentum so all orbits decay inward.

Another possibility is a past galaxy merger, perhaps with a counter-rotating galaxy, so that average angular momentum canceled, and gas falls directly inward instead of feeding the Quasar gradually.

In any case, the gist of the post is that the gas falls directly inward, thus not giving off as much radiation, therefore not accelerating other gas outward.
1 / 5 (12) Nov 08, 2013
Heyyy, some of you hold it with your 'ones'! Da lurker spent some time and put some thought and work into his post! That kind of galaxy could exist even if it does not strictly apply in this particular galaxy under study. Some slow degradation of all galaxies is plausible in the light of how chaotic their nature, so all galaxies face this kind of end someday. Call it galactic entropic progression.
1 / 5 (16) Nov 08, 2013
Rare uni-polar jet, oriented away from us? Unlikely strictly accretive structure.
1 / 5 (8) Nov 08, 2013
Remember when magnetar wasn't a thing? I suspect that this may be one of the first, if not the first, quasar-like object that isn't exactly a quasar. It would be to a quasar what a magnetar is to a pulsar.
5 / 5 (3) Nov 13, 2013
Dear Walters1: it's the discovery of 17 examples of a new type of quasar. And it's true that we expect both infall and outflow in quasars. But in optical/ultraviolet light we've only seen outflow up until now, and no one expected we'd see infall like this. So that's a new and puzzling finding, but you're quite right that it's not a fundamental shift in our picture of quasars. I tried to make that clear in the original press release by trying to pique curiosity without overdoing the hype. Thanks for reading!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.