An asteroid pile-up in the orbit of Mars

October 11, 2013, Armagh Observatory
The paths traced by all seven Martian Trojans around L4 or L5 (crosses) in a frame rotating with the average angular speed of Mars (red disk) around the Sun (yellow disk). A full revolution around the corresponding Lagrange point takes approximately 1,400 years to complete. The dotted circle indicates the average distance of Mars from the Sun.

The orbit of the planet Mars is host to the remains of an ancient collision that created many of its Trojan asteroids, a new study has concluded. It paints a new picture of how these objects came to be and may even hold important lessons for deflecting asteroids on a collision course with our own planet. The findings were presented at the annual Meeting of the Division for Planetary Sciences of the American Astronomical Society in Denver last week, by Dr. Apostolos Christou, a Research Astronomer at the Armagh Observatory in Northern Ireland, United Kingdom.

Trojan asteroids, or "Trojans," move in orbits with the same average distance from the Sun as a planet. This may seem as a precarious state to be in, as eventually the either hits the planets or is flung, by the planet's gravity, on an entirely different orbit.

But solar and planetary gravity combine in such a way as to create dynamical "safe havens" 60 degrees in front and behind the planet's orbital phase. The special significance of these, as well as three other similar locations in the so-called three-body problem, was worked out by

18th century French Mathematician Joseph-Louis Lagrange. In his honor, they are nowadays referred to as the Lagrange points. The point leading the planet is referred to as L4; that trailing the planet as L5.

Although not all Trojans are stable for long periods of time, almost 6,000 such objects have been found at the orbit of Jupiter and about 10 at Neptune's. Those are believed to date from the solar system's earliest times when the planets were not yet at their present orbits and the distribution of small bodies across the solar system was very different than observed today.

Of the inner , only Mars is known to have stable, long-lived, Trojan companions. The first, discovered back in 1990 near L5 and now named Eureka, was later joined by two more asteroids, 1998 VF31 also at L5 and 1999 UJ7 at L4. In the first decade of the 21st century, observations revealed them to be a few km across and compositionally diverse. A 2005 study led by Hans Scholl of the Observatoire de Cote d'Azur (Nice, France) demonstrated that all three objects persist as Mars Trojans for the age of the solar system, putting them on a par with

the Trojans of Jupiter. In that same decade, however, no new stable Trojans were discovered, which is curious if one considers the ever-improving sky coverage and sensitivity of asteroid surveys.

Christou decided to investigate. Sifting through the Minor Planet Center database of asteroids, he flagged six additional objects as potential Martian Trojans and simulated the evolution of their orbits in the computer for one hundred million years. He found that at least three of the new objects are also stable. He also confirmed the stability of an object originally looked at by Scholl et al., 2001 DH47, using a much better starting that was available at the time. The result: the size of the known population has now more than doubled, from 3 to 7.

But the story does not end there. All these Trojans, save one, are trailing Mars at its L5 Lagrange point [see Fig. 1 & left panel of Fig. 2]. What's more, the orbits of all but one of the six L5 Trojans group up around Eureka itself [see right panel of Fig. 2]. "It is not what one would expect by chance," Christou says. "There is some process responsible for the picture we see today."

Left (same as Figure 1): The paths traced by all seven Martian Trojans around L4 or L5 (crosses) in a frame rotating with the average angular speed of Mars (red disk) around the Sun (yellow disk). A full revolution around the corresponding Lagrange point takes approximately 1,400 years to complete. The dotted circle indicates the average distance of Mars from the Sun. Right: Detail of left panel (demarcated by the dashed rectangle) showing the motion, over 1,400 years, of the six L5 Trojans: 1998 VF31 (blue), Eureka (red), and the objects identified in the new work (amber). Note the latter's similarity to the path of Eureka. The disks indicate the estimated relative sizes of the asteroids.

One possibility put forward by Christou is that the original Martian

Trojans were several tens of km across, a great deal larger than those we see today. In that scenario, described in a paper published in the May 2013 issue of Icarus, a series of collisions kept breaking those up into ever smaller fragments.

This "Eureka cluster"—in reference to its largest member—is the result of the most recent collision. This hypothesis not only accounts for the observed distribution of orbits but also explains why the new objects are relatively small, some hundreds of meters across. As

Christou explains: "In the earlier collisions, km-sized objects would be among the smallest fragments produced and thus moving at tens to hundreds of meters per second, too fast to be retained as Trojans of Mars." In the event that formed the Eureka cluster, the energy of the

collision would only allow the sub-km fragments to fly apart at a meter per second or less, so not only do they stay on as Trojans but their orbits end up being quite similar as well.

Christou points out that, although there are alternative ways of making the Eureka cluster, collisions are generally accepted as being responsible for many other similar groupings or "families" of asteroids in the Main Belt, "so why not Martian Trojans as well? Collisions are like taxes; all asteroids must suffer them." He hopes that his findings will motivate the modelers to work out the plausible impact scenarios and the observers to look for telltale signs that the members known so far share a common origin.

Assuming the collisional hypothesis stands the test of time, we are left with the closest example yet of a collisionally derived group of asteroids still in their original locations. Christou predicts that further study of the cluster and Mars Trojans in general will tell us a great deal about how small asteroids behave when they collide with each other.

Scientists trying to simulate collisions of large—tens to hundreds of km across—asteroids in the Main Belt have a lot of data to compare their models against. This is not true for impacts on km-sized asteroids and their even smaller fragments; these are simply too faint to be efficiently picked up by surveys either now or in the near future.

Understanding what happens under these conditions is important if we ever hope to deal with asteroids in a collision course with the Earth.

Deflecting such an object might be a trickier job than first meets the eye. As Christou explains, "Setting off explosives in its vicinity to push it away from its predicted path may instead break it apart. This will turn it into a cosmic 'cluster bomb,' capable of causing widespread destruction across our planet."

Martian Trojans are just the right size to serve as guinea pigs for such brute-force deflection strategies. In fact, our knowledge of the population is about to increase significantly thanks to new facilities and initiatives. These include Canada's Near-Earth Object Surveillance

Satellite, Europe's Gaia sky-mapper, and the US's recently reactivated Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer satellites as well as the Panoramic Survey Telescope and Rapid Response System and Large Synoptic Survey Telescope ground-based surveys.

In concluding, Christou posits that "the future looks bright. Using the new data we should be able to determine what made these asteroids group up, even if the collisional model doesn't pan out in the end." For the time being, the work by Christou and the many others before him have

succeeded in highlighting the Martian Trojan regions as unique "natural laboratories," providing insight to evolutionary processes that even today are shaping our solar system's small body population.

Explore further: 'Trojan' asteroids in far reaches of solar system more common than previously thought

Related Stories

Asteroid found in gravitational 'dead zone'

August 12, 2010

There are places in space where the gravitational tug between a planet and the Sun balance out, allowing other smaller bodies to remain stable. These places are called Lagrangian points. So-called Trojan asteroids have been ...

WISE colors in unknowns on Jupiter asteroids

October 15, 2012

(—Scientists using data from NASA's Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer, or WISE, have uncovered new clues in the ongoing mystery of the Jovian Trojans—asteroids that orbit the sun on the same path as Jupiter. ...

Three centaurs follow Uranus through the solar system

June 18, 2013

Astrophysicists from the Complutense University of Madrid have confirmed that Crantor, a large asteroid with a diameter of 70 km has an orbit similar to that of Uranus and takes the same amount of time to orbit the Sun. Researchers ...

New horseshoe orbit Earth-companion asteroid discovered

April 6, 2011

( -- Apostolos Christou and David Asher from the Armagh Observatory in Northern Ireland announced the discovery of an asteroid near Earth called Asteroid 2010 SO16 and their findings were published on ...

Recommended for you

Three 'super-Earths' orbiting a cool dwarf star discovered

January 23, 2018

Using NASA's prolonged Kepler mission, known as K2, astronomers have found three new "super-Earth" exoplanets. The newly detected alien worlds orbit the cool dwarf star designated LP415-17. The finding is reported January ...

Scientist proposes new definition of a planet

January 23, 2018

Pluto hogs the spotlight in the continuing scientific debate over what is and what is not a planet, but a less conspicuous argument rages on about the planetary status of massive objects outside our solar system. The dispute ...

Dust storms linked to gas escape from Martian atmosphere

January 23, 2018

Some Mars experts are eager and optimistic for a dust storm this year to grow so grand it darkens skies around the entire Red Planet. This type of phenomenon in the environment of modern Mars could be examined as never before ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (16) Oct 11, 2013
Re: "Of the inner planets, only Mars is known to have stable, long-lived, Trojan companions."

That's a fascinating observation, for those who have seen the YouTube documentary, "Symbols of an Alien Sky" ...
2.1 / 5 (8) Oct 11, 2013
RE: "Of the inner planets, only Mars is known to have stable, long-lived, Trojan companions."

Asteroid 2010 TK7 orbits at the Earth-Sun L4 point. Even more interesting is 3753 Cruithne, which has a 'horseshoe' orbit that loops around the Earth-Sun L4 and L5 points alternately, roughly following the earth's orbit *behind* the sun in between its visits to the Lagrange points.
1 / 5 (2) Oct 11, 2013
Does this theory not contradict the theory of accretion? Or does the planet's own gravity somehow alter the equation?

1 / 5 (11) Oct 11, 2013

As far as I know, this does not contradict the theory of accretion. You are correct, the planets own gravity alters the equation.

My understanding is that lagrange points are gravitationally balanced points, where the force gravity from the sun, and the planet cancel out partially (by acting in mostly opposite directions), leading the material around the point to follow/lead the planet around the sun.

Here's a link to learn more: http://en.wikiped...an_point
1 / 5 (13) Oct 11, 2013
1999 an10
an asteroid that quite possibly may hit earth in 2027 with just a 'nudge' of less than
4000 gigajoules of energy----easily provided by a cluster of 10 or so EXISTING ion thrusters--the deep space dawn mission 1 asteroid was equipped with a 2100 watt continuous thrust----- over 7 years starting 2020. you could push an10 into earth with 10 of these or so.


1 / 5 (4) Oct 13, 2013
Perhaps Earth's big Moon (gradually receding) and Venus' proximity limit the long-term stability of Earth's Trojan zones ?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.