Under leaden skies: Where heavy metal clouds the stars

August 1, 2013
Artist's impression of the surface of HE2359-2844. The very high temperature (38000 degrees Celsius) makes the surface bluish in colour. An alien observer close to the star might be able to see the lead- and zirconium-rich cloud layers using specially chosen filters. Credit: Images created using POV-Ray by C. S. Jeffery

(Phys.org) —In a paper shortly to be published in the Oxford University Press journal Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, a team of astronomers from the Armagh Observatory in Northern Ireland report the discovery of two unusual stars with extremely high concentrations of lead in their atmospheres.

Naslim Neelamkodan, Simon Jeffery, Natalie Behara and Alan Hibbert are studying the surfaces of small hot stars, known as helium-rich subdwarfs. They are already known to be peculiar because they contain much less hydrogen and much more helium than normal.

Three years ago they discovered one with a very high surface concentration of zirconium - better known for making false diamonds. Now studying a group of similar stars, they have discovered two which have surfaces containing ten thousand (10,000) times more lead than is present on the surface of the Sun.

The discoveries were made in two stars, known as HE 2359-2844, 800 light years distant in the direction of the constellation of Sculptor and HE 1256-2738, located 1000 away in the of Hydra. The studied the stars using observations from the archives of the European Southern Observatory's Very Large Telescope in Chile.The light signatures, or spectra, of both stars showed a few features which did not match any atoms expected to be present. After some detective work, the team realised that the features were due to lead.

With atomic number 82, lead is one of the heaviest naturally occurring elements; in the Sun there is less than one lead atom for every ten billion . At around 38000 degrees Celsius, the surfaces of HE 2359-2844 and HE 1256-2738 are so hot that three electrons are removed from every lead atom. The resulting ions produce distinctive lines in the star's spectrum, from which the concentration of lead in the atmosphere can be measured. Using the same technique, HE 2359-2844 was also found to show ten thousand times more yttrium and zirconium than on the Sun. Along with the zirconium star, LS IV-14 116, these stars now form a new group of 'heavy metal subdwarfs'.

The team believes that these heavy-metal stars are a crucial link between bright red giants, stars thirty or forty times the size of the Sun, and faint blue subdwarfs, stars one fifth the size, but seven times hotter and seventy times brighter than the Sun. A few red giants lose their thick hydrogen skin and shrink to become hot subdwarfs, or nearly-naked helium stars. As they shrink, conditions become favourable for the pressure of light from the helium stars to act on individual atoms to sort the elements into separate layers, where they are concentrated by a factor of ten thousand or more.

Like water vapour in the earth's atmosphere, or layers of different density in a rainbow cocktail drink, a layer of heavy metal at just the right height and concentration can form clouds that become detectable from Earth. The team suggests that the new discoveries are rare examples of these layers coming into view and estimates that the lead layer could be about 100 km thick and weigh some 100 billion tonnes.

Naslim and co-workers will continue to search for evidence of other heavy metals forming cloud layers in these rare stars, and to look for more information about how light pressure sorts the chemistry of -rich subdwarfs over time. For such rare , it is still not certain how they form, and what they will eventually become.

Explore further: Stars shrouded in glittering zirconium light up the sky

More information: Neelamkodan, N. et al. Discovery of extremely lead-rich subdwarfs: does heavy metal signal the formation of subdwarf B stars? Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt1091

Related Stories

Stars shrouded in glittering zirconium light up the sky

December 8, 2010

Its been said that the Universe isn’t stranger than you can imagine, its stranger than you can’t imagine. Nowhere is this more true than the study of stars. Recently, a team of scientists from the Armagh Observatory ...

Astronomers gain new knowledge about early galaxies

July 3, 2013

The early galaxies of the universe were very different from today's galaxies. Using new detailed studies carried out with the ESO Very Large Telescope and the Hubble Space Telescope, researchers, including members from the ...

Young, hot and blue: Stars in the cluster NGC 2547

March 27, 2013

(Phys.org) —This pretty sprinkling of bright blue stars is the cluster NGC 2547, a group of recently formed stars in the southern constellation of Vela (The Sail). This image was taken using the Wide Field Imager on the ...

The earliest stars in the Universe

December 19, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Matter in the universe after the big bang consisted almost entirely of hydrogen and helium atoms. Only later, after undergoing fusion reactions in the nuclear furnaces of stars, did these light elements transform ...

Light from the darkness

January 16, 2013

(Phys.org)—An evocative new image from ESO shows a dark cloud where new stars are forming, along with a cluster of brilliant stars that have already emerged from their dusty stellar nursery. The new picture was taken with ...

Recommended for you

Astrophysicists discover dimming of binary star

January 16, 2017

A team of University of Notre Dame astrophysicists led by Peter Garnavich, professor of physics, has observed the unexplained fading of an interacting binary star, one of the first discoveries using the University's Sarah ...

Simulations suggest Planet Nine may have been a rogue

January 12, 2017

(Phys.org)—Space researchers James Vesper and Paul Mason with New Mexico State University have given a presentation at this year's American Astronomical Science meeting outlining the results of simulations they have been ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (8) Aug 01, 2013
Exactly a calm nova that allows the sun to stay whole while being layered in metals. And what if the excess metal were to coalesce into orbiting rocky bodies aka as planets?
not rated yet Aug 01, 2013
Sorry, but I just can't follow the math. You're saying that the star is 1/5 the size of our sun. You're saying that the cloud is visible, which to me means that it's not buried somewhere within the star itself. Given the size of the star, approximately 200,000 earths could fit within it. Given the estimate, the cloud weighs about 100 billion tons. The estimate also states that the cloud might be 100km thick. My best guess would put the weight of the cloud at MUCH more than the weight of the earth, even if it is mostly vapor. But the earth weighs more than the estimate by a long shot. What gives?
not rated yet Aug 01, 2013
OttJ: It isn't a "layer of lead", but a "layer of helium with some lead atoms in it". It doesn't take much lead in stellar gases to produce a distinct spectrographic signal. I'll admit that their description could use a little editing.
2 / 5 (4) Aug 02, 2013
Exactly a calm nova that allows the sun to stay whole while being layered in metals. And what if the excess metal were to coalesce into orbiting rocky bodies aka as planets?

A nova takes two stars, with one bleeding material to the other until it periodically has a brief nova. A single star exploding is a supernova, and it takes a much higher mass to do that. These are too small to supernova, so they never will. The material in them will stay locked inside them virtually forever. Keep in mind that they are still +90% helium, hydrogen, carbon, etc., with a little bit of heavy stuff mixed in. It's just a bit more than the usual amount of heavy stuff. 10,000 times a very small % is still a very small %.

As an example: The soil in your back yard may have 10,000 times more gold in it than the soil in my back yard. Neither of us would have enough to make a singel gold stud ear ring. This study is like trying to figure out why your yard has so much more gold than mine.
5 / 5 (2) Aug 03, 2013
Keep in mind that they are still +90% helium, hydrogen, carbon, etc., with a little bit of heavy stuff mixed in. It's just a bit more than the usual amount of heavy stuff. 10,000 times a very small % is still a very small %.

The figure for the Sun is 70 parts per trillion so 10,000 times more is still only 700 parts per billion.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.