Better power grid synchronization may enable smart grids to self-recover from failures

February 22, 2013 by Lisa Zyga, feature

The stability of a power grid in Northern Italy is enhanced by tuning certain generator parameters. (A) shows the response of the original network to an applied perturbation, and (b-d) show responses with tuned parameters. Credit: Adilson E. Motter, et al. ©2013 Macmillan Publishers Limited
(—Although the LHC has often been called the largest machine in the world, that title may be more appropriately given to something much more familiar: power grids. Consisting of thousands of generators and substations linked across thousands of miles, these networks form the backbone of society in developed countries. Yet most of the grids that power our modern economy are based on technology from the 1960s, even though power demands have changed dramatically since then. As a result of the additional strain, power grids have been failing more often, causing billions of dollars in business losses.

To combat these problems, researchers and power companies have been working on developing smart grids, in which the system's many components communicate among each other to improve the reliability and efficiency of . In terms of reliability, one of the biggest areas of research focuses on improving grid synchronization, so that every component that generates power oscillates at the same frequency (50 Hz in Europe; 60 Hz in the US). When one or more components become desynchronized, part or all of the grid loses its stability and can occur.

So far, most studies on grid synchronization have focused on the role of the grid's structure as a network consisting of nodes (the and subsystems that consume, produce, and distribute power) and links (the that transport power). Changes in the —such as adding or removing generators or transmission lines—can change the grid's synchronization and stability. But since changes in the grid's structure are mainly market-driven rather than theory-driven, it's often difficult to control the overall network design.

In a new study published in , researchers from Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois; Stanford University in California; and Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico have discovered that power grid synchronization depends on more than the network of transmission lines alone. They found that the leading factor for grid stability is not the network structure itself, which most previous studies have focused on, but the relation between the network structure, the state of the grid, and certain parameters of the generators.

The researchers showed that the stability of synchronized states in power grids can be enhanced by tuning generator parameters rather than modifying the entire network. As lead author Adilson Motter of Northwestern explained, this strategy works by quickly addressing any potentially damaging perturbations that arise in a stable grid.

"The rate at which small perturbations to the grid die out can be faster by a factor of 10 or more, according to our results," Motter told "Thus, the improvement can be substantial."

To identify which of the generators' parameters need to be tuned in order to achieve stability, the researchers mathematically derived a condition of the grid where grid synchronization is stable. They then used this condition to identify the important parameters, which involve inertia, damping, and regulation, allowing them to establish a "master stability condition" for the of power generators.

In the future, a smart grid could measure the state of the grid with high-speed sensors called phasor measurement units, and then communicate the data to an online control system that could adjust the parameters of the generators as necessary. In this way, smart grids could act as self-healing systems that can quickly recover from failures without human intervention, as well as help prevent failures from occurring in the first place.

The researchers hope that this finding that certain generator parameters can be tuned to enhance network stability will help guide the development of efficient controllers for smart grids and improve overall reliability. In addition to , the results could also have applications in other networks where the dynamical units (generators in this case) co-evolve with the structure. Examples include biological systems and other systems involving collective behavior.

Explore further: Power grid upgrades may cause blackouts, warns Braess's paradox

More information: Adilson E. Motter, et al. "Spontaneous synchrony in power-grid networks." Nature Physics. DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS2535

Journal reference: Nature Physics search and more info website


Related Stories

Smart software for self-regulating smart grid

May 24, 2011

Siemens and the utility company Allgauer Uberlandwerk (AUW) in the city of Kempten, Germany, are testing the smart grids of the future. The tests focus on optimized power distribution and the use of a self-organizing energy ...

Siemens makes US acquisition in smart grid sector

December 5, 2011

German engineering giant Siemens said Monday it has agreed to buy eMeter, a US-based data management specialist, in a bid to enhance its position in the field of so-called smart grids.

Solar and wind energy may stabilise the power grid

September 14, 2012

(—Renewable energies such as wind, sun and biogas are set to become increasingly important in generating electricity. If increasing numbers of wind turbines and photovoltaic systems feed electrical energy into ...

'Thinking machines' will run future power grids

October 13, 2011

( -- Plans to develop the "smart" grid - a system that uses intelligent computer networks to manage electric power - cannot succeed without the creation of new "thinking machines" that can learn and adapt to new ...

Recommended for you

Magic number colloidal clusters

December 14, 2018

Complexity in nature often results from self-assembly, and is considered particularly robust. Compact clusters of elemental particles can be shown to be of practical relevance, and are found in atomic nuclei, nanoparticles ...

Tangled magnetic fields power cosmic particle accelerators

December 13, 2018

Magnetic field lines tangled like spaghetti in a bowl might be behind the most powerful particle accelerators in the universe. That's the result of a new computational study by researchers from the Department of Energy's ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Feb 22, 2013
What if there were certain generators in the grid that could not be tuned, because of the way they operate and because of the way they have been made to operate by political decisions?

The article dances around the concept of "certain parameters" and avoids carefully to point out that what they're talking about is the phase angle which depends on the local balance between generation and load - the grid being locally stable when the two match and unstable when they don't.

And to tune this parameter, you basically need to increase or decrease the generator's output in a smarter way, except with generators like windmills this doens't happen because they've been deliberately made to push everything into the grid to collect the subsidies and not give a damn about the problems it causes.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.