No panaceas for Mexico's violent drug war, but prohibition has failed

January 15, 2013, Rice University

While Mexico and the United States have ramped up their efforts to control and perhaps defeat Mexico's increasingly violent drug cartels, the outcome of these efforts remains in doubt and no panaceas are in sight, but prohibition has once again proved to be a failure, according to a paper from Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy.

The paper by Rice William Martin, "Cartels, Corruption and Carnage in the Calderón Era," traces the origins and growth of Mexican drug cartels and the corruption, failed and gruesome violence that accompanied their rise. Martin is the Baker Institute's Harry and Hazel Chavanne Senior Fellow in Religion and Public Policy.

"An observer with deep ties and in both the United States and Mexico compared the conflict among the cartels and between the cartels and the government to a sporting event," Martin said. "Spectators in both the government and the public may keep score as individual contests are won or lost and as teams move up or down in the standings, but regardless of the treasure expended and the damage done, drugs will still be desired, provided and sold. And as long as societies and their governments treat as a crime rather than as a matter of public health, the deadly game will continue, season after season."

Martin's analysis places a special focus on efforts and developments during former Mexican President Felipe Calderón's term from December 2006 to November 2012. Despite Calderón's drawing on the force of the Mexican military, his war on the cartels appeared to have exacerbated the violence, Martin said.

To reverse course, Martin recommends that the work to shift from a of war to one of crime fighting and to reduce the role of the military while strengthening that of the police. "It must continue to build and reinforce professional civil service, law enforcement and judicial systems, from local to federal levels, with effective measures to prevent, identify, check, prosecute and punish corruption and violation of the rights of citizens," he said. "This will involve improvement in pay, higher educational requirements, vigilant screening and continuing reinforcement of appropriate values and attitudes. Obviously, this is a mammoth and daunting task. The United States can offer assistance, but most of this work will have to be done by Mexicans."

In addition, Martin said both countries must work to improve educational and employment opportunities so that young people in particular do not turn to drugs and crime because they have abandoned hope of achieving ameaningful life by legal means.

"Finally, both countries, in dialogue with other nations in the hemisphere, in Europe and elsewhere, should examine the drug policies and programs of other countries to consider viable alternatives to a policy of strict ," he said. "A growing number of countries have adopted such policies, either officially or de facto. Usage rates have generally remained stable, without an increase in problems popularly associated with the drugs in question. Equally notable, the quite high usage rates in the persist despite some of the harshest penalties in the world. Looking with an open mind at alternative systems should help dispel the fear that any change to current policies will lead to catastrophe."

Explore further: An altered state

More information: "Cartels, Corruption and Carnage in the Calderón Era" paper: … b-PolicyReport55.pdf

William Martin bio: … ows-scholars/wmartin

Related Stories

An altered state

April 19, 2010

Mexico's president Felipe Calderon has made a military campaign against the country's ascendant drug-trafficking gangs the centerpiece of his presidency. After thousands of fatalities, many of them due to retaliatory strikes ...

Mexican hacker group member freed by cartel: report

November 4, 2011

A Mexican member of online "hacktivist" group Anonymous was released by the Zetas drug cartel ahead of a threat by the Web group to expose details of the crime ring's activities, Mexican television reported Friday.

Recommended for you

Study sheds new light on ancient human-turkey relationship

January 17, 2018

For the first time, research has uncovered the origins of the earliest domestic turkeys in ancient Mexico. The study also suggests turkeys weren't only prized for their meat—with demand for the birds soaring with the Mayans ...

Lifting barriers to citizenship for low-income immigrants

January 15, 2018

Taking the Oath of Allegiance at a naturalization ceremony is an emotional moment for many immigrants, and for good reason: it is the culmination of an often arduous process and many years of striving. Citizenship also opens ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Jan 15, 2013
"turn to drugs and crime because they have abandoned hope of achieving a meaningful life by legal means".

I guess by this you mean the traffickers? Because "abandonment of hope" is NOT a significant reason why people use marijuana. Marijuana is significantly milder, safer and less addictive than alcohol and many people use it simply to avoid the harm that alcohol causes. And for this reason marijuana should be legalized like beer and wine.
1 / 5 (4) Jan 16, 2013
reports like this underline the need for even more enforcement of existing laws for dangerous narcotics like marijuana whose reign of terror can only be abated when more users are gaoled for their and society's own good - showing them the value of American freedom and justice - we need more prisons not some liberal solutions! there as Reagan once said, 'there is no more a dangerous drug than an idea'.
1 / 5 (4) Jan 16, 2013

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.