Troy Wolverton: iPhone 5 still comes up short compared to rivals

September 13, 2012 by Troy Wolverton

Apple's new iPhone 5 is a well-crafted device that's likely please the company's fans and sell in the tens of millions. But if you're looking for something truly innovative in a smartphone, look elsewhere.

Its are welcome updates to the iPhone line. But they are incremental improvements, and many were pioneered long ago on rival phones. And the new iPhone still lacks some features that have long been standard in others.

When it comes to new features, Apple seems to not only be playing a constant game of catch-up to such as Samsung and Nokia, but also falling farther and farther behind.

Compared with its predecessor, the iPhone 5 has a bigger screen, a faster processor and a thinner and taller body. It also has a new radio that will connect to the super-fast LTE and an aluminum - not glass - back that should be more durable.

Thanks to an update to iOS, the operating system that underlies the iPhone, the new device will offer users turn-by-turn and the ability to take panoramic photos from within its included camera application. It will also feature a new application called Passbook that will collect users' loyalty cards and event and travel tickets and let users post updates to Twitter and Facebook from within its notification center.

Call me jaded, but none of those features is terribly exciting. Android-based phones have sported screens as large as or larger than the new iPhone's for more than two years. Every new phone touts its speedy new processor. Free turn-by-turn directions has been a standard feature on Android phones for years, and some Android models have been LTE-powered for more than a year.

Apps within Apple's store already offered the ability to take panoramic photos, and that feature is already built into other devices. And while the Passbook app sounds useful, it also seems incomplete. Unlike other phones, you won't be able to use the new iPhone to board the bus or buy coffee by simply tapping it to a card reader, because it lacks an NFC chip, which makes such wireless transactions possible.

Apple says the new iPhone's battery will allow users to talk or Web-surf for 8 to 10 hours. That's more or less in line with previous iPhones, and what you'll get on Samsung's rival Galaxy S III. But it's pitiful compared with the battery life you get on one of Motorola's new Razr Maxx HD phone, which boasts 21 hours of talk time.

New phones from Samsung, Research in Motion and Nokia will all sport a new group photo feature that rapidly takes several images and automatically detects the faces within them. Users can then choose among several expressions for each person to get the best composite shot.

It's a neat feature and something that would seem a natural for the iPhone, given Apple's emphasis in recent years on the device's photo-taking capabilities. But you won't find it in the iPhone 5's native camera app.

Samsung's Galaxy line of phones has another cool feature that you won't find on the Phone 5 - the ability to beam files such as pictures and videos directly from one phone to another by just tapping the devices together.

To be sure, Apple, by not including such cutting-edge features, is simply going by its playbook. While the company has a reputation for being an innovator, its real genius has typically been to take innovations that are pioneered by others and find a way to redesign and market them so that they appeal to a mass audience.

And while the innovations that Apple is bringing to the iPhone 5 aren't new, they are new to iPhone users, notes Creative Strategies analyst Ben Bajarin. For consumers who wouldn't consider an Android or Windows Phone device, the new features in the will be much appreciated.

But it's not just at the cutting-edge where the iPhone is falling behind. It lacks other features that, simply put, should have been baked in a long time ago.

For example, the new iPhone still won't let you quickly change common settings, such as switching on the Wi-Fi or Bluetooth antennas. Years ago, Palm's Web OS devices let you change such settings by simply tapping on an icon in the notification bar atop the screen from within any application. On many Android devices, you can do the same by tapping buttons found by pulling down on their notification bars.

On the iPhone, you have to find its setting app and frequently dive down within its menus to find the appropriate button.

Likewise, Android devices have long allowed users to run small programs called widgets on their home screens to get information such as the weather, sports scores or stock quotes without having to launch a browser or a full-screen app. Apple actually helped pioneer widgets on its Mac computers, but for some reason still won't let you run them on the iPhone.

Maybe the new 's big new screen will help hide the ways it doesn't measure up to its rivals. But I'm guessing even Apple lovers will notice sooner or later.

Explore further: IPhone to get larger screen: A report to take with a grain of salt?

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News.


Related Stories

Samsung begins Europe sales of Galaxy S III smartphone

May 29, 2012

Samsung Electronics Co., the world's largest maker of mobile phones, said its third-generation Galaxy S smartphone went on sale Tuesday in 28 European and Middle Eastern countries, hoping to cement its lead over Apple's iPhone.

My offbeat wish list for the next iPhone

September 12, 2012

The flurry of rumors and reports surrounding Apple's upcoming iPhone launch have left little to the imagination about what Apple will actually announce Wednesday, but I'm still hoping for a few surprises.

Recommended for you

New method analyzes corn kernel characteristics

November 17, 2017

An ear of corn averages about 800 kernels. A traditional field method to estimate the number of kernels on the ear is to manually count the number of rows and multiply by the number of kernels in one length of the ear. With ...

Optically tunable microwave antennas for 5G applications

November 16, 2017

Multiband tunable antennas are a critical part of many communication and radar systems. New research by engineers at the University of Bristol has shown significant advances in antennas by using optically induced plasmas ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

4 / 5 (9) Sep 13, 2012
You're a brave man Mr. Wolverton. The mobs of iSlaves are amassing as we speak to surround your home, pitch forks and soon to be obsolete iPod chargers in hand. Unfortunately, until 5's release they will still use Google Maps to locate your house.

But be warned, those who speak unkindly of the iGods will face the fury of his loyal servants.
2.3 / 5 (3) Sep 13, 2012
This iSlave agrees with him. To be honest, I'm been a bit meh about all the phones come out this year. NFC sounds good but the infrastructure isn't available in Australia to my knowledge.

Widgets? I'm not sure what is supposed to be shown that is useful. A vague reference to volume? Weather? I'll grant stock prices or commodity values would be valuable to several industries.

Not really sure what innovations they could have done to impress me though. I would have been happy with ~ 10mm thick phone & a battery that lasts for 2 days. That would also allow for better focal length in a phone too.

But everyone is determined to manufacture thinner despite going wider. What is the attraction under 10mm? Weight makes sense but little else.
2.6 / 5 (5) Sep 13, 2012
NFC, as in near field communication? Android has supported this for a while now...
1 / 5 (1) Sep 13, 2012
Yes. It has been in Android (& WP?) for awhile. It would be nice to have in all smart phones, though I'd prefer an automated QR generation setup than an rfid system for financial transactions.

But to my knowledge the infrastructure isn't widely available here in Australia, so no grip there. I believe it is widely available in Eastern Asia & several 3rd world countries. The latter is probably because they are now updating their infrastructure.
2.3 / 5 (3) Sep 13, 2012
Ugh. Turns out that LTE is either voice or data. Switching between the two cuts the other off. WTF Apple!
5 / 5 (1) Sep 14, 2012
a tad sleeker and polished here and there but they didn't pull white rabbits out of the hat.

Fortunately that leaves apple many room for much more incremental upgrades (read: milking you) for the iphone6 with tech thats basically already there:

- an SD card expansion slot (DUH, but they don't seem to like user carrying files from/to the walled garden)
- The Mototrola 3200 Mha fat battery slab (surely the new iphone is allmost too thin, so a few millimeters extra for battery juice aint gonna hurt)
- Nokia Pureview like camera
- OPPO 1080p screen
- list goes on
3 / 5 (2) Sep 14, 2012
Y'know until I read this article I figured my old Android phone was way behind the curve in terms of abilities, but I've been using 4G and turn by turn directions for over a year now.

Of course the real advantage is there is only one Iphone.

All the other companies should stop putting out a dozen versions a month as it makes them seem unnecessarily puny vs a vs the Iphone, because media always compares one of their many phones to the only phone Apple puts out so that makes them look totally worthless in terms of appeal.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.