Microsoft hits Motorola, Google with EU complaint

February 22, 2012 By GABRIELE STEINHAUSER , AP Business Writer
Microsoft filed a complaint against Motorola Mobility with the European Commission on Wednesday, accusing it of seeking to block sales of Windows personal computers, Xbox game consoles and other products.

Microsoft on Wednesday lodged a formal complaint with the European Union's competition regulator against Motorola Mobility and its soon-to-be owner Google, saying Motorola's aggressive enforcement of patent rights against rivals breaks competition rules.

The complaint follows a similar step by Apple against Motorola last week.

Motorola is in the process of being taken over by Google for $12.5 billion, the biggest acquisition in the Californian company's history. Microsoft fears that Google will continue Motorola's tight hold on key patents.

Apple Inc. and Microsoft Corp. have been hit by legal cases in Europe and the United States, with Motorola claiming that the companies' products are using key patents it owns without permission.

Apple and Microsoft, meanwhile, argue that Motorola is overcharging for the use of these patents, which cover technologies necessary to connect wirelessly to the Internet or stream video online.

"We have taken this step because Motorola is attempting to block sales of Windows PCs, our Xbox game console and other products," Dave Heiner, Microsoft's deputy general counsel, wrote in a blog post.

"Motorola is on a path to use standard essential patents to kill video on the Web, and Google as its new owner doesn't seem to be willing to change course," Heiner added.

A spokesman for Google Inc. declined to comment on the complaint against Motorola. He couldn't immediately be reached after Microsoft announced its complaint also targeted Google directly.

A spokeswoman for Motorola didn't immediately respond to an emailed request for comment.

The complaints are the latest development in increasingly acrimonious disputes between global technology giants over patents on standardized technologies.

Industrywide standards play an important role not only in the technology sector. They allow products from different companies to function seamlessly together - different mobile phones or tablet computers connecting to the Internet and each other via 3-G or Wi-Fi networks, for example. Under EU competition rules, holders of patents necessary for industry standards are required to let other companies use them for a fair price.

But regulators and companies complain that holders of standard-essential patents have tried to gain an edge in the market by suing rivals over the use of their patented technologies.

When the European Commission, the EU's competition watchdog, cleared Google's takeover of Motorola earlier this month, it indicated concern over Motorola's aggressive patent enforcement. The Justice Department in its clearance of the merger made similar comments.

Separately, the Commission has already launched a formal investigation into Samsung's similar approach to patent protection and has warned that other probes may follow.

Microsoft says Motorola is demanding an unreasonable fee for using its patents, amounting to 2.25 percent of the products' total price. For a $1,000 laptop that would mean a royalty of $22.50 for using 50 patents related to a video standard. Microsoft says a group of 29 companies that hold the other 2,300 patents related to this standard charge a total of 2 cents for using them.

"If every firm priced its standard essential patents like Motorola, the cost of the patents would be greater than all the other costs combined in making PCs, tablets, smartphones and other devices," Heiner wrote. "Obviously, this would greatly increase the prices of these devices for consumers."

Explore further: Google adds more IBM patents to tech arsenal


Related Stories

US, EU clear Google's $12.5B Motorola Mobility bid (Update)

February 13, 2012

Google's $12.5 billion acquisition of cellphone maker Motorola Mobility have won approvals from U.S. and European antitrust regulators, moving Google a major step closer to completing the biggest deal in its 13-year history.

Recommended for you

Volumetric 3-D printing builds on need for speed

December 11, 2017

While additive manufacturing (AM), commonly known as 3-D printing, is enabling engineers and scientists to build parts in configurations and designs never before possible, the impact of the technology has been limited by ...

Tech titans ramp up tools to win over children

December 10, 2017

From smartphone messaging tailored for tikes to computers for classrooms, technology titans are weaving their way into childhoods to form lifelong bonds, raising hackles of advocacy groups.

Mapping out a biorobotic future  

December 8, 2017

You might not think a research area as detailed, technically advanced and futuristic as building robots with living materials would need help getting organized, but that's precisely what Vickie Webster-Wood and a team from ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) Feb 22, 2012
These patent wars are ridiculous, most of the patents that Apple sued other for are so incredibly vague, it's unbelievable that anyone ever granted them. Like the "slide to unlock", how the hell can that be a patent? These wars are slowing down technological advancement.
5 / 5 (3) Feb 22, 2012
Apple, which is suing just about all its competitors ( Samsung comes to mind ), does not want Motorola to protect its patents?
5 / 5 (1) Feb 23, 2012
I hate all this innovation-stifling litigation, but I can't help feel a little schadenfreude when I hear Microsoft complaining about anti-competitive practices.
On behalf of the computer industry for the past 30 years - "Waa"
5 / 5 (1) Feb 23, 2012
Bill Gates colluded with IBM execs to create a monopoly (absolutely true - it amounted to conspiracy). Gates stole PC DOS from CPM. He disassembled an existing BASIC interpreter and made it look the way he wanted it to then charged $60 per copy, back in the day. In the meantime, others were improving on his BASIC interpreter and giving them away for the cost of a floppy disk. Those are the guys I like. Open Source dudes.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.