Superhard carbon material could crack diamond

December 7, 2011 by Lisa Zyga feature
CNT bundles, shown in (a), are compressed and distorted, shown in (b), (c), and (d). After the formation of additional carbon bonds, they are transformed into the new carbon allotrope, Cco-C8, shown in (e). Image credit: Zhao, et al. ©2011 American Physical Society

( -- By applying extreme pressure to compress and flatten carbon nanotubes, scientists have discovered that they can create a new carbon polymer that simulations show is hard enough to crack diamond. The pressure-induced formation process of the new carbon allotrope, called Cco-C8, is similar to the 3D polymerization of the soccer-ball-like buckminsterfullerene, C60, at high pressure. When the carbon nanotube bundle is subjected to further compression, it becomes even more distorted and flattened to produce the Cco-C8 structure.

The scientists, led by Professor Yongjun Tian from the State Key Laboratory of Metastable Materials Science and Technology at Yanshan University in Qinhuangdao, China, have published their study on the new superhard in a recent issue of .1

“Star material carbon exists in various architectures due to its ability to form sp-, sp2-, and sp3-hybridized bonds, fostering graphite, diamond, lonsdaleite, carbine, chaoite, amorphous carbon, nanotubes, fullerenes, graphene, and so on,” Tian told “These carbon allotropes possess outstanding and unparalleled properties, as well as unique scientific and technological importance, such that searching for new carbon allotropes has long been a hot topic in scientific research communities. The greatest significance of this work lies in the new strategy of directly compressing carbon nanotube bundles to design and to synthesize novel metastable carbon allotropes. This strategy implies that some metastable phases of carbon with higher energy may also be experimentally obtained.”

As the scientists explain, applying pressure to some of these carbon allotropes can change the bonds, resulting in different forms of carbon with novel electronic and mechanical properties.

Instead of experimentally searching for new carbon allotropes, the scientists here used a recently developed technique called the Crystal Structure Analysis by Particle Swarm Optimization (CALYPSO). This computerized search was designed to predict stable crystal structures using only chemical compositions of a given compound at specified external conditions, such as pressure.

The CALYPSO simulations first yielded several carbon structures that are already experimentally known (such as graphite and diamond) or theoretically proposed (such as chiral C6). The simulations then revealed the novel Cco-C8 allotrope, a 3D composed of thin (2, 2) carbon nanotubes interconnected through 4-and 6-member carbon rings, which arises due to the formation of additional bonds between carbon atoms.

The simulations showed that Cco-C8 has a Vickers hardness of 95.1 GPa, which is slightly below diamond’s 97.5 GPa. Although there are several ways to measure the hardness of a material, Vickers hardness is one of the most common methods. In this method, a sharp object is compressed into a material, and the dimensions of the resulting indentation are measured.

“Hardness has been used as one of the macroscopic mechanical properties of materials for about three centuries,” Tian explained. “Usually, hardness can be defined macroscopically as the ability of a material to resist being scratched or dented by another. Recently, we defined hardness microscopically as the combined resistance of chemical bonds in a crystal to indentation.” 2

Although Cco-C8 has a Vickers hardness slightly below that of diamond, the scientists predict that Cco-C8 should be hard enough to scratch and crack diamond. As Tian explains, this is because Cco-C8’s compressive strength is higher than diamond’s shear strength.

“The mechanical strength or ideal strength of a material depends on the loading modes of tensile, shear and compression,” he said. “For example, both the tensile strength and shear strength of diamond are about 90 GPa, while its compressive strength is up to 223 GPa. If forced into the surface of a single diamond crystal, Cco-C8 as an indenter is mainly in a compressed state, the chemical bonds of diamond below the indenter withstand compressive deformation, and the bonds around the indenter withstand shear deformation. Although Cco-C8 has slightly lower hardness than diamond, the compressive strength of Cco-C8 should be much higher than the shear strength of diamond. When the stress in the shear deformation zone exceeds the shear strength of diamond, an indentation is formed. In other words, Cco-C8 is able to crack diamond.”

Cco-C8 may not be too difficult to synthesize in the future. The simulations showed that Cco-C8 is highly stable; the new carbon allotrope is energetically more favorable than almost all other theoretical carbon structures. Also, the simulations suggest that Cco-C8 can be synthesized by directly compressing carbon nanotube bundles in a similar way to synthesizing 3D C60 polymers.

In fact, Cco-C8 may have already been synthesized unknowingly. Previous experiments on the cold compression of carbon nanotube bundles yielded a new phase of carbon that was originally identified as P-62c. However, Tian and his coauthors think that the structure was more likely Cco-C8.

In addition, the researchers expect that other novel carbon materials with unique physical properties can be formed by similar compression techniques by using different sized nanotubes or other carbon structures. They plan to search for these materials in the future.

“First, we will use this strategy to design more novel carbon allotropes, especially conducting superhard carbons with partially sp2-hybridized C-C bonds (in the crystal structure of Cco-C8, each carbon atom is sp3-hybridized),” Tian said. “Second, we will try to synthesize these designed carbon materials using bundles at high pressure and high temperature.”

He added that Cco-C8 could have applications in fields where diamond has been used as a superhard material. And if the CALYPSO search discovers conducting superhard carbon materials, they could have potential applications in electronic devices.

Explore further: New carbon allotrope could have a variety of applications

More information: 1Zhisheng Zhao, et al. “Novel Superhard Carbon: C-Centered Orthorhombic C8.” PRL 107, 215502 (2011). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.215502

2Bo Xu, Zhisheng Zhao, and Yongjun Tian. “Microscopic theory of hardness and design of novel superhard crystals.” (Invited Review), Int. J. Refract. Met. Hard. Mater. (under review)


Related Stories

New carbon allotrope could have a variety of applications

April 22, 2011

( -- Carbon comes in many different forms, and now scientists have predicted another new form, or allotrope, of carbon. The new form of carbon, which they call T-carbon, has very intriguing physical properties ...

Scientists Discover Material Harder Than Diamond

February 12, 2009

( -- Currently, diamond is regarded to be the hardest known material in the world. But by considering large compressive pressures under indenters, scientists have calculated that a material called wurtzite boron ...

Structure of new form of super-hard carbon identified

November 8, 2010

( -- An experiment in 2003 formed what was believed to be a new form of carbon, but the findings were controversial. Now two teams of scientists have used different means to identify a three-dimensional network ...

Researchers predict material 'denser than diamond'

June 8, 2011

( -- Stony Brook University graduate student Qiang Zhu, together with Professor of Geosciences and Physics, Artem R. Oganov, postdoc Andriy O. Lyakhov and their colleagues from the University de Oviedo in Spain, ...

Graphene can be strengthened by folding

September 20, 2011

( -- With a strength 200 times greater than that of steel, graphene is the strongest known material to exist. But now scientists have found that folding graphene nanoribbons into structures they call “grafold” ...

Recommended for you

Artificial photosynthesis steps into the light

March 23, 2017

Rice University scientists have created an efficient, simple-to-manufacture oxygen-evolution catalyst that pairs well with semiconductors for solar water splitting, the conversion of solar energy to chemical energy in the ...

Chemical reactions 'filmed' at the single-molecule level

March 22, 2017

Scientists have succeeded in 'filming' inter-molecular chemical reactions – using the electron beam of a transmission electron microscope (TEM) as a stop-frame imaging tool. They have also discovered that the electron beam ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Dec 07, 2011
I thought denting and cracking were two different things.
not rated yet Dec 07, 2011
The first thing I read was 'Star Material Carbon'... which references shape instead of origin, I know, but I wonder if these shapes would be similar to those found in the so-called Diamond Stars?

Also, I wonder about the thermal conductivity of this new allotrope. Seems like it should be quite high and be quite stable at high temperatures.
not rated yet Dec 07, 2011
The first thing I read was 'Star Material Carbon'... which references shape instead of origin, I know, but I wonder if these shapes would be similar to those found in the so-called Diamond Stars?

Also, I wonder about the thermal conductivity of this new allotrope. Seems like it should be quite high and be quite stable at high temperatures.

Even with a poor conductivity, this could be pretty spectacular stuff. Manufacturing it on any large scale is probably a long way off (I don't know enough to speculate, but surely 10 to 30 years?), yet if you can produce it on a large scale it would be the best choice yet for a space elevator (assuming better tension strength than other wonder-carbon alternatives).

I can't help but think that once we crack large scale nanotubes, many other forms of carbon (such as this) will fall into place shortly after.

It will be like the plastic revolution (but better) all over again.
not rated yet Dec 08, 2011
i would think of a heavy anvil pressing machine that use diamond coated rolls to weld the nanotubes, if you line up two sets of nanotubes lenghtwise and use a slight offset so that they overlap at the linking points you could press together a nanochain of arbitrary length of 2 nanotubes thick, these long strands could be used to weave a cable, i would think it would work for chaining up small patches of overlapping graphene flakes also, allthough it would ewsemble more like a patched quilt than a single giant monolayer piece of graphene, i would think the physical properties be very good for industrial/consumer uses and easier to manufacture
not rated yet Dec 08, 2011
If it's so easy to create, why did they leave this at the "simulation" stage? It would have been much better for CALYPSO's reputation if they had actually created the material to prove the simulation's effectiveness.
not rated yet Dec 09, 2011
The first thing I read was 'Star Material Carbon'... which references shape instead of origin, I know, but I wonder if these shapes would be similar to those found in the so-called Diamond Stars?

Also, I wonder about the thermal conductivity of this new allotrope. Seems like it should be quite high and be quite stable at high temperatures.

Here "Star" does not refer to shape, but has the same meaning as in "movie star"...

not rated yet Dec 12, 2011
Let me know when they have something that will scratch diamond.
not rated yet Dec 15, 2011
At least this is meta-stable. I cant stand it when they report some great material that has crazy properties, but only exists when it is under immense pressure or massive magnetic field.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.