Free-to-pay? No way! Professor explores negative billing

December 15, 2011

During the festive season, online shoppers may think they're getting a bargain when they click on promotional discount boxes or sign up for free trials for such things as Christmas cards, exercise tips or even e-dating. But one University of Alberta researcher warns that these online goodies may take a bite out of your credit card balance.

It's called negative option billing, and it's the topic of a case study that Alberta School of Business professor Paul Messinger and fellow researchers Yuanfang Lin and Sabrina Yan recently published in the Asia Pacific and Globalization Review. It's also something that stung Messinger when he tried to save a couple of dollars by purchasing flowers online for his mother. Clicking a box to save 15 per cent inadvertently sent his card information to a third-party company that continued to charge a low-dollar monthly amount to his account, Messinger says.

"It looked like something I had allowed my daughter to bill, but after a certain period of time, I started to question it," Messinger says. "I contacted the online flower company and they said 'no, it's a completely different company.' Unbeknownst to me, they had handed off my information to the other party."

The fine print: A test of reasonable expectation

Messinger says there are benefits to negative option billing, provided the consumer is aware of what he or she signed up for, especially when it comes to paying monthly utility bills. The challenge comes when people don't realize they need to opt out, especially after a free trial offer. He says that people rarely read the fine print when clicking through screens and that's where they will fall prey to unanticipated credit card withdrawals. He says when trying or buying a product online, there should be a reasonable expectation that an online consumer will not be burdened more than a regular store shopper would when entering into a .

"The issue of what's reasonable comes into play because on the web you have the possibility of displaying all sorts of conditions that no reasonable person can absorb in 60 seconds," said Messinger. "There needs to be standards that take into account the cognitive limitations of people. It really is unreasonable to sell your soul just because you are buying (or trying) something online and you missed the fine print."

Caveat surfer: Online shopper beware

While some laws in the U.S. and Canada have been enacted to disallow third-party handoffs and restrict certain opt-out practices, Messinger says that negative option billing is still a lucrative scheme that catches millions of people every year. He says that a Visa survey indicated that 29 per cent of American cardholders had unauthorized recurring card charges as a result of an online offer. So, the free, seven-day trial may seem like a good idea initially, but when the user forgets to opt out before the billing period commences, there's nothing free about it.

Messinger advises that consumers need to be vigilant about checking their monthly statements because the amounts that negative option billing incurs are typically small enough to fly under the radar of most consumers. "These particular programs have been set up in such a way that there will be a fraction of people who won't notice them for a couple of months," he says, "and in the meantime, the company has made $30 from them."

Messinger says that consumers need to consider offers carefully before clicking, reminding themselves that they must opt out almost immediately after opting in. They may even decide that the free-to-pay services aren't worth the trouble. Further, he notes that regulatory bodies need to review and modify marketing standards to reflect a constantly growing and evolving e-marketplace.

"We have to set reasonable standards for online promotions," he says. "The Canadian Marketing Association recommends standards of practice that err on the side of being very protective of consumers, but we need to apply those more rigorously and continue to adapt them to the times."

Explore further: Sold-out products influence consumer choice

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Waiting periods reduce deaths from guns, study suggests

October 17, 2017

(—A trio of researchers with Harvard Business School has found evidence that they claim shows gun deaths decline when states enact waiting period laws. In their paper published in Proceedings of the National Academy ...

Roman theater uncovered at base of Jerusalem's Western Wall

October 16, 2017

Israeli archaeologists on Monday announced the discovery of the first known Roman-era theater in Jerusalem's Old City, a unique structure around 1,800 years old that abuts the Western Wall and may have been built during Roman ...

Human speech, jazz and whale song

October 13, 2017

Jazz musicians riffing with each other, humans talking to each other and pods of killer whales all have interactive conversations that are remarkably similar to each other, new research reveals.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Dec 15, 2011
We will probably get the new regulations when the politicians themselves become victims of these unethical practices.
1.4 / 5 (10) Dec 15, 2011
I never sign up for trial periods when they need a credit card as I find them nothing more than a scam. I agree that these practices are completely unethical!
3 / 5 (2) Dec 16, 2011
The other day I was at the bank finalizing negotiations on a $30k loan. I had to sign a half-dozen papers, some of which I could not even find where to put my X on, and trying to read them in the time slot we got was impossible. She did offer me time to read the 8(!) pages long legalese but I declined because there is no way in the world I could have understood the _implications_ of the text well enough to make any informed comment. And anyhow you'd need to be a lawyer to even try to. -- I simply threw my destiny at the mercy of the bank and the clerk.

When I install a piece of software, I need to "agree" on truckloads of crap, that often is only viewable through a two-line window!

My insurance policy is not understandable even to Mensa members. Or, rather, its actual ramifications when something happens.

So, I don't even pretend to read any of them. These Free-Trial-Scheisster vermins are low enough to exploit this fact of life, and should be shot and all small print made illegal.
not rated yet Dec 16, 2011
Simple: Don't use credit cards. Ever. (OK, maybe in dire emergencies).
COD, only, when buying on the internet. May costs a buck more every now and then, but you're safe from any such shennanigans.
not rated yet Dec 17, 2011
" finalizing negotiations on a $30k..." Despite brow-beating by clerk, I dug in my heels and read *all* of our mortgage agreement, discovering several blatant errors...
Re-drafting and proof-reading delayed completion by several weeks; The bank grudgingly picked up the tab for their error.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.