Has our black hole been blowing bubbles?

December 1, 2011 by Pete Wilton, OxSciBlog
Image: illustration showing the gamma-ray bubbles (highlighted in purple) extending 50,000 light-years, or roughly half of the Milky Way's diameter, either side of the Milky Way (the line across the centre). Credit: NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center

Our galaxy is a relatively quiet neighbourhood with the supermassive black hole at its heart gently dozing: or is it?

The recent discovery of huge gamma-ray emitting ‘’ around the Milky Way is challenging this assumption and posing a new puzzle: just where do these bubbles come from?

Philipp Mertsch and Subir Sarkar of Oxford University’s Department of Physics recently reported in Physical Review Letters a model that could explain the origins of these strange phenomena. I asked them about bubbles, ‘feeding’ , and how their ideas could be tested...

OxSciBlog: What are 'Fermi bubbles' and where are they found?

Philipp Mertsch: The 'Fermi bubbles' are gigantic structures above and below the centre of our Galaxy which were discovered by astrophysicists at Harvard in a gamma-ray sky map made by NASA's Fermi satellite.

The bubbles extend ~50,000 light years above and below the galactic plane, i.e. they are about the same size as the disk of the Galaxy. A correlated structure can also be seen in the X-ray map made by the ROSAT satellite.

It may seem surprising that such huge structures have gone unnoticed earlier - this is a testimony to how advances in astronomical instrumentation lead to serendipitous discoveries!

OSB: Why is it important to understand them?

Subir Sarkar: The bubbles are important for a variety of reasons. First, their origin is very likely related to an energetic outflow from the the lurking at our Galactic Centre - it is supposedly not "feeding" but clearly was doing so as recently as a million years ago. Understanding the mechanism of their gamma-ray emission also holds clues as to what is powering them.

Moreover this region of the sky is a prime target for dark matter annihilation signals - while the bubbles are themselves very unlikely to be due to dark matter annihilations, we need to understand them in meticulous detail if we want to look for the much smaller signal in gamma-rays expected from dark matter.

OSB: How have scientists previously tried to explain them?

PM: So far, scientists have considered the same processes that are believed to produce gamma-rays in astrophysical sources, for example decays of neutral pions created by interactions of high energy protons with ambient matter, and inverse-Compton scattering of background photons by high energy electrons.

High-energy protons are certainly present in the disk of the Milky Way, but it is not easy to explain how they could be transported to such large distances from the disk and be contained inside the bubbles for billions of years.

The problem with electrons is that they lose energy rapidly and would need to be reaccelerated - it has been suggested that this happens at hundreds of shock fronts inside the bubbles. However, there is no evidence for such an onion-like structure, in fact, the bubbles have a smooth surface and a well-defined, sharp edge.

OSB: What do you suggest may have produced the bubbles?

SS: The X-ray data from the ROSAT satellite suggest only one shock front which delineates the outer edge of the bubbles. This shock produces turbulence in the plasma behind it which can accelerate electrons to very high energies through a stochastic process first discussed by Enrico Fermi.

These electrons then transfer their energy to low energy photons from the microwave and infrared backgrounds as well as starlight, producing the gamma-rays observed.

It turns out that the variations of the plasma properties inside the bubbles can exactly reproduce the observed, namely the smooth surface and the sharp edges of the bubbles. The other models cannot explain this.

OSB: If you are correct what does this tell us about our galaxy/galaxy formation in general?

PM: An important question is of course where does this shock front come from? Looking at other we see similar bubbles being produced by jets powered from the central black hole. This is certainly a possibility for our own Galaxy.

In fact it is rather peculiar that the black hole at the centre of the Milky Way is so quiet - it now appears that this may just be a transient phase.

This picture is further supported by numerical simulations which have shown that a jet shooting out from the centre above and below the galactic plane can easily produce structures of the size and shape of the Fermi bubbles.

OSB: How could your ideas be tested?

SS: Our model for the gamma-ray emission predicts a unique energy-dependence: at lower energies, the surface of the bubbles is very smooth but at higher energies, the bubble inside should become fainter while only the edges stay bright. The energies at which this happens are beyond the reach of the Fermi satellite but with data from the forthcoming Cherenkov Telescope Array this shell-like structure should become observable. 

Explore further: Fermi telescope discovers new giant structure in our galaxy (w/ Video)

Related Stories

Giant gamma ray bubbles in our galaxy

November 19, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Gamma rays are the most energetic form of light, typically about one hundred billion times as energetic as optical light.

Chandra Shows Shocking Impact of Galaxy Jet

April 22, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- A survey by the Chandra X-ray observatory has revealed in detail, for the first time, the effects of a shock wave blasted through a galaxy by powerful jets of plasma emanating from a supermassive black hole ...

Fermi maps an active galaxy's 'smokestack plumes'

April 1, 2010

If our eyes could see radio waves, the nearby galaxy Centaurus A (Cen A) would be one of the biggest and brightest objects in the sky, nearly 20 times the apparent size of a full moon. What we can't see when looking at the ...

High Energy Mystery lurks at the Galactic Centre

September 22, 2004

A mystery lurking at the centre of our own Milky Way galaxy - an object radiating high-energy gamma rays - has been detected by an international team of astronomers. Their research, published today (September 22nd) in the ...

600 mysteries in the night sky

October 19, 2011

NASA's Fermi team recently released the second catalog of gamma-ray sources detected by their satellite's Large Area Telescope (LAT). Of the 1873 sources found, nearly 600 are complete mysteries. No one knows what they are.

Recommended for you

Time crystals—how scientists created a new state of matter

February 22, 2017

Some of the most profound predictions in theoretical physics, such as Einstein's gravitational waves or Higgs' boson, have taken decades to prove with experiments. But every now and then, a prediction can become established ...

Science versus the 'Horatio Alger myth'

February 22, 2017

In a new study published today in the journal PLOS ONE, Los Alamos National Laboratory scientists have taken a condensed matter physics concept usually applied to the way substances such as ice freeze, called "frustration," ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Dec 01, 2011
How some big structures are similar to those small. These one look like one of electron clouds...
2.1 / 5 (7) Dec 01, 2011
French astronomer La Violette predicted the blowing of bubbles before thirty years already.


Understanding the mechanism of their gamma-ray emission also holds clues as to what is powering them
It's not the only "clue" available here. If LaViolette is correct, than these emissions are very regular, with period of 12.500 thousands of years. It would point to same process inside of black hole, rather than outside of it.
1 / 5 (6) Dec 01, 2011
IMO we wouldn't make any mistake, if we would consider the black hole bubbles as a scaled up analogy of stellar protuberances or as a scaled down analogy of supernova explosions, which occurs at the neutrino level - heavier particles are trapped inside the area of dense cloud at the galactic centre.

Of course, some process outside of black hole can still apply too. Central black hole is surrounded with many fast rotating stars, which are encircling it along eccentric path. We could imagine, the central black hole sucks some material from them periodically and blows them into free space in form of X-rays and neutrinos. But my feeling is, the amount of material released in this way cannot be as large, as my other theories require.
vlaaing peerd
not rated yet Dec 01, 2011
Do black holes (or complete galaxies) have a magnetic field?

If so wouldn't it contain the Gamma rays within it's field, causing such a shape?
5 / 5 (1) Dec 01, 2011
Do black holes (or complete galaxies) have a magnetic field?

If so wouldn't it contain the Gamma rays within it's field, causing such a shape?

No. Photons are not trapped by magnetic fields.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 02, 2011
No. Photons are not trapped by magnetic fields.

This is true, however the galactic magnetic field can direct particles that area precursors to particle interactions that create photons. p (matter)->pi_0->gamma gamma

Asymmetric neutral pion decays can lead to high energy gamma rays which have a statistical characteristic shape. This shape can be determined by reading the gamma ray flux over a long period of time and then we can infer initial proton energy and deflections due to galactic/supergalactic ambient magnetic fields. Also, it is important to consider spacetime distortions in regions closer to high mass regions (closer to the black hole)
1 / 5 (3) Dec 03, 2011
LaViolette is an American. Fermi bubbles support his cosmic ray superwave theory, as do the enormous outflows observed in many galaxies, as do many other lines of evidence, including ice core records from 12,000 years ago, and the current externally-sourced illumination of the Crab nebula. The magnetic fields dispersion problem is overcome via mechanisms detailed in his SubQuantum Kinectics continuous creation physics model.


The periodicity of the superwaves can be mapped in Earth's long-term climate changes. Abrupt changes are noted therefrom.

2 / 5 (4) Dec 04, 2011
Actually, for those interested:

Here LaViolette's superwave model from his 1983 dissertation details how the cosmic rays propagate radially outward from the black hole region in spite of the magnetic fields present.

And I was wrong about the 12,000 year event. He actually links the evidence to 40,000 years ago via a spike in Be-10 measured in ice core records. If you care to read more on the superwave phenomenon:

3 / 5 (2) Dec 04, 2011
But.. but... isn't he a dirty aetherist? His web is full of blasphemous aetheric symbols... We all can smell the evil crackpot at distance - Apage Satanas!
1 / 5 (1) Dec 07, 2011
But.. but... isn't he a dirty aetherist? His web is full of blasphemous aetheric symbols... We all can smell the evil crackpot at distance - Apage Satanas!

I gave you 5 stars as I realized you were being sarcastic toward those who give low scores for being on the correct path.
not rated yet Dec 20, 2011
Fermi gamma ray bubbles in dwarf galaxies?
Might one look for such gamma ray bubbles in dwarf galaxies? Hence suggestive of a central black hole? Resolution permitting, might one search for nearby Local Group dwarf galaxies, by looking for such gamma ray bubbles?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.