Social media, social pressures and the power of opinion

September 21, 2011 by Deborah Braconnier report
Social media, social pressures and the power of opinion
An example comparison used in the experiment

( -- New research from HP's Social Computing Research Group suggests that while social media and the recommendations of others can cause you to change your mind regarding a product or service, it is not in the way you may think. While you may assume that people change their mind when more people disagree with their choice, this study shows people are more likely to change their mind when the amount of people disagreeing is fewer.

The internet is filled with product reviews and rating systems and many turn to these for information when deciding on a new product. The research team at HP wanted to determine just how effective these reviews were on influencing a person’s decision.

The team presented participants with a series of choices when it came to two pieces of furniture. The participants were then asked again after varying amounts of time, but were this time told that other participants had preferred the other item. What they discovered was that when a small number of other participants differed in their , the participant was more likely to make a change in their choice as opposed to when a large number disagreed with them.

Two main theories of social influence are represented in this experiment. The first, psychological reactance theory, believes that when a person’s beliefs are threatened by opposition, they stand strong in the need for self-preservation. This theory proved to be more powerful in the experiment when the amount of people opposing a participant’s beliefs was large.

The second theory, social influence and conformity, believes that people have the need to feel socially connected and when faced with opposition will change to conform to the group. The experiment by HP shows that this theory holds truer when the group opposing is smaller.

The research also revealed that the timing of outside influence is important when it comes to getting someone to change their mind. Influence is more likely to occur when a person is given more time before being approached with different opinions. They also discovered that the more time a person takes to make their initial choice, the more likely they are to be influenced by other opinions.

The researchers now plan to tackle the idea of quality when it comes to recommendations and test whether a person is more or less likely to change their choice when influenced by friends and family. If sources that they feel connected to choose the opposite item, will they be more or less likely to conform.

Explore further: The freedom of power

More information: via Wired

Related Stories

The freedom of power

December 1, 2008

With the forthcoming inauguration this January, the nation will be closely watching to see how the President Elect will respond to the advice, influence, and criticism of his advisors, cabinet members, media, and other political ...

What choice do we have?

March 29, 2011

( -- Too much choice can be a bad thing—not just for the individual, but for society. Thinking about choices makes people less sympathetic to others and less likely to support policies that help people, according ...

Negativity is contagious, study finds

October 4, 2007

Though we may not care to admit it, what other people think about something can affect what we think about it. This is how critics become influential and why our parents’ opinions about our life choices continue to matter, ...

Recommended for you

Averaging the wisdom of crowds

December 12, 2017

The best decisions are made on the basis of the average of various estimates, as confirmed by the research of Dennie van Dolder and Martijn van den Assem, scientists at VU Amsterdam. Using data from Holland Casino promotional ...

Genetics preserves traces of ancient resistance to Inca rule

December 12, 2017

The Chachapoyas region was conquered by the Inca Empire in the late 15th century. Knowledge of the fate of the local population has been based largely on Inca oral histories, written down only decades later after the Spanish ...

Violence a matter of scale, not quantity, researchers show

December 11, 2017

Anthropologists have debated for decades whether humans living in tribal communities thousands of years ago were more or less violent than societies today. Researchers at the University of Notre Dame wonder if the question ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 21, 2011
Probably because most human beings gain their deepest mental positions in early life, and from their parents.
It is only when challenged do some (I couldn't guess the percentage of the population) people begin to examine a position. Others, of course, will never do that examination since they are comfortable with the one they, and their parents have.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 22, 2011
thats a fairly interesting result. The person with wildly variant beliefs 1/99 is steady in their belief but public opinion is easier to shift when beliefs are closer to 50/50.
Further questions would be what happens when the decision isnt binary and whats the exact threshold for the shift in behavior between steady and changeable?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.