Reforestation practices may be lagging behind climate change

August 24, 2011 By Bev Betkowski
Reforestation practices may be lagging behind climate change
Laura Gray holds up a map of Alberta's tree habitats.

A University of Alberta study is sounding a warning about forestry practices in North America, claiming that climate change is already rendering established planting guidelines obsolete.

“We’ve found that trees are already lagging in adaptation to climate change and are not performing as they should,” said Laura Gray, a PhD student in the Department of Renewable Resources. “We need to change the way we manage our forests today if we want to maximize production.”

Gray’s findings were based on two studies she conducted for her thesis, exploring planting guidelines in the forest-rich regions of western North America, including parts of Alberta, British Columbia, Montana, South Dakota and Wyoming, seeking ways to adapt to climate change that is leaving forests less productive or vulnerable to disease and pests like the Mountain Pine Beetle.

The related findings are published in the latest issues of the scientific journals Public Library of Science and Ecological Applications.

Using computer models, Gray and her colleagues analyzed the landscape of western , attempting to find optimal climate habitat for tree species under observed warming trends and under future climate change scenarios. Based on that data, changes could be made to what type of tree seed is planted where.

Currently, legislated forestry practices dictate that seed for reforestation cannot be transferred from designated zones where seed has been collected, but, said Gray, climate change is altering tree habitat so that the existing zones may not be the best places for current and future reforestation efforts.

“A lot of forest management strategies are based on data we have from the 1960s and 1970s, but the climate has definitely changed since then,” said Gray. Her research has revealed that aspen trees—used for oriented strandboard and pulp—are already climactically mismatched for their current seed zones. In turn, that has led to much less forest productivity over the last decade, Gray said. “It’s already happening, and we are behind the times.”

“We know the climate is changing and we are trying to determine where we can pick up seed and move it, so that trees are more closely matched to their optimal environments, creating better productivity over their lifetime.”

The studies recommend that various tree seeds be planted in multiple zones that show a close climatic match for the future. “In many cases, we have found that those locations range well beyond the current seed zones.”

The research also showed that trees suited to warm and dry climates—such as southern Alberta and some areas of the United States—will likely be the best choices for the forests of tomorrow. “Trees best adapted to those conditions are going to be really useful in the future,” Gray said.

And while the trend in forestry is to look ahead 80 to 100 years, Gray’s research recommends against that, suggesting instead that projections can realistically only stretch to 2020 or so. “The adaptation strategies are limited to the short-term horizon, because it is difficult to really predict the climate beyond that time. A better strategy is to focus on seeds that are climate-matched for 10 years from now.”

Gray has made several presentations on her findings to the forestry industry, and said while the research represents a significant departure from contemporary forest management practices, changes are necessary.

“We really are suggesting a change to the way things are managed today, and while this research can’t fix the problem of , we can certainly make suggestions on how to mitigate impacts for the forestry sector.”

Explore further: Study illustrates shifting boreal forest ecosystem in Alaska

Related Stories

Aspen's 'dandelion' habits challenge mountain evergreens

February 22, 2010

( -- The face of high-elevation evergreen forests in Western Canada could be drastically altered as a combination of climate change, human and natural disturbances is making spruce and pine forests in the Rocky ...

Plants protect from climate impacts

August 2, 2011

Native vegetation must be restored to protect Australia’s unique ecosystems from the impacts of climate change, according to scientists from the Australian National University.

Insects continue to threaten forests across Colorado

February 16, 2011

( -- Although the mountain pine beetle epidemic has largely run its course in north-central Colorado, insect and disease activity continued to stress the state’s forests in 2010.

Climate is warming - despite 'ups and downs'

December 28, 2010

Periodic short-term cooling in global temperatures should not be misinterpreted as signalling an end to global warming, according to an Honorary Research Fellow with CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research, Barrie Hunt.

Recommended for you

The world needs to rethink the value of water

November 23, 2017

Research led by Oxford University highlights the accelerating pressure on measuring, monitoring and managing water locally and globally. A new four-part framework is proposed to value water for sustainable development to ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Aug 24, 2011
Based on that data, changes could be made to what type of tree seed is planted where

Palm oil; the new cash crop for Alberta? Sorry, I couldn't restrain myself.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.