Google has changed the way students research - and not for the better, study says

August 29, 2011 By Sunanda Creagh, The Conversation
A US study found that students use research databases like they use Google — which limits the results they turn up. Credit: Flickr/langwitches

Many university students use scholarly databases like they would Google, revealing an astonishingly poor understanding of how to refine searches for better research results, a US study has found.

The Ethnographic Research in Illinois Academic Libraries (ERIAL) Project, a two-year study of the student research process involving five US universities, included extensive interviews with students, librarians and other in an effort to better understand 21st Century student research habits.

The study, to be published by the American Library Association under the title Libraries and Student Culture: What We Now Know, revealed worryingly crude research skills among the students surveyed. Many were unwilling to ask university librarians for help — or even knew that they could ask.

“While students used the libraries at all five universities pretty extensively, librarians were absent from most students’ academic worldview. Students typically didn’t know what librarians did, or how they might help with academic work,” said Dr. Andrew D. Asher, Scholarly Communications Fellow at Bucknell University and one of the authors of the study.

However, students who were introduced to their librarian by a faculty member were much more likely to ask for help and get better research results, he said.

The students surveyed often looked in journals or databases unsuited to their field of study and displayed a poor understanding of how to refine search results.

“Many (but not all) students are not gaining the information literacy skills in college that they will need in their future careers. This isn’t just about doing academic research, but also about being a savvy, reflective, and critical consumers of information,” said Dr Asher, adding that most students were working hard and doing their best in difficult circumstances.

“Students need better conceptual training on how search engines organise and retrieve information. These are really epistemological questions that I don’t think are being adequately addressed in many student’s academic experiences.”

Google-style databases

Some have argued that the study says more about poor usability of many academic databases than about student research skills and that “dinosaur databases” should adopt a more user-friendly, Google-style interface.

However, Dr. Asher said that would not address the underlying problem — that many students do not understand how databases work.

“While the interface of and other similar search engines might be more intuitive, what’s going on behind the scenes isn’t intuitive at all, and very few students had a clear conception of how search engines work. This lack of understanding compounds the problem of building an effective search strategy.”

A global problem?

The US study did involve interviews with some international students and they did not seem to differ in any systematic way from the US students, suggesting the problem may be more widespread, said Dr Asher.

“I think the problems we observed in searching are not limited to students and probably reflect problems that are also present in the general population,” he said.

However, University of Sydney Librarian John Shipp said he thought that if the survey was done in Australia, it would show a different picture.

“Large US university libraries tend to emphasise collections rather than service to users,” and are often staffed by student workers out of normal hours, he said.

“By contrast, Australian and New Zealand university libraries have, in general, tried to ensure that professional staff are available whenever the library is open.”

Australian students were also more likely to have information literacy training embedded in their course curricula — an approach not yet common in the US, he said.

“There is a misconception that students must know their way around the internet as they are constantly using the technology. Research and observation indicates the opposite,” said Mr. Shipp.

“Students may be savvy with the technology but their knowledge of the location and relevance of information resources is frequently minimal.”

Catherine Clark, assistant director of Research and Learning Support for Medicine, Dentistry, Education at the University of Western Australia said new students frequently overestimate their research abilities.

Compulsory training on how to find and evaluate information sources are now included in first year courses, she said.

“You can’t teach these things as a separate entity. It needs to be embedded in the program so students see it as part of their learning,” she said.

“In medicine, especially, it’s really important students are using peer reviewed material.”

Sophie McDonald, Information Services Librarian at the University of Technology Sydney (UTS), said her library encouraged students to seek help from librarians both in person and via social media and instant messaging.

UTS also runs workshops on skills like advanced database searching, mobile searching, Google skills and finding images, she said.

“[Google] has increased expectations that finding information should be easy, so library catalogues and databases have become easier to use. Students can now access the full text of journal articles via library links in Google Scholar and we focus more on helping them evaluate the information they find and using it ethically,” said Ms McDonald.

She said the US study highlighted how librarians in general “are failing to promote their services effectively.”

“How can ask questions when they don’t know who we are and what we do? Librarians need to be more open and present in places where they can connect with clients – like using social media and mobile technologies,” she said.

This story is published courtesy of the The Conversation (under Creative Commons — Attribution/No derivatives).

Explore further: Critical thinking called into question

Related Stories

Critical thinking called into question

February 4, 2011

A post-secondary education won’t necessarily guarantee students the critical thinking skills employers have come to expect from university grads, says a recent study.

Shuttle launches BYU student-designed circuit into space

May 17, 2011

When the shuttle Endeavor launched  Monday morning there was a little bit of BYU on board. A BYU research team designed a highly specialized type of circuit that could improve the reliability of current NASA technology.

Recommended for you

How to cut your lawn for grasshoppers

November 22, 2017

Picture a grasshopper landing randomly on a lawn of fixed area. If it then jumps a certain distance in a random direction, what shape should the lawn be to maximise the chance that the grasshopper stays on the lawn after ...

Plague likely a Stone Age arrival to central Europe

November 22, 2017

A team of researchers led by scientists at the Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History has sequenced the first six European genomes of the plague-causing bacterium Yersinia pestis dating from the Late Neolithic ...

Ancient barley took high road to China

November 21, 2017

First domesticated 10,000 years ago in the Fertile Crescent of the Middle East, wheat and barley took vastly different routes to China, with barley switching from a winter to both a winter and summer crop during a thousand-year ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 30, 2011
Yes, that's what the Advanced Search function is for on the Google Scholar page. The problem I've always had with the journal searches that college libraries provide are a pain to work with, in that one minor misstep will have you locked out of your own session and having to log in again, provided there isn't a timeout period for your previous session.
You want students to use the library resources, make sure the things work correctly to begin with.
The Angry Technician
not rated yet Aug 30, 2011
While usability is definitely a big issue, I think part of the decline is that students are no longer learning library skills in school the way they once were.

Today, using Google and Google Scholar is "good enough" for grade school and often high school assignments, and educators have come to accept that. School libraries are losing the importance to those assignments they once held, and the ever-increasing pressure on school finances leads many school administrators to de-professionalise the role of librarians, while in other schools the traditional library all but disappears entirely.

The result is that by the time students reach college, they have had little or no exposure to classic library skills or the resources that go along with that; they assume that the resources they've got by with so far will be all they need. After all, if they needed something more, surely their school would have taught them about it?
not rated yet Aug 30, 2011
It seems to me, then, that the PARENTS of the children should endevour to provide those opportunities and skills. Grade school teachers can help, as well, by doing what my grade-school teachers did at times, and march the whole class down to the library and teach them about it, maybe require them to write a paper only with material they find IN the library...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.