How British is 'Rule Britannia'?

How British is 'Rule Britannia'?
Last night of the Proms
(PhysOrg.com) -- It is seen by many as an unofficial British national anthem – but an Oxford University academic believes she has discovered that Rule Britannia was heavily influenced by Greek literature.

Dr. Cressida Ryan of Oxford University’s Classics Faculty has found clear traces of Greek literature and culture in the famous song written by James Thomson – a link that has never been made before.

Dr Ryan said: ‘While studying the Greek and Roman influences on William Mason’s Caractacus, I decided to look at James Thomson, Mason’s contemporary, who wrote Rule Britannia and I found clear evidence that Thomson’s poem had an eye to classical Greek literature. Rule Britannia, like Greek literature, contains elements of the sublime – a term used to describe how aesthetic works affect someone drawing on ancient ideas of pity, fear, terror and the soul.

Dr. Ryan explained: ‘In eighteenth-century London he mixed with men such as Robert Walpole, Dr. Arbuthnot, Alexander Pope and John Gay, who focused on the sublime in their writings. The emerging concept of the sublime was shaped by changes in their choices of Greek and Roman philosophical models.

"Thomson combined Greek tragedy with English nationalistic writing early in his career – in 1738 his play Agamemnon opened at Drury Lane and although this was unsuccessful, Greek tragic influence remains discernible in his later work such as Edward and Eleanora. In Rule Britannia, we find the same combination of focus on the country, religion, politics, law, strength against enemies and artistic inspiration that are present in Caractacus."

Rule Britannia, which is associated with British patriotism and the Royal Navy, was written as a chorus for the masque Alfred, written by James Thomson and his friend David Mallet, and set to music by Thomas Arne in 1740.

Dr. Ryan points to several lines in the lyrics which may have roots in ancient Greece. She said: "Thomson’s line ‘The blast that tears the skies, Serves but to root thy native oak' portrays the oak as the symbol of Britain, as the olive symbolised Athens. The emphasis on Britain as divinely protected in the first verse – ‘When Britain first at Heaven’s command ...and guardian angels sung this strain ... as the loud blast, the blast that tears the skies’ invokes the power of the thunderbolt, an instrument of the Old Testament God but also of Zeus.

"Biographical and literary links between Thomson and Mason make such a reading more plausible. It is clear that they were both working with similar Greek and Roman models in mind, and that their own work seems to overlap more directly."

Ancient Greece may have influenced the tune of Rule Britannia, in addition to the lyrics. Dr. Ryan said: ‘Thomas Arne, who set the music for Rule Britannia, was also fond of Greek tragedy and composed Oedipus, King of Thebes.’


Explore further

What the Romans learnt from Greek mathematics

Provided by Oxford University
Citation: How British is 'Rule Britannia'? (2011, April 14) retrieved 26 June 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2011-04-british-britannia.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
0 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Apr 14, 2011
Maybe things relating to the British state are hypocritical like this...just look at the monarchy...meant to be as british as..but the truth is the word group of briton brython etc is from the latin roman occupiers relating to the P celtic speakers (brythonic) and nothing to do with the increasingly anglicised island

Apr 14, 2011
Many*

The Official British national anthem tune is also used by liechtenstein (used before britain)

Also, until the act of union 1707, the welsh and cornish were called british (though wales was officially England from 1536 to 1955) in documents and manuscripts I have read during my study of the genetical history of this island :)

British was brought into to common parlance to make the scots feel less bad being part of England and use a unifying 'neutral' term

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more