Apple: IPhone not tracking users, will get update (Update 2)

A man displays an iPhone
A man displays an iPhone in 2009. Apple on Wednesday denied claims it was tracking the location of iPhone users but said it planned to fix "bugs" that resulted in location data being unencrypted and stored for up to a year.

Apple denied that the iPhone has a privacy problem Wednesday - and then promised to fix it. It took the technology giant a week to respond to a brouhaha over how the devices log their owners' movements.

Privacy concerns erupted last week when security researchers said a file found on PCs linked to iPhones allowed them to create maps of the phones' movements for up to a year. Combined with similar questions about Google's Android smartphone software, the news left privacy-conscious smartphone users wondering how much information they were unknowingly giving up.

Apple denied claims that it was keeping tabs on its customers, saying the file records Wi-Fi hot spots and cell towers in the general area of iPhones, not the whereabouts of their users.

The company implied that the privacy concerns raised by that file were partly based on a misunderstanding. But it also said that a software error was the reason the files are storing up to a year's worth of information, and that it would fix that issue and others in a few weeks.

"Users are confused, partly because creators of this new technology (including Apple) have not provided enough education about these issues to date," Apple said in its first comprehensive response to the allegations. It had revealed the nature of the location file in a letter to Congress last summer following an earlier round of questions about its location-tracking practices.

The data help the phone figure out its location, Apple said. They allow the phone to listen for signals from hot spots and cell towers, which are much stronger than signals from GPS satellites. Wi-Fi signals don't reach very far, which means that if a phone picks up a signal it recognizes, it can deduce that it's close to that hot spot.

Taken together, this means navigation applications can present the phone's location faster and more accurately than if the phone relied on GPS alone, Apple said.

However, it's still not clear why the files are so detailed that they allow the reconstruction of the phone's movements.

In its 10-point question-and-answer statement, Apple didn't address why the files contain "timestamps" that link a phone to certain hot spots and cell towers at a certain time. Those timestamps are what allowed the researchers Alasdair Allan and Pete Warden to construct animated maps of a phone's movements over a year.

Warden said that as far as he could tell, Apple could have used the location data productively without storing timestamps. He said he's pleased the company is applying software fixes to safeguard the data.

Marc Rotenberg, executive director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, a Washington-based privacy rights group, commended the company for quickly making significant changes to the iPhone operating system.

But Larry L. Smith, the president of the Institute for Crisis Management, a public relations company, said Apple should have responded to concerns last week even if it didn't have all the answers ready.

Questions such as "Is Apple tracking my iPhone's location?" are not entirely unexpected, and Apple should have had some standby statements ready to go, Smith said.

Apple's reaction is reminiscent of its response last summer, when Consumer Reports and others reported that the iPhone 4 suffered from signal loss when held a certain way.

Apple stayed quiet for a week after the launch of the phone, then denied there was a hardware problem but said it would fix how the iPhone displayed its signal bars. Two weeks later, it offered free protective cases that insulated the antenna, mitigating the signal loss. It still denied the design was flawed. The phone's appeal stayed intact.

Apple is not the only technology company addressing allegations that it's tracking customers. Google Inc. acknowledged last week that phones running its Android software store some location data directly on phones for a short time from users who have chosen to use GPS services. Google said that was done "to provide a better mobile experience on Android devices."

Apple said iPhone data are stored for up to a year because of a software error. The company said there's no need to store data for more than seven days, and a software update in the next few weeks will limit the size of the file.

The iPhone will also stop backing up the file to the user's computer, a practice that raised some concerns. Computers are much more vulnerable to remote hacking attempts than are phones.

A third planned fix is to encrypt the file, and to stop downloading the data completely to phones that have all "Location Services" turned off, Apple said.

Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., chairman of the Senate Judiciary subcommittee on privacy, technology and the law, said he still has questions about why Apple didn't tell users what it was doing.

"This has raised larger questions of how the locations of mobile devices are tracked and shared by companies like Apple and Google, and whether federal laws provide adequate protection as technology has advanced," Franken said Wednesday. He plans a hearing on cellphones and privacy next month.

The way an iPhone stores its own location appears to be at most a minor privacy threat. A snoop would need access to the victim's phone or PC, both of which usually store lots of other personal information. Phones contain texts, emails and lists of phone calls. PCs contain such information as tax returns, logs of websites visited and passwords.

There's a separate issue of smartphones like the iPhone transmitting their location wirelessly to corporate servers. In Wednesday's statement, Apple reiterated that iPhones regularly send their location to Apple, but do so anonymously, so the company isn't able to track users.

IPhones can also transmit a user's location to companies that run applications with location-based services, with the user's consent. Companies that buy ads through Apple's iAds advertising system can also locate users, but only ones that specifically approve of a location request from a particular ad.

Apple shares fell 27 cents to $350.15 on Wednesday.

Explore further

Apple, Google asked to testify on mobile privacy

More information: Apple Q&A on location tracking:

©2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Citation: Apple: IPhone not tracking users, will get update (Update 2) (2011, April 27) retrieved 21 July 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Apr 27, 2011
They're gonna reduce the amount of time the information is stored on the phone... big deal it's still being sent to apple regularly, it's still stored on your phone. I don't believe for a moment that the data is sent anonymously. Was it not originally that the information was not sent to anyone ever? hmm.

Apr 27, 2011
Apple did not even bother to come up with a better excuse. A bug? really?

Apr 27, 2011
"a bug we uncovered" really? is the email address of the spammers Business manager, Vanessa, listed under contact on their page. I suggest she receive some uncomplimentary emails from those here who object to being spammed in the face :)

Apr 27, 2011
The Ipod folks will still keep collecting the data, only now that they have been exposed they will collect more data and be sly about it. They already admitted doing it, and now are really implying that they will encrypt it to make it harder to discover what kind of spying they are doing, and also to lay the groundwork for laying criminal charges of 'beating a security system' to put in jail and/or otherwise imtimidate folks who would discover their chicanery and have the guts to go public about it. Bottom line, take all your apple equipment, and by this I mean that 'safari' browser software as well as any other apple software on any GPS equipped product, and destroy it. Do not continue to use it. If GPS info is overlain with map info and commercial databases of businesses, all you 'businessmen' that go to fronts for prostitution may well get caught up with by your wives who bother to look into some present or future 'check-him-out' website ta see whatcha do on your trips.

Apr 27, 2011
I wondered how Apple would respond.

I thought they would minimize the problem and perhaps modify how they are doing it to make it seem that they are responding to public dismay over the tracking.

That is what they have done.

No apology because that would be an agreement that what they have done was wrong and would mean they would have to stop doing it.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more