Lie, lay: a grammar trap lying in wait
(PhysOrg.com) -- "I'm going to lay down and take a nap," the man said to his wife.
You cant lie that one on me. I know youre lying, she sternly replied. Youve never laid down for a nap in your life. What are you really going to do?
Eeek. Doesnt anyone know the difference between lay and lie anymore? Does anyone even care?
And furthermore, should we care?
Todays usage of lie and lay is totally arbitrary, said Elly van Gelderen, professor of English. The Oxford English Dictionary Samuel Johnsons dictionary decided on these forms, and I think we should get rid of them. I dont see them as errors, just that things are changing.
The correct, or prescriptive, usage of lie and lay seem to be moving farther (or should that be further?) away from peoples conscience, as a careful reading of current newspapers illustrates.
Just ask the two people who uttered these sentences:
"You dont get a choice really. You can lay there and you can die, or you can get up and get going again.
This is just money laying on the table that companies havent gotten around to doing.
And, many of van Gelderens students dont know the difference. As part of a 10-question grammar quiz, she asked the students to choose the right usage for lay and lie and only two students got all 10 sentences right, she said.
(Lesson: Lay is a transitive irregular verb it needs an object: The chicken lays an egg every day. Lie is an intransitive irregular verb that does not need an object: I lie down regularly.)
And then theres the quandary of who and whom, which, van Gelderen says, has been around since the time of Shakespeare.
(Lesson: 'Who' is subject and 'whom' is the object of a preposition or verb.)
Speaking of Shakespeare, the dramatist actually wrote this sentence in The Merchant of Venice: All debts are cleared between you and I. (Another subject-object conundrum.)
But if you read a modern version of the play, youll find that it has been changed to between you and me.
(Shakespeares spelling of cleared as cleerd in The Merchant of Venice also has been fixed, and there are numerous other examples of how his language has been cleaned up.)
A new wrinkle in grammar is the increasing use of goes instead of says, as in the following exchange:
He goes, You are so last-year. Why are you wearing those ripped-up jeans? Then I go, Because I just fell and torn them.
This use of go is quotative, van Gelderen said. The speaker will say go or goes then go on to quote someone.Many people are self-conscious about how they put words together, particularly if they know they are speaking with a grammar expert such as van Gelderen.
If she happens to mention, say at the dentist, that she teaches grammar, the usual reaction is: "'Oh, my grammar is terrible.' Therefore I never say that I teach grammar, she said.
So why bother learning the rules of grammar? Why not just let it all go and say, Me sees you instead of I see you?
We stick to the rules because it makes us sound educated, van Gelderen said. To some extent it does empower people to learn grammar. Its important in our society.
And, she added, though grammar does subtly change, too many people have a vested interest in keeping it the way it is.
To say it another way, people want to see things stay like they are. (Or should it be as they are?)
Pop Quiz: See if you can use the appropriate form of `lie or `lay in the following sentences.
Choices: lie, lay, laid, lay, laying, lying, lain, laid
1. Did you want to .................. on the couch?
2. Did you .......... your pen down?
3. Earlier today, I ................. down some towels to absorb the rain.
4. Last night, she ................. awake for a long time.
5. Have you been ................. brick long?
6. She was ................. on the couch.
7. I have ................... in the sun all day.
8. They have ................... down their arms.
Answers: 1. lie 2. lay 3. laid 4. lay 5. laying 6. lying 7. lain 8. laid