4G cellular networks might not live up to hype

November 18, 2010 By David Sarno

If today's fastest smart phones deliver e-mails and Web pages with the speed of a thoroughbred racehorse, then the next generation of phones - now rolling onto the runway - may feel like jet planes.

Powered by souped-up networks (that's fourth generation), new smart phones will be more like centers, allowing users to watch live, high-definition TV broadcasts, download entire movies in seconds and make smooth, uninterrupted video phone calls from street corners and hilltops alike.

But don't burst into song quite yet: For all their high-flying potential, 4G networks are still a long way from taking off.

All four major cellular providers have been touting the speed and possibility of 4G, but the number of consumers these embryonic networks now reach is limited, and only a few early handsets are on the market. It could be a year or more before the technology is widely available.

Corp. has an early lead in the 4G race, having turned on its new networks in a few dozen smaller cities this year. The company plans to bring 4G capability to parts of Los Angeles on Dec. 1, and San Francisco a few weeks after.

Sprint's network, based on a technology called WiMax, will offer users average download speeds of about 3 to 6 megabits per second - roughly four times what most 3G users get now. At those speeds, users could download an entire song in about 10 seconds.

But Sprint's 4G network will cover only a fraction of the users that it serves with its current 3G system. The company says if you're looking to upgrade, you should first consult to see whether your home or office is covered. If it isn't, you might end up with a flashy 4G phone that's getting the same old 3G speeds.

Building the networks has been slow and costly for all of the major providers, which have spent billions retrofitting cell towers across the country, replacing older copper wiring with fiber-optic cable capable of carrying thousands of times more data.

"I've never seen a network undertaking that's as intensive as this, including the building of the original cellular network," said Andy Shibley, AT&T's vice president and general manager for the Los Angeles area, noting that the company has spent close to $40 billion building its network over the past two years - including upgrading tens of thousands of cell sites across the U.S.

"When you start dealing with that many zeros, that's a giant undertaking," Shibley said.

At a new Verizon Wireless switching center in Los Angeles last month, Jim Harper, a senior technician, walked down rows lined with dozens of black metal cabinets containing hundreds of circuit boards that process millions of calls and data requests every day.

Harper stopped at a lone white cabinet, about the size of a gym locker. It was a 4G server that could handle as much call traffic as fifty of the black 3G cabinets. Verizon's version of 4G, it says, will allow speeds of 5 to 12 megabits per second - more than twice as fast as Sprint's on the high end.

"The pace that the technology moves is just exploding," Harper said.

Yet as powerful as the forthcoming technology may be, the white cabinet was still the only one in the room - a sign that Verizon is still in the early days of building its network.

Verizon Wireless hasn't turned on 4G yet. It will begin to flip the switch in about 30 U.S. cities this year, initially offering 4G service only to wireless accessories for laptops. Its 4G smart phones won't come out until sometime in the middle of 2011 (Verizon declined to say if whether that would include Apple Inc.'s iPhone), and as far as size, its 4G network won't catch up to its existing 3G footprint until 2013.

In the meantime, if you are wondering exactly what 4G means, you're not alone.

The technical definition of 4G is set by a United Nations standards body. It has to do with the specific way data are moved around and was created to achieve mobile broadband close to 100 times faster than what is available today.

The carriers have jumped out in front of that definition, however, adopting the 4G label even when their networks do not fit the technical specifications.

T-Mobile, which as recently as March was calling its grid the "nation's fastest 3G wireless network," recently began referring to itself as "America's largest 4G network" - though its technology has not changed.

T-Mobile uses a technology called HSPA+, an extension of 3G networking that delivers much faster speeds. The company contends that the technical definition doesn't much matter to consumers, as long as they're getting faster service.

"Consumers don't care about how many G's are attached to the underlying technology," said David Gallacher, T-Mobile's regional vice president of engineering, noting that T-Mobile's HSPA+ network is faster than Sprint's 4G offering. "They care about the speed and quality of the experience."

AT&T, the iPhone's exclusive carrier, has endured frequent criticism about the performance of its wireless network, which has sometimes creaked under increasing demands of data-hungry .

Perhaps understandably, the company has taken a more cautious approach to the 4G debates. AT&T, like T-Mobile, has highlighted its faster new HSPA+ network - but unlike T-Mobile, it has not called it 4G.

AT&T has said its HSPA+ networks, which have just begun rolling out, will be two or three times faster than other companies' 3G offerings.

As for 4G, the company said, it will begin rolling it out toward the middle of next year.

Explore further: T-Mobile renames upgraded 3G network '4G'


Related Stories

T-Mobile renames upgraded 3G network '4G'

November 3, 2010

(AP) -- Sprint Nextel Corp. and Verizon Wireless are building wireless data networks using new technologies that the industry calls fourth-generation, or 4G. Not to be outdone, T-Mobile USA launched a campaign this week ...

Verizon says fast 4G wireless coming to 38 cities

October 6, 2010

(AP) -- Verizon Wireless said Wednesday that its new wireless broadband network, which offers higher data speeds initially for laptop users, will be live before the end of the year in the cities on the Boston-to-Washington ...

Verizon Wireless Plans to Offer 4G Capability Next Year

September 3, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- In today's world, we want our information to travel faster. This is especially true as smart phones take over and we become used to using smaller devices to accomplish more while we are away from home. Verizon ...

4G wireless: It's fast, but outstripped by hype

May 31, 2010

(AP) -- Cell phone companies are about to barrage consumers with advertising for the next advance in wireless network technology: "4G" access. The companies are promising faster speeds and the thrill of being the first on ...

MetroPCS to launch 4G phone before Verizon

March 24, 2010

(AP) -- MetroPCS Communications Inc. plans to be the first wireless carrier to introduce a phone using a new network technology that provides faster data access. It's beating Verizon Wireless, the country's largest carrier.

Recommended for you

A not-quite-random walk demystifies the algorithm

December 15, 2017

The algorithm is having a cultural moment. Originally a math and computer science term, algorithms are now used to account for everything from military drone strikes and financial market forecasts to Google search results.

US faces moment of truth on 'net neutrality'

December 14, 2017

The acrimonious battle over "net neutrality" in America comes to a head Thursday with a US agency set to vote to roll back rules enacted two years earlier aimed at preventing a "two-speed" internet.

FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality' (Update)

December 14, 2017

The Federal Communications Commission repealed the Obama-era "net neutrality" rules Thursday, giving internet service providers like Verizon, Comcast and AT&T a free hand to slow or block websites and apps as they see fit ...

The wet road to fast and stable batteries

December 14, 2017

An international team of scientists—including several researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory—has discovered an anode battery material with superfast charging and stable operation ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Nov 18, 2010
News flash; There is no such thing as a 4G network. It's a marketing term.
not rated yet Nov 18, 2010
Another newsflash: no matter how fast the theoretical speed on the "last mile" to the customer, cellular networks still have to divide it among all the users in that cell, and it says nothing about how fast the connection between the cell tower and the actual internet is.

not rated yet Nov 18, 2010
Aye, which brings to the bigger issue, is their lack of investment in infrastructure to handle the load.
not rated yet Nov 19, 2010
If there is a standard recognized by IEEE or the like, you should be fined for not meeting the requirements and advertising that you do. Would we tolerate an 802.11G performing at 802.11B intentionally? If a car carries a label indicating it can get 42MPG and it only gets 35 at best (by their own admission), would we not take legal action against the company?
not rated yet Nov 19, 2010
But there is not I-triple-E standard for 4g and there never will be.

802.11g INTENTIONALLY operating at 802.11b speeds is much harder to prove than MPG. Your bandwidth/throughput is a theoretical maximum at best.
not rated yet Nov 20, 2010
But there is not I-triple-E standard for 4g and there never will be.

802.11g INTENTIONALLY operating at 802.11b speeds is much harder to prove than MPG. Your bandwidth/throughput is a theoretical maximum at best.

Not IEEE exactly, but there is a standard devised by ITU-R. There must be a standard, it exists somewhere.
not rated yet Nov 21, 2010

Not IEEE exactly, but there is a standard devised by ITU-R. There must be a standard, it exists somewhere.

No standard can overcome basic physical limits that dictate how much data you can push through a certain band at a certain frequency. The problem of wireless networking is that this bandwith is always shared.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.