Appeals court ruling threatens used software sales

September 11, 2010 By MICHAEL LIEDTKE , AP Technology Writer

(AP) -- A federal appeals court has sided with the computer software industry in its effort to squelch sales of second-hand programs covered by widely used licensing agreements.

Friday's ruling by the 9th Circuit of Appeals raised worries that it will embolden , movie studios and to circumvent the so-called "first-sale" doctrine in an attempt to boost their sagging sales.

The doctrine refers to a 102-year-old decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that determined copyright holders can't prevent a buyer from reselling or renting a product after an initial sale, as long as additional copies aren't made.

It's a legal principle that allows used book and music stores to operate, as well as DVD subscription services such as Inc.

But a three-judge panel in the 9th Circuit concluded the first-sale doctrine didn't apply to used programs that online merchant Timothy Vernor peddled in his store on eBay. Vernor had bought the unopened software, made by Inc., at garage and office sales, without ever agreeing to the imposed on the original buyer.

That contract made it clear the rights to install Autodesk Inc.'s software were being licensed rather than sold, according to the 9th Circuit's interpretation.

Without a definitive sale, the first-sale doctrine is moot, the appeals court reasoned in its decision overturning a lower federal court in Washington state.

Autodesk, which is based in San Rafael, said it was pleased with the decision. The Software & Information Industry Association had filed documents supporting Autodesk's position in the case.

The ruling sets the stage for even more legal skirmishes over the definitions of a sale and a license, said Corynne McSherry, an attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a group fighting to set the boundaries of digital copyrights.

"I am sure there are going to be others (in the media) trying to find the magic words that prevent a buyer of intellectual property from being considered the owner," McSherry said.

Another round in the 3-year-old battle pitting Vernor against Autodesk seems assured. Vernor's attorney, Gregory Beck of Public Citizen, said he intends to ask a full panel of 11 judges in the 9th Circuit to review Friday's decision before considering a possible appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

For the moment, Beck and another attorney involved in the case, Sherwin Siy of Public Knowledge, said they expect the 9th Circuit's decision to have a chilling effect on the used software market.

That's something that Inc. had hoped to avoid. The e-commerce company, based in San Jose, Calif., filed a brief in support of Vernor's legal arguments citing the protections under the first-sale doctrine.

Many other popular software programs already installed on home and office computers are covered by licensing agreements using similar language to Autodesk's programs, Beck said.

"That means the infrastructure already is in place for other software makers to say their customers don't really own those programs," he said.

Explore further: U.S. court rules against medical marijuana


Related Stories

U.S. court rules against medical marijuana

March 14, 2007

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Wednesday that an individual's right to medical marijuana does not supersede the Controlled Substances Act.

Court bans sale of Word; Microsoft promises fix

December 22, 2009

(AP) -- A federal appeals court ordered Microsoft Corp. to stop selling its Word program in January and pay a Canadian software company $290 million for violating a patent, upholding the judgment of a lower court.

Court Denies Vonage Bid for Patent Case Retrial

May 4, 2007

A U.S. appeals court denies a request by Internet phone company Vonage Holdings that it order a retrial in the patent infringement case brought against it by Verizon Communications.

Court rules against Bush administration

March 20, 2006

A federal appeals court has overturned a clean-air regulation issued by the Bush administration, ruling in favor of environmental advocacy groups.

Recommended for you

Cryptocurrency rivals snap at Bitcoin's heels

January 14, 2018

Bitcoin may be the most famous cryptocurrency but, despite a dizzying rise, it's not the most lucrative one and far from alone in a universe that counts 1,400 rivals, and counting.

Top takeaways from Consumers Electronics Show

January 13, 2018

The 2018 Consumer Electronics Show, which concluded Friday in Las Vegas, drew some 4,000 exhibitors from dozens of countries and more than 170,000 attendees, showcased some of the latest from the technology world.

Finnish firm detects new Intel security flaw

January 12, 2018

A new security flaw has been found in Intel hardware which could enable hackers to access corporate laptops remotely, Finnish cybersecurity specialist F-Secure said on Friday.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Sep 11, 2010
All the more reason for potential software buyers to look closely at freeware and Open Source alternatives in this case QCAD and FreeCAD.

What is the point of buying something that you do not own?
5 / 5 (2) Sep 11, 2010
How would this ruling affect the sail and/or purchase of used PC's with the software already installed?
5 / 5 (2) Sep 12, 2010
I really hate the software industry, let it fail and people will make their own software just like we already do. I own a used bookstore and it seems to me like we are rapidly moving toward Fahrenheit 451 scenario. Frightening to say the least. Down with commercialization of thoughts.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.