Astronomers Find Planets in Unusually Intimate Dance around Dying Star

July 29, 2010
Caltech astronomer John Johnson. Credit: Courtesy of Bill Youngblood

Hundreds of extrasolar planets have been found over the past decade and a half, most of them solitary worlds orbiting their parent star in seeming isolation. With further observation, however, one in three of these systems have been found to have two or more planets. Planets, it appears, come in bunches. Most of these systems contain planets that orbit too far from one another to feel each other's gravity. In just a handful of cases, planets have been found near enough to one another to interact gravitationally.

Now, however, John A. Johnson, an assistant professor of astronomy at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech), and his colleagues have found two systems with pairs of locked in an orbital embrace.

In one system—a planetary pair orbiting the massive, dying star HD 200964, located roughly 223 light-years from Earth—the intimate dance is closer and tighter than any previously seen. "This new planet pair came in an unexpected package," says Johnson.

Adds Eric Ford of the University of Florida in Gainsville, "A planetary system with such closely spaced giant planets would be destroyed quickly if the planets weren't doing such a well synchronized dance. This makes it a real puzzle how the planets could have found their rhythm."

A paper by Johnson, Ford, and their collaborators describing the planets and their intriguing orbital dynamics has been accepted for publication in the (see for a preprint).

All of the four newly discovered exoplanets are gas giants more massive than Jupiter, and like most exoplanets were discovered by measuring the wobble, or , in the light emitted by their parent stars as the planets orbit around them. Surprisingly, however, the members of each pair are located remarkably close to one another.

Astronomers Find Planets in Unusually Intimate Dance around Dying Star
Inward migration of a swarm of protoplanets. The protoplanets are represented by white circles, with size proportional to mass. The disc is coloured according to density: the brighter part is the denser region of the disc. Credit: Astronomy & Astrophysics

For example, the distance between the planets orbiting HD 200964 occasionally is just .35 astronomical units (AU)—roughly 33 million miles—comparable to the distance between Earth and Mars. The planets orbiting the second star, 24 Sextanis (located 244 light-years from Earth) are .75 AU, or about 70 million miles. By comparison, Jupiter and Saturn are never less than 330 million miles apart.

Because of their large masses and close proximity, the pairs exert a large gravitational force on each other. The gravitational tug between HD 200964's two planets, for example, is 3,000,000 times greater than the gravitational force between Earth and Mars, 700 times larger than that between the Earth and the moon, and 4 times larger than the pull of our sun on the Earth.

Unlike the gas giants in our own solar system, the new planets are located comparatively close to their stars. The planets orbiting 24 Sextanis have orbital periods of 455 days (1.25 years) and 910 days (2.5 years), and the companions to HD 200964 periods of 630 days (1.75 years) and 830 days (2.3 years). Jupiter, by contrast, takes just under 12 Earth years to make one pass around the sun.

Planets often move around after they form, in a process known as migration. Migration is thought to be commonplace—it even occurred to some extent within our own solar system—but it isn't orderly. Planets located farther out in the protoplanetary disk can migrate faster than those closer in, "so planets will cross paths and jostle each other around," Johnson says. "The only way they can 'get along' and become stable is if they enter an orbital resonance."

When planets are locked in an orbital resonance, their orbital periods are related by the ratio of two small integers. In a 2:1 resonance, for example, an outer planet will orbit its parent star once for every two orbits of the inner planet; in a 3:2 resonance, the outer planet will orbit two times for every three passes by the inner planet, and so forth. Such resonances are created by the gravitational influence of planets on one another.

"There are many locations in a protoplanetary disk where planets can form," says Johnson. "It's very unlikely, however, that two planets would just happen to form at locations where they have periods in one of these ratios."

A 2:1 resonance—which is the case for the planets orbiting 24 Sextanis—is the most stable and the most common pattern. "Planets tend to get stuck in the 2:1. It's like a really big pothole," Johnson says. "But if a planet is moving very fast"—racing in from the outer part of the protoplanetary disk, where it formed, toward its —"it can pass over a 2:1. As it moves in closer, the next step is a 5:3, then a 3:2, and then a 4:3."

Johnson and his colleagues have found that the pair of planets orbiting HD 200964 is locked in just such a 4:3 resonance. "The closest analogy in our solar system is Titan and Hyperion, two moons of Saturn which also follow orbits synchronized in a 4:3 pattern," says Ford. "But the planets orbiting HD 200964 interact much more strongly, since each is around 20,000 times more massive than Titan and Hyperion combined."

"This is the tightest system that's ever been discovered," Johnson adds, "and we're at a loss to explain why this happened. This is the latest in a long line of strange discoveries about , and it shows that exoplanets continuously have this ability to surprise us. Each time we think we can explain them, something else comes along."

Johnson and his colleagues found the two systems using data from the Keck Subgiants Planet Survey—a search for planets around stars from 40 to 100 percent larger than our own sun. Subgiants represent a class of stars that have evolved off the "main sequence," and have run out of hydrogen for nuclear fusion, causing their core to collapse and their outer envelope to swell. Subgiants eventually become red giants—voluminous stars with big, puffy atmospheres that pulsate, making it difficult to detect the subtle spectral shifts caused by orbiting planets.

"Subgiants are rotating very slowly and they're cool," unlike rapidly rotating, hot main sequence stars, "but they haven't expanded enough to be too fluffy and too jittery," Johnson says. "They're 'Goldilocks' stars: not too fast, not too hot, not too fluffy, not too jittery"—and, therefore, ideal for planet hunting.

"Right now, we're monitoring 450 of these massive stars, and we are finding swarms of planets," he says. "Around these stars, we are seeing three to four times more planets out to a distance of about 3 AU—the distance of our asteroid belt—than we see around main sequence stars. Stellar mass has a huge influence on frequency of planet occurrence, because the amount of raw material available to build planets scales with the mass of the star."

Eventually, perhaps 10 or 100 million years from now, subgiant stars like HD 200964 and 24 Sextanis will become red giants. They will throw off their outer atmospheres, swelling to the point where they could engulf the inner planet of their dancing pair, and will throw off mass, changing the gravitational dynamics of their whole system. "The planets will then move out, and their orbits will become unstable," Johnson says. "Most likely one of the planets will get flung out of the system completely"—and the dance will end.

Explore further: Is The Solar System Unique in The Universe?

Related Stories

Is The Solar System Unique in The Universe?

August 3, 2004

On the evidence to date, our solar system could be fundamentally different from the majority of planetary systems around stars because it formed in a different way. If that is the case, Earth-like planets will be very rare. ...

Missing planets attest to destructive power of stars' tides

April 27, 2009

During the last two decades, astronomers have found hundreds of planets orbiting stars outside our solar system. New research indicates they might have found even more except for one thing - some planets have fallen into ...

Astronomers discover 'tilted planets'

December 22, 2009

( -- University of Exeter, UK, research has added to a growing evidence that several giant planets have orbits so tilted that their orbits can be perpendicular or even backwards relative to their parent star’s ...

Planetary systems can form around binary stars

January 10, 2006

New theoretical work shows that gas-giant planet formation can occur around binary stars in much the same way that it occurs around single stars like the Sun. The work is presented today by Dr. Alan Boss of the Carnegie Institution’s ...

Recommended for you

Lowest-frequency accreting millisecond X-ray pulsar found

February 22, 2017

(—Astronomers have found the lowest-frequency accreting millisecond X-ray pulsar in the X-ray source known as IGR J17062−6143. By analyzing the data provided by the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE) spacecraft, ...

Surprising dunes on comet Chury

February 22, 2017

Surprising images from the Rosetta spacecraft show the presence of dune-like patterns on the surface of comet Chury. Researchers at the Laboratoire de Physique et Mécanique des Milieux Hétérogènes (CNRS/ESPCI Paris/UPMC/Université ...

Fermi finds possible dark matter ties in Andromeda galaxy

February 21, 2017

NASA's Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope has found a signal at the center of the neighboring Andromeda galaxy that could indicate the presence of the mysterious stuff known as dark matter. The gamma-ray signal is similar to ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.9 / 5 (9) Jul 29, 2010
"This is the tightest system that's ever been discovered," Johnson adds, "and we're at a loss to explain why this happened. This is the latest in a long line of strange discoveries about extrasolar planets, and it shows that exoplanets continuously have this ability to surprise us. Each time we think we can explain them, something else comes along."

I just LOVE this statement. Like someone said some time ago: they're all unique.
So how to explain this beautiful dance in terms of the current accretion model?

It can't.

Maybe it's time to find another model.

My model says God created the most intricate and astonishing things we have yet to discover. Your mileage may vary.
1 / 5 (3) Jul 29, 2010
Born around is false one between live truth dying multi was, to be read downunder my blogspot.

Your message is unclear. However, . . .

Earth itself was born around the dying star that became our Sun - a plasma diffuser, covered with lightweight elements (H & He) because the Sun sorts atoms by mass [Physics of Atomic Nuclei 69, 1847-1856 (2006)].

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
Former NASA Principal
Investigator for Apollo

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.