Scientists finding sink holes in Great Lakes

May 4, 2009 By James Janega

Scientists studying submerged sinkholes in the Great Lakes off the coast of northern Michigan have stumbled onto something they never expected to find: life forms akin to those found in some of Earth's most extreme environments.

As groundwater leaks upward into Lake Huron, it re-dissolves an ancient seabed and creates a salty underwater environment that is supporting mats of primitive purple microbes -- cousins to bacteria that live in deep-sea hydrothermal vents and ice-locked Antarctic lakes.

The discovery in Huron's Thunder Bay underscores how little is known about the forms that life takes on Earth, or even where they might be found.

In this case, scientists wonder if the microbes may be truly primordial. Researchers found that the purple bacteria can photosynthesize as easily in sulfur-rich water as they can in fresh water, an ability suited to the dim and sulfur-rich conditions of shallow, primeval seas that existed billions of years ago.

"We see this as a peek into the ancient world," said research ecologist Bopaiah Biddanda of Grand Valley State University in Michigan. "This sort of life was not supposed to be occurring in the ."

The exposed limestone bedrock at the bottom of the lake -- a landform called karst -- was once the floor of a Silurian sea that 300 million years ago blanketed what would become North America.

The Great Lakes were formed by glaciers, and most of the water in them now comes from rain and snowfall. But the sinkholes in the lake bed are filled with groundwater rich in salts and dissolved sulfur.

The source of those dissolved minerals is unknown, but scientists hope to find clues by trying to determine the age of the groundwater more accurately this summer. Certainly, say scientists, it is very old.

"The question is whether it's several tens of thousands of years old, or several hundreds of thousands of years old," said Wayne State University geology professor Mark Baskaran.

The science community learned about the microbial ecosystems in Lake Huron's Thunder Bay National Marine Sanctuary when archaeologists from the Institute for Exploration were searching in 2001 for uncharted shipwrecks in the sinkholes.

Instruments on the group's remote-controlled, deep-water submersible robot found unexpected pockets of very salty, slightly warmer water in the holes, which pockmark the limestone bedrock that straddles northern Michigan between Lake Michigan's Grand Traverse Bay and northern Lake Huron.

Cameras on the submersible recorded something divers had seen and talked about for years -- vast purple carpets mottling the bottom of the shallower sinkholes, where dim surface light still reaches. In deeper, darker water, the submersible found white microbial mats similar to those around deep-ocean heat vents.

"The more they saw them, the more they brought in other folks with particular expertise to look at this stuff," said Cathy Green, education coordinator at the national marine sanctuary. In the nearby industrial town of Alpena, Mich., residents who once talked about shipwrecks offshore now talked about the scientists who returned each summer.

One thing the researchers tried to figure out was what on Earth those purple colonies were.

They found that the single-celled microbes banded together to form filaments that in turn joined to form mats. When debris fell on the mats, the bacteria got on top of it by crawling toward the light. The sticky ooze could climb a pebble in a laboratory water tank in a few hours, and crawled up the sides of beakers.

The bacteria also could eat sulfur, a primitive metabolic ability mostly abandoned when bacteria figured out how to use oxygen for photosynthesis billions of years ago.

Last spring, gene sequencing produced a startling result, said University of Wisconsin-Stout biologist Stephen Nold. When the DNA sequence was fed into a computer to compare with other species, the closest match was Phormidium autumnale, a rare bacterium found on an Antarctic floor.

The implication was that this kind of bacteria had once been everywhere but now survives only in pockets of inhospitable, salty, dim water -- what the world was like before plants.

Researchers will return to the unusual ecosystem again this summer, hoping to determine the age of the water source, how the sinkholes can be safely explored by divers in the marine sanctuary and how many more sinkhole ecosystems may exist elsewhere in the limestone-rich lower Great Lakes.

"Here we have this example of what early Earth must have looked like -- 70 feet down," Nold marveled. "It's not even that deep."


(c) 2009, Chicago Tribune.
Visit the Chicago Tribune on the Internet at
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Explore further: Great Lake's sinkholes host exotic ecosystems

Related Stories

New life beneath sea and ice

November 17, 2008

Scientists have long known that life can exist in some very extreme environments. But Earth continues to surprise us. At a European Science Foundation and COST (European Cooperation in the field of Scientific and Technical ...

Recommended for you

Good fighters are bad runners

July 21, 2017

For mice and men, a strength in one area of Darwinian fitness may mean a deficiency in another. A look at Olympic athletes shows that a wrestler is built much differently than a marathoner. It's long been supposed that strength ...

Genome study offers clues about history of big cats

July 21, 2017

(—A large international team of researchers has conducted a genetic analysis and comparison of the world's biggest cats to learn more about their history. In their paper published on the open source site Science ...

Researchers discover mice speak similarly to humans

July 21, 2017

Grasshopper mice (genus Onychomys), rodents known for their remarkably loud call, produce audible vocalizations in the same way that humans speak and wolves howl, according to new research published in Proceedings of the ...

Researchers discover biological hydraulic system in tuna fins

July 20, 2017

Cutting through the ocean like a jet through the sky, giant bluefin tuna are built for performance, endurance and speed. Just as the fastest planes have carefully positioned wings and tail flaps to ensure precision maneuverability ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) May 04, 2009
*points up* mats like this are where multicellular organisms came from. Single celled organisms co-operate in order to achieve a common goal, and eventually they form a close enough relationship with each other that they can't survive independently any more. And *poof*, a mere (heh) 3.5-4 billion years later, here we are.

That's just cool:). Makes me hope that there is life in Europa and in the watery mantel of Titan.
not rated yet May 05, 2009
Maybe there are tunnels connecting the great lakes with the ocean!!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.