Lawmakers adopt bill to punish Internet piracy

May 12, 2009 By EMMANUEL GEORGES-PICOT , Associated Press Writer

(AP) -- French lawmakers in the lower house on Tuesday passed a bill that would cut the Internet connections of those who repeatedly download music and films illegally, creating what may be the first government agency to track and punish online pirates.

The bill passed 296 to 233 in a show of force by President Nicolas Sarkozy's governing conservatives after an initial failure last month.

The Senate was likely to definitively pass the measure Wednesday. But even then, the battle will be far from over.

The bill defies a measure passed last week prohibiting EU governments from cutting off a user's Internet connection without first passing through a court of law. That still needs a final stamp after negotiations with the European Council.

The legislation by Sarkozy's government is hotly opposed by the rival Socialists as well as militants who claim that it will quash freedoms by denying accused Internet pirates the right to challenge the charges against them. Others fear it will pave the way for Big Brother-style intrusions by the government into citizens' private lives.

But international music labels, film distributors and artists have hailed the bill as a decisive step in combatting online piracy in France, where CD and DVD sales have plummeted 60 percent in the past six years.

The measure, sponsored by Culture Minister Christine Albanel, would introduce a "graduated riposte" for those pirating music and films. Warnings to culprits would begin with two e-mails followed by a certified letter. If the piracy continues within the following year, Internet access could be cut for a period of two months to a year - while the user keeps paying for the service.

The bill would create a government agency to sanction offenders, leaving monitoring efforts to entertainment industry watchdogs.

Legal experts say such an agency could be the first of its kind in the world, noting that the French bill also represents the first time a government has threatened to sever Internet connections in the battle against online piracy.

"Most places have left it to the realm of civil litigation," said law professor Wendy Feltzer, a fellow at Harvard University's Berkman Center for Internet and Society.

Feltzer said that despite its novel approach, the French bill is ill-adapted to the digital age.

"It's backward to so much of how the Internet has been developed," she said. "It's trying to retain a business model that is already evolutionarily behind the times."

Critics say the law misses the point, targeting traditional downloads at a time when online streaming is taking off, for example.

Others contend that users downloading from public Wi-Fi hotspots or using masked IP addresses might be impossible to trace.

"The law is ineffective, inapplicable and dangerous," said Jeremie Zimmerman, who heads a Paris-based Internet freedom activist group.

The bill failed in an April 9 vote attended by only a handful of lawmakers - a political embarrassment for Sarkozy who had made its passage a personal priority.


Associated Press Writer Scott Sayare in Paris contributed to this report.
©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: French lawmakers reject Internet piracy bill

Related Stories

French lawmakers reject Internet piracy bill

April 9, 2009

(AP) -- French lawmakers unexpectedly rejected a bill Thursday that would have cut off the Internet connections of people who repeatedly download music or films illegally.

EU Parliament rejects law allowing Internet cutoff

May 6, 2009

(AP) -- Worried about trampling on the rights of innocent consumers, the European Parliament rejected Wednesday attempts by EU governments to crack down on people who illegally download copyright-protected music and movies ...

Hollywood scores win over Pirate Bay, 4 convicted

April 17, 2009

(AP) -- The entertainment industry won round one Friday in a legal battle against file-sharing hub The Pirate Bay, with guilty verdicts and one-year prison sentences handed down to four men accused of running and financing ...

Recommended for you

Flying Dutch win world solar car race in Australia

October 12, 2017

Dominant Dutch team "Nuon" Thursday won an epic 3,000-kilometre (1,860-mile) solar car race across Australia's outback for the third-straight year in an innovative contest showcasing new vehicle technology.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet May 12, 2009
I have often railed against piracy, and I will continue to do so, but I feel uneasy about this legislation.

Governments grant rights to authors/owners of copyrights and patents. That is well established. Infringment can be resolved in so many ways: letters/emails from the owners of the copyrights, civil court, criminal court. The French government sending out letters is odd but harmless, however, for any government to bypass the courts and directly punish someone without trial is an abuse of power.

I personally prefer two methods to counter piracy: Those of us who think it is wrong to steal, even in the digital world, must attempt to persuade our fellow man that civilization cannot stand on piracy. There are legitimate things to be said on both sides, but in the end, we all must respect the property of others.

If, in the end, people cannot respect the rights of those who create and distribute digital goods, the I would call for a strike. Refuse to create, refuse to distribute, do not participate in a society that does not recognize your right to trade. Withhold your creative mind from their abuse. Leave them nothing to rape and pillage. Leave them to the dull and meaningless lives that they must live if they have nothing to do but spend their time stealing your very livelihood out from under you. Go on strike!

I know this would never happen, but I have to say how I feel and stand up for what is right. Without property rights, we have nothing.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.