Sony's PlayStation Move can't quite challenge Wii

Oct 01, 2010 By Troy Wolverton

When Nintendo unveiled the Wii four years ago, few game industry pundits gave it much of a chance.

Its core processor was pedestrian compared with those in Sony's and Microsoft's Xbox 360, the other new consoles that debuted about the same time. It didn't support high-definition video, unlike its rivals. And while the other two consoles could play movies and do other multimedia tricks, all the did was play games.

But none of that mattered because of the Wii's innovative motion-sensing controllers. The controllers helped reinvent gaming, making it more fun and accessible to the masses.

Those controllers, along with some well-done games and a price that was significantly lower than its rivals, made the Wii a hit. Nintendo has now sold 74 million Wiis, nearly as many as the combined sales of the PlayStation 3 and the .

It took them a while, but Sony and Microsoft finally realized that motion-sensing games are more than a passing fad. In hopes of luring past and would-be-future Wii buyers, Sony released its new motion-sensing system, dubbed the PlayStation Move, earlier this month, and Microsoft will soon follow with its own system.

The Move is actually a collection of accessories. The two core parts are the , a designed specifically for the PlayStation 3, and the Move , which looks like a handheld microphone with a glowing ping pong ball on top.

There are additional accessories players may want or need. Some games encourage the use of two Move controllers per person. Others require the Move controller to be used in tandem with the Move navigation controller, which has a small joystick and extra buttons and is used similarly to the Wii's Nunchuk accessory.

The Move controllers work very much like those for the Wii. Game players direct the actions of their on-screen characters by making more or less natural motions with the controllers. For example, if you want your character to hit the ball in a tennis game, you swing the controller through the air as if it were the handle of a racket.

I'm generally a fan of motion-sensitive games. I've enjoyed playing the tennis, boxing, swordplay and other mini-games included in "Wii Sports" and "Wii Sports Resort." I've also had fun with the motion-sensitive elements of other games, particularly making Indiana Jones snap his whip in the "Lego Indiana Jones" games.

I tested out a handful of the new Move games for the PlayStation 3. Their big advantage over similar games on the Wii is that they are in high definition. As fun as the Wii is, its standard-definition games often look fuzzy on an HDTV. "Sports Champions" isn't all that different from the "Wii Sports" games, but it looks a lot better on a big screen.

As with the motion-sensitive games for the Wii, the Move games are designed to get players up and moving, rather than sit on the couch mashing buttons. I got a decent workout playing tennis in "Racquet Sports," playing beach volleyball in "Sports Champions" and having a sword fight with my son in that game's Gladiator Duel activity. I also found myself moving with my character while playing "Kung Fu Rider" and "Sports Champions" disc golf mini-game.

But the Move system differs from the Wii in important ways and overall comes up short.

The biggest difference is the price. You can get a new Wii with a controller, Nunchuk and two games for $200. In contrast, a new PlayStation 3 with a Move controller and Eye camera costs $400. And a bundle of the Move controller and Eye camera alone costs $100.

The Move's underlying technology is different, but not always in a good way. The PlayStation 3 uses the Eye camera to track the ball on the Move controller. That allows players to become characters in augmented reality games as their images are projected on the screen holding a paintbrush or sword instead of a game controller.

But because it uses visible light, the camera can have a hard time tracking the ball against a bright background. I also noticed at times a lag between pressing a button on the Move controller and having the system respond.

Whether for those or for other reasons, I frequently found that the games I played didn't do a good job of mimicking my movements. I'd try to kick someone in "Kung Fu Rider," but nothing would happen. I'd try to hit the ball in a tennis game but my character wouldn't swing his racket.

I also found that the games generally weren't as inspired or fun as the motion-sensing games on the Wii. For example, the mini-games included in "Sports Champions" are similar to those in "Wii Sports," but "Sports Champions" includes a set of 20 stereotypical characters -- the jock, the tomboy, etc. -- that lack personality. Players aren't given the option, as they are on the Wii, of creating and personalizing their own zany characters.

"Kung Fu Rider" has a fun premise -- you ride through the streets of Hong Kong on rolling chairs and vacuum cleaners, collecting points and fighting off Mafiosi -- but its lack of responsiveness made it frustrating to play.

A slew of Move games is in the works, so better ones may come along soon. But given what's out there now -- and the Move's considerable price -- I think I'd stick with the Wii.
___

SONY PLAYSTATION MOVE:

• Troy's rating: 3.0 out of 5

• Likes: Brings high-definition to motion-sensing gaming. System's webcam allows players to become game characters

• Dislikes: Pricey. Didn't work well at times. Early games generally uninspired.

• How much: $100 for accessory bundle; $400 for bundle including PlayStation 3 console and Move accessories. Navigation controller (not included in either bundle, but needed for some games) is $30

• Web: us.playstation.com

Explore further: Selfie sticks could bring jail time in South Korea

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News. Reach him at twolverton@mercurynews.com .

2.7 /5 (7 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Sedentary gaming gets a shot in the arm with Move

Sep 16, 2010

Sony Corp. gets gamers off the couch with its new motion controller, the PlayStation Move. The Move is a sensitive device with extremely accurate character and object control. It's an attractively priced add-on ...

Sony delays release of motion controller

Jan 20, 2010

(AP) -- Sony Corp. said Wednesday it has pushed back the release of its highly anticipated motion controller for the PlayStation 3 game console to the fall.

Microsoft to launch Kinect in Japan in November

Sep 08, 2010

Microsoft's long-awaited Kinect motion-sensing system for the Xbox 360 videogame console will hit the Japanese market in November, the company said Wednesday, as competition in the sector heats up.

Recommended for you

GoGlove wearable aims to control life's soundtracks

Nov 26, 2014

Technology creatives are seeing the key attraction in wearables as being in solutions that save the user from fumbling around with the phone to make app adjustments or changes, or from repeatedly taking it ...

Amazon cuts Fire phone price to ignite sales

Nov 26, 2014

Amazon on Wednesday slashed the price of Fire mobile phones that stalled after launch early this year, becoming a drag on the US online retail titan's bottom line.

Tech review: Another year, another iPad

Nov 25, 2014

Some years, Apple introduces a new version of a product and the world rejoices. Other years, the updates are more under the hood, but they still sell a ton.

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Quantum_Conundrum
5 / 5 (2) Oct 01, 2010
Historically, Nintendo's competitors have always had slightly superior consoles, but never consistently made games of the same quality.

Many Nintendo games sell solely based on the success of the previous title in the franchise, and they rarely disappoint.
KidNomad
2.3 / 5 (3) Oct 01, 2010
What you fail to mention about Sony's $400 price is everything that comes in the box. PS3 is a cd/dvd/bluray player, the Wii is not. PS3 has just been updated for free so it is now a 3D bluray player, the Wii is not. The Playstation 3 and the Move controllers are actually more responsive than the wii due to the motion tracking, I have seen more than my fair share of Wii owners having problems with the PS3 Move controllers. The PS3 and their new Move controllers are quite a step up from the limitations of the Wii. If you have a high definition television, you would like to have some high definition content to watch/interact with, and that is what the PS3 gives you. If you enjoy your Wii, then have fun, but if you are ready for an upgrade, then the PS3 is a solid choice for everyone.
Leon_S_Kennedy
5 / 5 (1) Oct 01, 2010
I have both systems and the playstation move is definetley inferior to the wii motion plus in terms of accuracy and delay. Hopefully Sony can improve the performance of move with future software.
DKoncewicz
not rated yet Oct 01, 2010
I still think kinect will be the best motion sensing technology of the three, and personally I'm still a fan of gamepads, keyboards, and mice which will still be around up until the point where they can project games right into your mind.
Magus
4 / 5 (1) Oct 02, 2010
I like how we are comparing a 4 year old Nintendo Wii tech to a 1 month old PS3 Tech.
MarkyMark
5 / 5 (1) Oct 02, 2010
I like how we are comparing a 4 year old Nintendo Wii tech to a 1 month old PS3 Tech.

Heh yea just goes to show nintendo's policy of keeping the tech simple and cheap with tech that works is still beating its rivals.
mg1
not rated yet Oct 05, 2010
@kidnomad
youre talking about a games console arent you? I personally play games on a games console and movies on a dvd/blu-player are so last century. Most movies i watch are coming to me through my computer. blu-ray/dvd players are dead technology and youll not see a replacement in a few years.
What you will see are less distinctions between tvs and computers in the future. No one in the future will be buying dvds at the local store...omg its so dated already youre making me laugh.
But if you still think dvd's will be around then the only form they will in is a usb stick, you can hire one from the video store to take home movies on it or take your own to a store and transfer the movie to it. That technology is already dead though and is already outdated in japan where they trialled it years ago.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.