Free speech group fights lawsuits vs. news sharers

Sep 30, 2010 By CRISTINA SILVA , Associated Press Writer

(AP) -- A San Francisco group that defends online free speech is taking on a Las Vegas company it says is shaking down news-sharing Internet users through more than 140 copyright infringement lawsuits filed this year.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation's counterclaim represents the first significant challenge to Righthaven LLC's unprecedented campaign to police the sharing of on blogs, political sites and personal Web pages.

At stake is what constitutes fair use - when and how it is appropriate to share content in an age where newsmakers increasingly encourage readers to share stories on Facebook, Twitter, Digg and other social networking sites.

The EFF argues that the lawsuits limit free speech and bully defendants into costly settlements by threatening $150,000 in damages and the transfer of domain names. The foundation represents Democratic Underground LLC, which Righthaven sued in August for posting parts of a Las Vegas Review-Journal article on a message board.

Many of the cases involve stories originally published by the Review-Journal, Nevada's largest newspaper and the flagship of Stephens Media LLC.

"This case is a particularly abusive instance of a broad and aggressive strategy by Stephens Media, working in conjunction with its 'little friend' Righthaven as its front and sham representative, to seek windfall recoveries of statutory damages and to exact nuisance settlements by challenging a fair use of an excerpt of an article that Stephens Media makes freely available on the Internet," says the counterclaim filed in Las Vegas federal court this week.

Righthaven's , Steve Gibson, called EFF's claims "inflammatory."

"That's just ridiculous, and the reason it is ridiculous is that I don't think there has been any defendant that we've called to shake them down for a settlement," he said.

Dozens of the lawsuits have been settled privately, and Righthaven and Stephens Media declined to disclose the terms. The EFF says the settlements have averaged about $5,000.

Movie and music producers have previously targeted individuals who illegally share copyright content. What makes Righthaven's business model unique is that it buys copyrights from news companies like Stephens Media and then aggressively files lawsuits without first giving defendants a chance to remove the content in question.

Allen Lichtenstein, a lawyer for the Nevada American Civil Liberties Union, said the lawsuits unnecessarily pursue the full force of copyright law. He is representing Lisa Linowes, a New Hampshire blogger who was sued after posting a story about wind energy from Stephens Media's Ely Times. Lichtenstein said Linowes would have immediately removed the post if Righthaven had sent a cease-and-desist order.

Other defendants include the Nevada Democratic Party, the Progressive Leadership Alliance of Nevada and Republican U.S. Senate candidate Sharron Angle.

Mark Hinueber, vice president and general counsel for Stephens Media, declined to comment on EFF's counterclaim. He has said the lawsuits help protect the company's content by discouraging would-be offenders.

But Kurt Opsahl, a senior staff attorney for the EFF, said Righthaven's goal is to drum up cash from people who can't afford to fight the lawsuits. Some of the cases involve people who cited and linked to the original source.

"This is a copyright troll," Opsahl said. "They are trying to exploit a loophole in the copyright system ... for conduct that has not really caused any harm at all."

Opsahl said the lawsuits themselves cause harm by stifling open communication.

"Linking to articles and excerpting from them is part of the lifeblood of the online community," he said. "They are not trying to hurt the Review-Journal. In fact, many of them are excited about the coverage."

Gibson said readers do not have the right to reprint content simply because a news site encourages them to post links on .

"You can't say, 'Because I believe I am doing the party I am infringing on a benefit I am entitled to do it,'" Gibson said.

The lawsuits are being closely watched by news companies that are struggling to protect their content as more people rely on the Web for news and ad revenue in printed newspapers dwindles.

Righthaven's practice of suing without first providing offenders an opportunity to remove the content has been widely debated.

"The news media has just not done stuff like this before," said Eric E. Johnson, a University of North Dakota law professor who focuses on and intellectual property issues. "The news media has this sense of public responsibility and a deep sense of ethics and the public trust ... this seems like a straightforward effort to make money. It's mean."

Explore further: Britain's UKIP issues online rules after gaffes

4.8 /5 (5 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Studios Face Tough Battle Protecting Hi-Def DVDs

May 05, 2007

Hollywood studios may find it impossible to squash a Web-based movement to facilitate the illegal copying of high-definition DVDs, even though the law is on their side, because the information has already been distributed ...

Apple files 2nd countersuit against Creative

Jun 08, 2006

(AP) -- Apple Computer Inc. has filed a second countersuit against SIngapore-based Creative Technology Ltd., intensifying its legal battle against the smaller media player rival that sued the iPod maker for ...

Industry wants to ban Minn. woman from downloading

Jul 06, 2009

(AP) -- Just weeks after a federal jury ruled that a Minnesota woman must pay $1.92 million for illegally sharing copyright-protected music, the recording industry wants to make sure she doesn't do it again.

AP proposes new article formatting for the Web

Jul 10, 2009

(AP) -- The Associated Press is proposing that publishers attach descriptive tags to news articles online in hopes of taming the free-for-all of news and information on the Web and generating more traffic for established ...

Patent holder sues smart phone makers over patents

Jul 09, 2010

(AP) -- The patent-holding company that won a settlement of more than $600 million from the maker of the BlackBerry said Friday it has sued six other companies in the smart phone industry.

Recommended for you

Britain's UKIP issues online rules after gaffes

Dec 21, 2014

UK Independence Party (UKIP), the British anti-European Union party, has ordered a crackdown on the use of social media by supporters and members following a series of controversies.

Sony saga blends foreign intrigue, star wattage

Dec 21, 2014

The hackers who hit Sony Pictures Entertainment days before Thanksgiving crippled the network, stole gigabytes of data and spilled into public view unreleased films and reams of private and sometimes embarrassing ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.