Phone group sues San Francisco over radiation law

Jul 23, 2010 By PETER SVENSSON , AP Technology Writer

(AP) -- The wireless industry sued the city of San Francisco on Friday to stop a law that requires cell phone stores to post how much radio energy each model emits.

It's the first law of that kind in the nation. The industry trade group known as CTIA - The Wireless Association said the law will mislead consumers into thinking that one phone might be safer than another on the basis of radiation measurements.

Studies have not conclusively found that is a health risk. Research continues on .

The city attorney's office had no immediate comment on the suit.

In its lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in San Francisco, the industry group also said the city is usurping the authority of the , which sets limits for phone radiation.

The local ordinance requires cell phone retailers to disclose a measure of much energy will theoretically be absorbed by a user's head. FCC limits this specific absorption rate, or SAR, to an average of 1.6 watts per kilogram. Measurements for phones sold in the U.S. are available on the agency's site, but not usually in stores.

"Nobody should be suggesting to consumers that they ought to be shopping for phones based on a difference in SAR values," said John Walls, vice president for public affairs at CTIA. "There's no scientific basis to suggest, as the ordinance does, that two phones with different values have a safety distinction between them," as long as they're below the FCC's limit.

Under the law, larger chains will have to place SAR notices starting in February, while other stores will have until 2012.

The lawsuit is not the first response from CTIA. The association, which represents all major , usually holds a trade show in San Francisco in the fall. After the law was passed, CTIA announced that it would hold the show as planned this year, then look for another host city.

"We thought it was a clear message from the mayor that we weren't wanted there," Walls said.

San Francisco is known for novel legislation. It has banned plastic grocery bags, ended municipal use of bottled water, made composting mandatory and required the posting of nutrition information in restaurants.

Explore further: DOCOMO and Huawei confirm LTE network over unlicensed spectrum

4 /5 (1 vote)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Maine to consider cell phone cancer warning

Dec 21, 2009

(AP) -- A Maine legislator wants to make the state the first to require cell phones to carry warnings that they can cause brain cancer, although there is no consensus among scientists that they do and industry leaders dispute ...

San Fran: Mobile Phones Need Warning Attached

Jun 17, 2010

San Francisco is set to be the first place in the nation to require that retailers tell consumers how much radiation their brain will absorb from new phones. The ordinance -- approved on Tuesday and now awaiting ...

IRS, Treasury want cell phone tax repealed

Jun 17, 2009

(AP) -- Remember the last time you used a company cell phone for a quick personal call - or text or e-mail? Did you record the value of that call and pay taxes on it as income?

Cell execs say more steps needed to meet demand

Mar 23, 2010

(AP) -- Cell phone company executives support a proposal by federal regulators to find more wireless spectrum for mobile broadband services, but say the industry needs to do more to help networks keep up with the demand ...

Recommended for you

Bringing emergency communications together

Aug 21, 2014

A new University of Adelaide research project aims to improve emergency operations through integrated communications systems for police and the emergency services.

For top broadband policy, look no further than Canada

Aug 20, 2014

You might have seen communications minister Malcolm Turnbull raising the issue about Australian press not discussing policy problems and solutions from overseas, in a speech delivered at the Lowy Institute Media Awards last week: ...

Cities, states face off on municipal broadband

Aug 19, 2014

Wilson, N.C., determined nearly a decade ago that high-speed Internet access would be essential to the community's social and economic health in the 21st century, just as electricity, water and sewers were in the previous ...

New loss mechanism for global 4G roaming

Aug 19, 2014

A loss mechanism that has not been an issue in previous mobile handset antennas will become important for global 4G roaming, according to results of experiments carried out in Aalborg, Denmark.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

tarheelchief
not rated yet Jul 25, 2010
Have the City of San Francisco pay for the personnel
who must certify every phone carried into the city.I believe the authors of this legislation have an ulterior motive in mind.
Granted many people inside this SF display tendencies similar to those who participated in shock therapy.
I don't think the telephones are to blame since many other cities like Boston,LA,New York, and Miami see the same kind of behaviors.