Grandparents favor genetically close grandchildren

Apr 29, 2010 by Lin Edwards report
This image shows the coding region in a segment of eukaryotic DNA. Courtesy: National Human Genome Research Institute

( -- New research suggests that grandparents naturally and subconsciously favor the grandchildren who are most closely related to them genetically. The phenomenon is called "sexually antagonistic grandparental care," and it has been known for some time that a grandmother will naturally prefer her son's daughters (with whom she shares 31 percent of her genes) to her son's sons (with whom she shares only 23 percent, suggesting she will most nurture the grandchild who inherits more of her genes.

Dr Urban Friberg of the University of California, Santa Barbara and colleagues used mathematical methods to test the supposition that grandparents “differentially” care for grandchildren according to their lineage and gender.

A father has an XY chromosome pair, with the X derived from his mother and the Y derived from his father. He passes copies of the X to his daughters and Y to his sons. This has evolutionary consequences, according to Friberg’s team, because of the innate drive to ensure the survival of our in future generations. The team developed a new paradigm they called the “no-cost-to-self nepotism” rule to generate predictions about the behaviors of .

The major prediction the group found was that (and to a lesser degree, grandfathers) will evolve grandson-harming that effectively reduce the competition between siblings, and favor their more closely related granddaughters, especially daughters of their sons (who have definitely inherited the grandmother’s ).

Women always know their children are their own, while fathers always have some uncertainty because of the possibility they were cuckolded. This means maternal grandmothers know for certain their grandchildren are recipients of copies of their genes, while paternal grandfathers are doubly uncertain about the genetic inheritance of their grandchildren. The results of the current research supports the findings of previous studies that showed a baby girl’s chances of survival are increased if a paternal grandmother cares for her, while a boy’s chances are diminished. If a maternal grandmother is involved, the boys have improved chances of survival.

The results of the study are published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

Explore further: Evolution of stem cells traced in study of fossilized rodent teeth

More information: William R. Rice et al., The evolution of sex-specific grandparental harm, Proceedings of the Royal Society B, Published online before print April 28, 2010, doi:10.1098/rspb.2010.0409

Related Stories

The health burden of raising a grandchild

Nov 07, 2008

Precautionary health measures such as mammograms and cholesterol tests that identify the risk of heart disease are critical for the well-being of women over 50. Add the responsibility of providing sustained care for a grandchild, ...

Grandma and grandpa are good for children

Jun 04, 2008

The first national survey about the relationships that adolescents have with their grandparents shows that grandparents who are involved in the upbringing of their grandchildren can contribute to a child’s ...

Recommended for you

York's anti-malarial plant given Chinese approval

Apr 24, 2015

A new hybrid plant used in anti-malarial drug production, developed by scientists at the University of York's Centre for Novel Agricultural Products (CNAP), is now registered as a new variety in China.

The appeal of being anti-GMO

Apr 24, 2015

A team of Belgian philosophers and plant biotechnologists have turned to cognitive science to explain why opposition to genetically modified organisms (GMOs) has become so widespread, despite positive contributions ...

Micro fingers for arranging single cells

Apr 24, 2015

Functional analysis of a cell, which is the fundamental unit of life, is important for gaining new insights into medical and pharmaceutical fields. For efficiently studying cell functions, it is essential ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Apr 29, 2010
"especially daughters of their sons (who have definitely inherited the grandmothers X chromosome)."

"Definitely" is an awful strong term to describe a child who may or may not be their son's depending upon the fidelity of the daughter-in-law. I should think they would favor their daughters daughters since they know for certain whose womb they came out of.
not rated yet Apr 30, 2010
There are so many socio-cultural forces acting here that making such claims will seem absolutely unfounded for majority of population of the world. In Asia and Arab region the birth of a boy is always favouarable (unfortunately so), especially for the father's side of the family, so a grandmother will 99% of times favour her son's son rather than her son's daughter, it is very commonplace to see the son's daughter being neglected unfairly in favour of the son's son.
The researcher's need to learn a lot about human beings.
not rated yet May 02, 2010
I should think they would favor their daughters daughters since they know for certain whose womb they came out of.

Yes but those granddaughters don't necessarily have to carry the grandmother's X, they might carry the grandfather's X and the father's X instead.

But yeah I agree not entirely convinced by this study either.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.