Musical illusion fools audiences and performers, says researcher

Jan 05, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Musicians take advantage of a previously undocumented musical illusion to change the way audiences hear their performances. Intriguingly, the performers themselves are generally unaware of what they are doing.

Visual information can have a profound impact on how we experience live music, creating an illusion where percussive sounds seem longer or shorter than they really are.

In an article published in a recent edition of the journal Percussive Notes, Michael Schutz, assistant professor in the Department of Music at McMaster University describes how expert musicians take advantage of a previously undocumented musical through visible physical gestures to change the way audiences hear their performances. Intriguingly, the performers themselves are generally unaware of what they are doing.

Using videos of a world-renowned percussionist Michael Burritt, Schutz found that the length of the physical gesture - the up-down motion used to strike a percussion instrument - has no effect on acoustic duration of musical notes. In other words, notes produced using long and short motions are acoustically indistinguishable. But when study participants were watching the gestures as well as listening, the notes sounded long or short due to their brains' integration of auditory and .

"Although physical gestures fail to change the sound of a note, they can change the way a note sounds," explains Schutz, who is affiliated with the McMaster Institute for Music and the Mind. "It's very much like the well-known 'ventriloquist illusion' in which we think the speech or sound is coming from the lips of a mute puppet."

This raises some interesting questions about how music is best experienced, he says. In this context, performers can only realize their musical intentions through the use of visual information. Therefore, do CDs, mp3s and radio broadcasts capture the full musical experience, or do they instead rob performers and listeners of an important dimension of musical communication?

Not only do expert musicians "trick" their audiences, they in fact trick themselves. Many professional musicians believe their gestures change the acoustic information they produce. Although this research demonstrates they have no acoustic effect, these gestures accidentally accomplish their goal by instead changing an audience's perception.

"Sound becomes music only within the mind of the listener," says Schutz. "Therefore that change the sound within the mind have done more than 'alter perception'. They have effectively changed the music."

Explore further: When it comes to how pizza looks, cheese matters

Related Stories

Music makes you smarter

Oct 26, 2009

Regularly playing a musical instrument changes the anatomy and function of the brain and may be used in therapy to improve cognitive skills.

Taking up music so you can hear

Aug 17, 2009

Anyone with an MP3 device -- just about every man, woman and child on the planet today, it seems -- has a notion of the majesty of music, of the primal place it holds in the human imagination.

Ray Charles really did have that swing

Dec 04, 2006

Ray Charles was really good at snapping, said musical acoustician Kenneth Lindsay of Southern Oregon University in Ashland. Charles's snaps that open "It Don't Mean a Thing (If It Ain't Got That Swing)" are timed so well ...

Recommended for you

When it comes to how pizza looks, cheese matters

Aug 21, 2014

Most consumers have an idea what they want their pizza slice to look like. Golden cheese with that dark toasted-cheese color scattered in distinct blistery patches across the surface with a bit of oil glistening in the valleys. ...

Freedom and responsibility of science

Aug 21, 2014

Yesterday, the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the Leopoldina National Academy of Sciences presented their recommendations for "The Freedom and Responsibility of Science" in Berlin. Both research organizations appeal ...

What I learned from debating science with trolls

Aug 20, 2014

I often like to discuss science online and I'm also rather partial to topics that promote lively discussion, such as climate change, crime statistics and (perhaps surprisingly) the big bang. This inevitably ...

Activists urge EU to scrap science advisor job

Aug 19, 2014

Nine major charities urged the European Commission on Tuesday to scrap a science advisor position it says puts too much power over sensitive policy into the hands of one person.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

KBK
5 / 5 (1) Jan 06, 2010
This falls right into the aspect of people using gestures for inflection in speech to aid in the viewer/listener 'getting' the full intent of the speech delivered. Same mechanism, methinks.