Colorado county copes with methane mystery

Nov 02, 2009 By JUDITH KOHLER , Associated Press Writer
In this photograph taken on Monday, Aug. 10, 2009, Ben Bounds stands next to a pipe that vents methane away from his water well on his land outside of Walsenburg, Colo. Area residents are experiencing problems with their wells since drilling for natural gas started around the southeast Colorado community. (AP Photo/Judith Kohler)

(AP) -- Bernice and Jerry Angely like to show visitors the singed T-shirt a friend was wearing when their water well exploded and shot flames 30 feet high.

The friend wasn't hurt. But that and an explosion at another home weeks earlier forced Colorado to suspend natural gas drilling around this southern plains town until someone could find out why dangerous levels of methane were getting into the groundwater.

Two years later, Walsenburg and surrounding Huerfano County are still waiting, its residents caught in a collision between two of the West's vital resources: and natural gas.

"The water is so saturated with methane and other chemicals it is not to be used for human consumption," said Bernice Angely, who's had water trucked to her home 10 miles west of town since her well blew up in July 2007.

Petroglyph Energy Inc., a Boise, Idaho-based firm that has worked the rolling plains of the Raton Basin since 1999, suspended drilling until it can stem the methane. Colorado also is rewriting rules that had allowed Petroglyph to discharge water runoff from its drilling into streams and creeks.

But Petroglyph says it's not clear the drilling caused the methane leaks or prompted other area water wells to run dry. Eying what it calls an extremely promising natural gas field, it believes a shallow water formation tapped by area homeowners isn't connected to a deeper one pumped by the company for its drilling operations.

Petroglyph chief operating officer Paul Powell also believes a growing number of new homes in the area could explain some of the dry water wells.

"We'll do what we need to do," Powell said, stressing that his firm is working with the state on a solution.

Petroglyph has a plan to prevent the flow of methane into water wells by creating a hydraulic barrier. The company has proposed pumping water from an underground formation and injecting it into a row of wells where gas drilling occurs. Powell said gas will migrate into a void, and "if the void is full of water, there isn't room for gas to migrate through it."

State regulators say the plan is plausible but that Petroglyph needs to prove it works. Democratic U.S. Rep. John Salazar, who farms in the nearby San Luis Valley, has asked the U.S. Geological Survey to weigh in by evaluating the area's water quality and formations to determine if the gas drilling is to blame for the problems.

Water coursing through porous rock and streams has allowed farming, ranching and new subdivisions to thrive in the semiarid area about 160 miles south of Denver.

It also helps trap methane gas in the vast coal seams that once made the area a mining hot spot. The coal mines are gone, but the methane that made digging for it dangerous is a valuable resource. Companies like Petroglyph pump huge volumes of water out of the ground to relieve the pressure trapping the natural gas.

Steve Gunderson, director of Colorado's water quality control division, said Petroglyph will have to build a water treatment plant before it gets a new permit to discharge water. The old permit allowed Petroglyph to release up to 8 million gallons of water daily.

Fourth-generation dairy farmer Brett Corsentino blames the discharges into the Cucharas River for ruining his corn crops. He uses river water to irrigate his crops just a few miles east of the homeowners having problems with their wells. He says the high levels of sodium in the wastewater has diminished his soil's ability to absorb water and stunted the corn's growth.

"They say, `Well, there's no proof,'" Corsentino said. "Well, we'd been getting along for generations just fine until they started pumping 8 million gallons out of this country."

Corsentino also says his herd suffered abnormally high birth and death rates and now numbers 400, down from 650. He believes the cows consumed too much sodium from the water and corn grown from it. His corn used to produce 6,000 tons of silage; this year's crop yielded 1,500 tons.

However, Corsentino says his herd is healthier and milk production has increased since drilling stopped.

"There's an obvious direct, substantial impact to Brett Corsentino's dairy," the state's Gunderson said of the drilling.

Petroglyph paid for soil tests on Corsentino's farm. They showed high levels of sodium but that it also needed more calcium, Powell said. Petroglyph and Corsentino are discussing possible treatments.

"We still don't believe we have liability for the situation," Powell said. "But we were willing to help him fix his land and get back to productivity."

Ten miles west of Walsenburg, a rushing sound emanates from a pipe that vents methane from Ben and Melanie Bounds' water well. The pipe was installed after a June 2007 explosion blew off a shed roof covering the well.

The Bounds had moved from Dallas to build what they call their dream home atop a hill with a breathtaking view of the Spanish Peaks. They say their problems started when Petroglyph began drilling nearby. They're suing the company and haul water from town to their cistern.

"If I could run the clock back, we'd have never tried this," Ben Bounds said.

"I had more methane coming out of my water well than they had out of any of their gas wells. It sounded like a locomotive going down the road," said Kent Smith, who also has a methane detector in his house. "The damage and the problems they've caused have got to be addressed, and they keep getting pushed aside and forgotten about."

Petroglyph insists it's a good neighbor. Despite the methane mystery, it's trucking water to 14 area homes and has supplied 15 homes with alarm systems.

---

On the Net:

Petroglyph Energy Inc., http://tinyurl.com/ybfpcco

Walsenburg 2009 Drinking Water Consumer Confidence Report for Calendar Year 2008, http://tinyurl.com/yenabct

©2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Explore further: Five anthropogenic factors that will radically alter northern forests in 50 years

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Uranium mining prospect worries neighbors

Nov 17, 2006

A company wanting to mine for uranium in south Texas said a strike would be an alternative fuel dream while opponents said it's an environmental nightmare.

Gas hydrates research expedition begins

Sep 23, 2005

An international team of scientists has started a six-week expedition off the coast of Vancouver Island to conduct research beneath the Earth's crust.

Methane doesn't necessarily mean life on Mars

Jun 07, 2005

Two Dartmouth researchers have weighed in on the debate over whether the presence of methane gas on Mars indicates life on the red planet. Mukul Sharma, Assistant Professor of Earth Sciences, and Chris Oze, a postdoctoral fellow, ...

Recommended for you

More, bigger wildfires burning western US, study shows

10 hours ago

Wildfires across the western United States have been getting bigger and more frequent over the last 30 years – a trend that could continue as climate change causes temperatures to rise and drought to become ...

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

jerryd
1 / 5 (1) Nov 02, 2009

If I had that methane coming from my well I'd be using it to heat my home, make, sell electricity rather than flaring it off.

That said the gas industry needs to do far better as problems like this are happening most everywhere they are drilling. If they don't, the regulations need to be passed.
otto1923
not rated yet Nov 02, 2009
Yeah you'd think there'd be a plug-in capture system for the gas and that people would be drilling their own gas wells to get it. That along with a water filtration system and you'd be self-sufficient. Why not? Is there a problem with quality or something?
Nik_2213
not rated yet Nov 02, 2009
Is this one of the cases where the gas company has bought the rights to *all* the gas ? So you must let it go to waste from your land rather than use even a cup full ? IIRC, there are similar restrictions on rain-water collection in some areas, where adding a water-butt to your down-spout brings the legal eagles to feast on your gizzard...
holoman
1 / 5 (1) Nov 02, 2009
The air quality has to be really bad.

The methane would be a good energy source if
the carbon could be removed before or after
burning.
defunctdiety
3 / 5 (2) Nov 02, 2009
The air quality has to be really bad.

The methane would be a good energy source if
the carbon could be removed before or after
burning.

Please get a clue before you talk like you understand something (this includes AGW).

1st, METHANE IS NOT TOXIC, not an ambient air quality concern, only a concern in enclosed places because it displaces air.

2nd, if you COULD remove carbon before burning (which you can't without burning it - i.e. that's what burning does, separates the hydrogen and carbons), there would be nothing to burn, those carbon-hydrogen bonds are where all the energy comes from.

Thank you holoman for illustrating why AGW is failing.

i.e. People are getting educated. Seriously this misinformation perpetuated by AGW is infuriating. Here we have an average Joe, thinking CH4 is the freaking devil I imagine because of AGW. Horrible! Read a book people, learn to learn and think for yourself, please!
otto1923
not rated yet Nov 02, 2009
So can we use it as it comes from the ground or not? Is it clean or moisture-free, variable quality, are there plug-in systems for this or can we make money by selling them?
defunctdiety
4 / 5 (1) Nov 03, 2009
So can we use it as it comes from the ground or not?

I suppose it depends on how the methane got there (the water well). But no matter what, for a private person to make it usable would probably be very expensive (harvesting, compressing, generation, transmission equipment). It would also be dirty (sulfur,nitrogen,metal impurities) and wet, also diffuse. Commercial operations have extensive dehydration and refining (sweetening) processes. Judging from the article: "Colorado also is rewriting rules that had allowed Petroglyph to discharge water runoff from its drilling into streams and creeks." the methane got in the wells from waste-water of the dehydration and sweetening process, but could also have gotten there if the energy company injected water below where the natural gas was thought to be, to push it up.

If they just flare it off, it wouldn't be hard to stick a boiler on that and get at least something off of it, but that would be the dirtiest and most inefficient use.

More news stories

There's something ancient in the icebox

Glaciers are commonly thought to work like a belt sander. As they move over the land they scrape off everything—vegetation, soil, and even the top layer of bedrock. So scientists were greatly surprised ...

China says massive area of its soil polluted

A huge area of China's soil covering more than twice the size of Spain is estimated to be polluted, the government said Thursday, announcing findings of a survey previously kept secret.

Clean air: Fewer sources for self-cleaning

Up to now, HONO, also known as nitrous acid, was considered one of the most important sources of hydroxyl radicals (OH), which are regarded as the detergent of the atmosphere, allowing the air to clean itself. ...

Better thermal-imaging lens from waste sulfur

Sulfur left over from refining fossil fuels can be transformed into cheap, lightweight, plastic lenses for infrared devices, including night-vision goggles, a University of Arizona-led international team ...

Hackathon team's GoogolPlex gives Siri extra powers

(Phys.org) —Four freshmen at the University of Pennsylvania have taken Apple's personal assistant Siri to behave as a graduate-level executive assistant which, when asked, is capable of adjusting the temperature ...

Chronic inflammation linked to 'high-grade' prostate cancer

Men who show signs of chronic inflammation in non-cancerous prostate tissue may have nearly twice the risk of actually having prostate cancer than those with no inflammation, according to results of a new study led by researchers ...