Previously Unknown Volcanic Eruption Helped Trigger Cold Decade

Oct 29, 2009 By Kim McDonald and Lance Nixon
The previously unknown eruption in 1809 was larger than the Mt. Pinatubo eruption. Credit: USGS

(PhysOrg.com) -- A team of chemists from the U.S. and France has found compelling evidence of a previously undocumented large volcanic eruption that occurred exactly 200 years ago, in 1809.

The discovery, published online this week in the scientific journal , offers an explanation as to why the decade from 1810 to 1819 is regarded by scientists as the coldest on record for the past 500 years.

“We’ve never seen any evidence of this eruption in Greenland that corresponds to a simultaneous explosion recorded in Antarctica before in the glacial record,” said Mark Thiemens, Dean of the Division of Physical Sciences at UC San Diego and one of the co-authors of the study. “But if you look at the size of the signal we found in the ice cores, it had to be huge. It was bigger than the 1991 eruption of Mount Pinatubo in the Philippines, which killed hundreds of people and affected climate around the world.”

Led by a chemist from South Dakota State University, the team of scientists made its discovery after analyzing chemicals in ice samples from Antarctica and Greenland in the Arctic, where the scientists visited and drilled ice cores three years ago. The year-by-year accumulation of snow in the polar ice sheets records what is going on in the atmosphere.

“We found large amount of volcanic in the snow layers of 1809 and 1810 in both Greenland and Antarctica,” said professor Jihong Cole-Dai of SDSU’s Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, who was the lead author of the paper.

Joël Savarino of the Laboratoire de Glaciologie et Géophysique de l’Environment in Grenoble, France, and a former postdoctoral fellow at UC San Diego, was also part of the team.

Previously Unknown Volcanic Eruption Helped Trigger Cold Decade
UCSD’s Mark Thiemens (upper left) pulls a cylinder in Greenland containing an ice core. Credit: UCSD

Cole-Dai said climate records show that not only were 1816 — the so-called “year without a summer”— and the following years very cold, the entire decade from 1810 to 1819 was probably the coldest for at least the past 500 years.

Scientists have long been aware that the massive and violent eruption in 1815 of an Indonesian volcano called Tambora, which killed more than 88,000 people in Indonesia, had caused the worldwide cold weather in 1816 and after. Volcanic eruptions have a cooling effect on the planet because they release sulfur gases into the atmosphere that form sulfuric acid aerosols that block sunlight. But the cold temperatures in the early part of the decade, before that eruption, suggest Tambora alone could not have caused the climatic changes of the decade.

“Our new evidence is that the volcanic sulfuric acid came down at the opposite poles at precisely the same time, and this means that the sulfate is from a single large eruption of a volcano in 1809,” Cole-Dai said. “The Tambora eruption and the undocumented 1809 eruption are together responsible for the unusually cold decade.”

Cole-Dai said the Tambora eruption was immense, sending about 100 million tons of sulfur gas into the atmosphere, but the samples suggests the 1809 eruption was also very large — perhaps half the size of Tambora — and would also have cooled the earth for a few years. The researchers reason that, because the sulfuric acid is found in the ice from both polar regions, the eruption probably occurred in the tropics, as Tambora did, where wind patterns could carry volcanic material to the entire world, including both poles.

Cole-Dai said the research specifically looked for and found a special indicator of sulfuric acid produced from the volcanic sulfur gas in the stratosphere.

The special indicator is an unusual make-up of sulfur isotopes in the volcanic sulfuric acid. Isotopes are different types of atoms of the same chemical element, each having a different number of neutrons (but the same number of protons). The unique sulfur isotope composition is like a fingerprint of volcanic material that has reached the stratosphere, said Cole-Dai.

The stratosphere is the second major layer of the Earth’s atmosphere, reaching from about six miles to about 30 miles above the Earth’s surface at moderate latitudes. To impact global climate, rather than local weather, the sulfur gas of a has to reach up into the stratosphere and once there, be spread around the globe.

“The way in which that these volcanoes affected the average temperatures of our planet gives us a better idea of how particulates in the atmosphere can affect our climate,” said Thiemens. “People talk about the possibility of geo-engineering our climate, but the question is how? In this case, nature has done an experiment for us.”

Provided by University of California - San Diego (news : web)

Explore further: Jeju Island is a live volcano, study reveals

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

1600 eruption caused global disruption

Apr 23, 2008

The 1600 eruption of Huaynaputina in Peru had a global impact on human society, according to a new study of contemporary records by geologists at UC Davis.

Volcanoes cool the tropics, say researchers

Jan 05, 2009

Climate researchers have shown that big volcanic eruptions over the past 450 years have temporarily cooled weather in the tropics—but suggest that such effects may have been masked in the 20th century by ...

First evidence of under-ice volcanic eruption in Antarctica

Jan 20, 2008

The first evidence of a volcanic eruption from beneath Antarctica’s most rapidly changing ice sheet is reported this week in the journal Nature Geosciences. The volcano on the West Antarctic Ice Sheet erupted 2000 years ...

Recommended for you

Jeju Island is a live volcano, study reveals

3 hours ago

In Jeju, a place emerging as a world-famous vacation spot with natural tourism resources, a recent study revealed a volcanic eruption occurred on the island. The Korea Institute of Geoscience and Mineral ...

Has Antarctic sea ice expansion been overestimated?

3 hours ago

New research suggests that Antarctic sea ice may not be expanding as fast as previously thought. A team of scientists say much of the increase measured for Southern Hemisphere sea ice could be due to a processing ...

Antarctic lakes theory dries up

6 hours ago

(Phys.org) —Antarctica is the driest continent on Earth, and always has been, with new research showing the previous "mega-lake theory" holds no water.

User comments : 9

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

paulthebassguy
4.3 / 5 (4) Oct 29, 2009
So do they have any theories on which actual volcano in the tropics this could have been?
Sonhouse
3 / 5 (4) Oct 30, 2009
So do they have any theories on which actual volcano in the tropics this could have been?


The only evidence so far is just the ice data from two locations so there is no way to pinpoint what geographical area it would have come from except to say it was in the tropics somewhere.
out7x
3.8 / 5 (4) Oct 30, 2009
This article should also talk about the dust layer composition, which is also a unique fingerprint.
gtownsend
5 / 5 (2) Oct 30, 2009
Perhaps a submarine volcano in the region of Vanuatu. Kuwae, for example, one of the largest eruptions in the past 500 years, likely in excess of VEI +7. Its climatic effects are suspected to have been cause of the torrential "blood rain" coincident with the fall of Constantinople in 1453. http://www.volcan...0507-07=
jerryd
5 / 5 (1) Oct 30, 2009

They are a lot of other things in these eruptions besides SOx that cause cooling. So let's stop simplifying it and include them too. It's likely SOx is the cause of less than 50% of the cooling.
marjon
2 / 5 (4) Oct 30, 2009
Given that a volcano can erupt at anytime, Gore's minions want to artificially cool the earth in the same way.
What happens if they implement their plan and a volcano erupts magnifying the effect? Oops?

It is easier to grow food in a warmer climate than a colder one.
The_Bobs
4.3 / 5 (3) Oct 31, 2009
Previously unknown? This is not true. Here is a link to a journal article from 2002 that mentions the still mysterious 1809 eruption. link There are others prior to this anouncement as well.

Of course, since the volcano has not been identified it is still unknown.
The_Bobs
4 / 5 (3) Oct 31, 2009
Guess I can't use html here. URL of above article: http://www.ingent...art00037
Ninderthana
3 / 5 (2) Oct 31, 2009
Is it just possible that the large number of big volcanic eruptions between 1783 and 1816 (bracketed by the Laki eruption of 1783 in Iceland and Lake Tambora volcanic eruption in 1816)
was a actually a symptom of a more fundamental underlying factor that caused the overall cooling event?

I do not believe that it was just a coincidence that the Dalton minimum (i.e. a 30 year hyatis in level of solar activity) also occured at this time.

"Modern" Science efficiently compartmentalizes the evidence, preventing us from seeing the bigger picture that is sitting right in front of our faces.