Analysis: 'Cash for Clunkers' program is expensive way to cut carbon emissions

Aug 14, 2009

New UC Davis estimates say the federal government's Cash for Clunkers program is paying at least 10 times the "sticker price" to reduce emissions of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide.

While carbon credits are projected to sell in the U.S. for about $28 per ton (today's price in Europe was $20), even the best-case calculation of the cost of the clunkers rebate is $237 per ton, said UC Davis transportation economist Christopher Knittel.

"When burned, a gallon of creates roughly 20 pounds of . I combined that known value with an average rebate of $4,200 and a range of assumptions about the of the new vehicles purchased and how long the clunkers would have been on the road if not for the program," Knittel said. "I even assumed drivers didn't change their habits, although some analysts have suggested that the owners of new vehicles will drive more than they would have with their old cars.

"In the end, the lowest cost to remove one ton of carbon from the environment was $237. More likely scenarios produced a cost of more than $500 per ton, even when we accounted for reductions in pollutants other than greenhouse gases. That suggests the Cash for Clunkers program is an expensive way to reduce carbon."

Knittel did not analyze the program's other key objectives: stimulating the economy and providing relief for automobile manufacturers.

More information: The analysis, titled "The Implied Cost of Carbon Dioxide Under the Cash for Clunkers Program," was published online today (Aug. 13) by the University of California Energy Institute. It was funded by the Energy Institute and the Institute of Transportation Studies.

Source: University of California - Davis

Explore further: MEPs back plans to slash use of plastic shopping bags

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

'Cash for clunkers' effect on pollution? A blip

Aug 05, 2009

(AP) -- "Cash for clunkers" could have the same effect on global warming pollution as shutting down the entire country - every automobile, every factory, every power plant - for an hour per year. That could ...

US to push plan to swap for fuel efficient cars

May 05, 2009

A key US lawmaker Tuesday announced agreement after White House talks on a plan to offer Americans government cash to trade in "old clunkers" -- ancient, gas guzzling cars -- for fuel efficient models.

Pricing can cut CO2 emissions from electric generators

Apr 28, 2008

Levying a price on carbon dioxide released by electric generators could considerably reduce greenhouse gas emissions — even before the deployment of any environmentally friendly technology — according to scientists in ...

Agricultural soil erosion is not adding to global warming

Oct 26, 2007

Agricultural soil erosion is not a source of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere, according to research published online today (October 25) in the journal Science. The study was carried out by an international team of resear ...

Recommended for you

Researchers question emergency water treatment guidelines

16 hours ago

The Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA's) recommendations for treating water after a natural disaster or other emergencies call for more chlorine bleach than is necessary to kill disease-causing pathogens ...

European climate at the +2 C global warming threshold

18 hours ago

A global warming of 2 C relative to pre-industrial climate has been considered as a threshold which society should endeavor to remain below, in order to limit the dangerous effects of anthropogenic climate change.

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (3) Aug 14, 2009
The CARS program was a welfare handout to the Vehicle corporations.

Government released reports state that the majority of vehicles purchased under the cash for clunkers program were SUV's. Good show....
2 / 5 (1) Aug 14, 2009
You're right, the program is only about carbon reduction and not a semi-popular plan to put purchasing and economic power into the hands of consumers. Dollar per ton must logically be the environmental save all, all the time!

Fueling the desire for appropriation into feasible and newer, more efficient technology will do more than blowing your load on a calculator because you found out cash for clunkers isn't perfectly tailored for the green binge you're on. Grow up Davis.
1 / 5 (1) Aug 16, 2009
The purpose of the program is to promote fuel economy and to provide a boost in business to the car manufacturers. Carbon reduction is way down the list. At any rate, coal is where that aim should be targeted.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 17, 2009
I'd argue the waste is much greater. Were the "clunkers" even being driven on a regular basis? I doubt it. Tell me: how many people wealthy enough to buy a NEW car were heavily driving a real clunker before CARS?

Those traded in were largely "spare" cars, seldom driven but kept as backups for use when the good car is at the repair shop, golf course or shopping mall. Removing them from use does not seriously impact polution, fuel prices or CO2 emissions.

Remember, there are over 150 million cars and light trucks registered in the US. Destroying 750,000 was never going to have much impact, but if they were sparingly used, the impact is even less.

Finally... realize the cars destroyed represent at least $750,000,000 of remaining value that that could have helped poor people and the disabled go to work at a job or be taken to doctors appointments, independently, with a measure of freedom.

More news stories

Melting during cooling period

( —A University of Maine research team says stratification of the North Atlantic Ocean contributed to summer warming and glacial melting in Scotland during the period recognized for abrupt cooling ...

Warm US West, cold East: A 4,000-year pattern

Last winter's curvy jet stream pattern brought mild temperatures to western North America and harsh cold to the East. A University of Utah-led study shows that pattern became more pronounced 4,000 years ago, ...

'Chief Yahoo' David Filo returns to board

Yahoo announced the nomination of three new board members, including company co-founder David Filo, who earned the nickname and formal job title of "Chief Yahoo."

New clinical trial launched for advance lung cancer

Cancer Research UK is partnering with pharmaceutical companies AstraZeneca and Pfizer to create a pioneering clinical trial for patients with advanced lung cancer – marking a new era of research into personalised medicines ...

More vets turn to prosthetics to help legless pets

A 9-month-old boxer pup named Duncan barreled down a beach in Oregon, running full tilt on soft sand into YouTube history and showing more than 4 million viewers that he can revel in a good romp despite lacking ...