It's All Relative: UCSD's Einstein Robot Has 'Emotional Intelligence' (Video)

Feb 13, 2009
The research team chose Albert Einstein as the model for their emotionally intelligent robot "because he's an icon of creativity, intelligence and science; he's emotionally accessible; he's lovable and visually recognizable very easily around the world," says Hanson.

(PhysOrg.com) -- Albert Einstein may have written his last scientific theory more than half a century ago, but he's still honing his emotional intelligence in a laboratory at the University of California, San Diego.

Scientists at UC San Diego's California Institute for Telecommunications and Information Technology (Calit2) have equipped a robot modeled after the famed theoretical physicist with specialized software that allows it to interact with humans in a relatively natural, conversational way. The so-called "Einstein Robot," which was designed by Hanson Robotics of Dallas, Texas, recognizes a number of human facial expressions and can respond accordingly. Scientists consider it an unparalleled tool for understanding how both robots and humans perceive emotion, as well as a potential platform for teaching, entertainment, fine arts and even cognitive therapy.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Watch Einstein in action.

"In the short-term, Einstein is being used to develop computer vision so we can see how computers perceive facial expressions and develop hardware to visually react," says Javier Movellan, a research scientist in the Calit2-based UCSD Machine Perception Laboratory (MPL). "This robot is a scientific instrument that we hope will tell us something about human-robot interaction, but also human-to-human interaction.

"When a robot interacts in a way we feel is human, we can't help but react. Developing a robot like this one teaches us how sensitive we are to biological movement and facial expressions, and when we get it right, it's really astonishing."

The Einstein Robot — a head-and-shoulders automaton complete with unruly white hair and bushy mustache — made its public debut at the Technology, Entertainment and Design (TED) conference in Long Beach last week. David Hanson, the robot's primary designer and owner of Hanson Robotics, amazed a crowd of 1,500 with Einstein's capacity to understand and mimic expressions. Several graduate students from the MPL accompanied Hanson to the conference, which was established to facilitate creative collaborations among scientists, entrepreneurs and designers.

Evoking realistic facial expressions in a machine made of wires and gears is no small feat, Hanson says. For Einstein to crack a smile, 17 of the robot's 31 motors must whir into action and subtly adjust multiple points of articulation around his mouth and piercing brown eyes. To express confusion, Einstein furrows his brow, but even that movement — which is second nature for most humans — is difficult to re-create in a robot. To achieve a realistic result, Hanson constructed Einstein's face from a patented, flesh-like material known as Frubber™, which he created after extensive research into facial anatomy, physiology, materials science and soft-bodied mechanical engineering. Hanson even went so far as to fashion the Frubber™ with realistic pores that measure in the macro-molecular scale at 4 to 40 nanometers — requiring him to take a crash course in nanotechnology.

"I know how the face needs to look when it deforms into a given expression, and I can see when an expression looks good," notes Hanson, a former Disney Imagineer. "But in addition to all these science and engineering studies, there's a certain magic of facial aesthetics that's beyond the scope of scientists. Artists understand it somehow, and are able to externalize facial movements and conversational interaction in external media like sculpture and film animation. However, this has not been successfully imported to robotics. Instead of sculpting it in marble, I have to get the Frubber™ material and the internal mechanisms to move into that expression on demand, and achieve that expression in the context of an interaction with a human."

The robot's internal facial recognition software is what provides that context. Developed by Movellan and a team of graduate students at Calit2, the software is based on a series of computational algorithms derived from an analysis of more than one million facial images. It allows Einstein to understand and respond to a number of "perceptual primitives," such as expressions of sadness, anger, fear, happiness and confusion, as well as facial cues suggesting age and gender (even whether the person interacting with the robot is wearing glasses). The robot's parallel facial action coding system can detect simple gestures like nods, and mimic those reactions.

Movellan, working with Jacobs School of Engineering computer science professor Yoav Freund, also succeeded in getting the robot to respond to audio cues such as clapping, which might prove helpful were Einstein to be used in an educational setting, for example. Movellan says he's hoping to have the robot's operational system fully integrated by June so that it can be deployed as a prototype robot teacher in a local high school, in much the same way that MPL's RUBI robot has been used to teach pre-schoolers.

Another important part of the robot's inner workings is its Character Engine Artificial Intelligence Control Software, which allows the programmer to author and define the persona of the character so it can hold a conversation.

"Einstein has pretty broad conversational abilities, although not like a human," Hanson notes. "In the demo mode, he might say something like, 'I'm an advanced perceptual robot bringing together many technologies into a whole that's greater than the sum of my parts, but here's what some of my parts can do. I can see your facial expressions and mimic them. I can see your age and gender. So why don't we demo some of these technologies?'"

During a demo, Einstein might turn his head, lock eyes with you, and then flash a dashing smile to mimic your own. But as loveable as the robot is, its developers have had to contend with a paradox familiar to all designers of humanoid robots: The more human-like the robot, the creepier it is to actual humans. And that's of crucial importance when one of the primary motivations behind the robot is to get humans to interact with it in a natural way.

"Some scientists believe strongly that very human-like robots are so inherently creepy that people can never get over it and interact with them normally," Hanson says, alluding to Japanese roboticist Masahiro Mori's "uncanny valley" theory. Mori speculated that when robots look and act like actual humans, it creates a response of revulsion among human observers. "But these are some of the questions we're trying to address with the Einstein robot," explains Hanson. "Does software engage people more when you have a robot that's more aware of you? Are human-like robots inherently creepy, and if so is that a barrier, or is it not a barrier?

"We're trying to get past the novelty of the technology to a certain extent so that people can socially engage with the robots and get lost in that social engagement," he continues. "And in a sense, we naturally do that with other humans. If I have a big piece of spinach in my teeth or I have something cosmetically atypical about me, it might be difficult to get past those superficial barriers so that we can have a more meaningful conversation."

"As people get more comfortable with them, these robots are becoming more popular," adds Movellan (think Johnny Depp as the "Captain Jack Sparrow" automaton at Disneyland's "Pirates of the Caribbean"). "Although we're thinking of Einstein as a tool for science right now, in the future, I could see it being used in museums or as a way to teach people from other cultures how to interact with one another. You could, in principle, program the robot to interact in a more Japanese way, or a more Middle Eastern way. We're also exploring the use of the robot for children with autism. It could be used as a way to teach them facial expression recognition."

But for now, manufacturing robots like Einstein remains cost-prohibitive.

"This isn't yet a real manufacturing business — these robots are still being built by engineers, so they're still very expensive," Hanson cautions. "Right now it costs $50,000 and up for a robot with very few degrees of freedom; something full-featured like Einstein will cost $75,000 and up. But our aspiration and our core discoveries are targeting mass production and trying to get the robots made for under $200."

All applications and cost factors aside, Hanson and Movellan say their ultimate goal is to develop a creative, intelligent machine that rivals or exceeds a human level of intelligence — and perhaps most importantly — does so without compromising civilization and humanity.

"This is something on the order of an Apollo project or a Manhattan project or a Linux initiative," Hanson explains. "It requires a lot of people at a lot of institutions cooperating and competing with each other to find the best way of creating a complete mind for a robot. If things go really well, we're maybe 10 years away from that happening. But it's very important that we develop empathic machines, machines that have compassion, machines that understand what you're feeling. If these robots do become as intelligent as human beings, we want this infrastructure of compassion and empathy to be in place so the machines are prepared to use their intellectual powers for the good of civilization rather than in ways that undermine the stability of civilization. In a way, we're planting the seeds for the survival of humanity."

Provided by UC San Diego

Explore further: Socially-assistive robots help kids with autism learn by providing personalized prompts

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Pepper the emotional robot may just make you angry

Jun 16, 2014

Softbank, a Japanese telecommunications giant, is selling what it is calling "the world's first personal robot that reads emotions". Pepper is designed to be a highly interactive household companion and was developed by Aldebaran, the company behind the succes ...

Robot does standup for London audience (w/ Video)

Aug 17, 2013

(Phys.org) —Robots as military gear haulers? Got it. Assembly line handlers? Got it. Waiters for the elderly? Check. Stand-up comics? Huh? A new role for robots may be trending, with the recent performance ...

Bielefeld robots take part in a space simulation

May 03, 2013

The two robots Flobi and Nao worked full time for three weeks in an isolation study in Cologne. Scientists from Bielefeld University's Research Institute for Cognition and Robotics (CoR-Lab) were studying ...

A future full of robots

Nov 29, 2012

A future where robots are as common as cars – and cheaper – is on the way. This is according to Prof. Hiroshi Ishiguro, named one of the top 100 geniuses alive in the world today, who has devoted himself ...

Mask-bot: A robot with a human face

Nov 07, 2011

Robotics researchers in Munich, Germany, have joined forces with Japanese scientists to develop an ingenious technical solution that gives robots a human face. By using a projector to beam the 3D image of ...

Recommended for you

Robots lending a helping hand to build planes

Aug 26, 2014

Trying to squeeze into small enclosed areas, carrying out highly repetitive tasks, retiring with back injuries even while your expertise is needed: these everyday realities of working in aviation construction ...

C2D2 fighting corrosion

Aug 22, 2014

Bridges become an infrastructure problem as they get older, as de-icing salt and carbon dioxide gradually destroy the reinforced concrete. A new robot can now check the condition of these structures, even ...

Meet the "swarmies"- robotics' answer to bugs

Aug 22, 2014

(Phys.org) —A small band of NASA engineers and interns is about to begin testing a group of robots and related software that will show whether it's possible for autonomous machines to scurry about an alien ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

moj85
not rated yet Feb 13, 2009
repeat post. about 3 times already.
WolfAtTheDoor
not rated yet Feb 13, 2009
I think it's funny that we have this fear of building a machine that will "take over the world". It's so absurd to think that we have that kind of power.

What match is a machine to millions of years of evolution. I contend that humankind has dealt with far more formidable opponents than anything we could create in a lab.
x646d63
4 / 5 (4) Feb 14, 2009
Machines are the result of evolution. Think of it that way. They are more evolved than we are.
Noumenon
3 / 5 (2) Feb 14, 2009
Robots like this are nothing but toys, neat, but I'm less impressed with it than I am with the internet and search engines. The internet to me is the best that AI can do, except dressed in a fancy search engine designed to fool someone rather than mimic thought as such. The turing test is misunderstood, its not about fooling someone off the street, its about someone TRYING to determine through questions wether its AI or human.

There is no 'mind' where there is no consciousness.
No_name
not rated yet Feb 14, 2009
"I think it's funny that we have this fear of building a machine that will "take over the world". It's so absurd to think that we have that kind of power."
-----------------------------------------------------
WolfAtTheDoor - Feb 13, 2009WolfAtTheDoor - Feb 13, 2009
____________________________________________________
What is even more amusing is people who say what is and is not possible with their incredibly limited knowledge of such things. To people like yourself, everything we have today would have been impossible to you if you lived even fifty years ago, I can guarantee that.

If someone told you in 1900 that you would have a box in your home that would connect you to the world and would allow you to search for information on every subject imaginable and download movies you would have said the same thing you say now about robots, GUARANTEED.
=====================================================

"Machines are the result of evolution. Think of it that way. They are more evolved than we are."
---------------------------------------------------
x646d63 - 22 hours ago
_____________________________________________________

No. Evolution does not include intelligent design, and robots are 100% intelligently designed. They are in no way a part of evolution, they are a creation of human beings.
Dhanne
not rated yet Mar 18, 2009
"Evolution does not include intelligent design, and robots are 100% intelligently designed."

Well, machines are still a result of evolution, at least the result of evolution of design if you prefer that human-made things are not part of natural evolution.

I'm not very concerned about that robots will someday surpass us hence biological humans will step aside and die out gradually to make space for their decendants. It's just natural continuum. Biological human is not a final top of evolution, it never was.

That does not mean I would kill myself if an AI asks for it. No, I merely approve that the future belongs to technology-melded humans and intelligent robots because the paradigm shift will eventually happen in future anyway.