'Digital piracy' may benefit companies

Mar 17, 2008
'Digital piracy' may benefit companies
Digital piracy has been claimed to endanger whole industries.

Unauthorised copying of software, music or films, so-called digital piracy, may have benefits for the affected companies, an Oxford researcher has claimed.

In her talk at the Annual Conference of the Royal Economic Society, Oxford economist Karen Croxson suggests that piracy does not necessarily undermine profit as pirates may actually help to promote the product they steal.

Ms Croxson said: ‘Digital piracy has been claimed to endanger whole industries. A natural question to ask is: Why do some companies develop water-tight technology to safeguard their intellectual property when others appear more relaxed about copying?’

Ms Croxson points out that piracy poses a threat to sales only when those who otherwise would buy become tempted instead to copy. In any market there are some who value the product but never would buy. Their piracy cannot harm the seller. Quite the opposite: because, like any consumer, a pirate will talk to others about product experiences, copying which does not displace sales can actually help business. Consumer `buzz’ is hugely important for sales success, studies have shown, and piracy drives up buzz without the need for extra marketing.

Ms Croxson’s analysis considers the temptation to copy a product illegally. This comes down to quite personal factors. Relevant parameters include the value of time, fear of penalties, and moral costs. Modelling this behaviour enables her to predict the variation across markets in the genuine threat to sales and the optimal response of the seller in different cases.

Computer games, for example, are protected heavily because their products are aimed at the youth market. Younger people tend to value games most, but may worry less about copying illegally and have more time on their hands. Piracy may be cheap for them, but their copying, because it undermines sales without generating extra promotional benefits, is detrimental to business. A taste for draconian anti-piracy measures, unsurprisingly, is prevalent among games manufacturers.

In contrast, business software producers appear to put lower effort into protecting their products against piracy, and the reasons may not be immediately obvious. The model provides some explanation. Professional users are known to attach a higher worth to office software than, for example, students. At the same time, they are likely to have higher piracy costs as their time is more precious and they may focus more on legal repercussions.

Ms Croxson explained: ‘With valuable users shying away from copying, the sellers in the business software market find themselves more naturally insulated against lost sales. Those more inclined to pirate, perhaps students, probably wouldn’t have bought the product anyway, so represent virtually free promotion. This helps explain why business software companies do not put as many resources into protection as computer games manufacturers.

‘Building a theoretical model of `promotional piracy’, it is possible to distinguish markets that are best advised to put considerable resource into safeguarding their products from others which may live quite comfortably with a higher incidence of digital piracy.’

Source: Univesity of Oxford

Explore further: Privacy groups take 2nd hit on license plate data

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Google resumes Glass sales in the US

May 14, 2014

Google is once again selling its Internet-connected eyewear to anyone in the U.S. as the company fine-tunes a device that has sparked intrigue and disdain for its potential to change the way people interact ...

Subscriptions woo fans back from pirated music

Mar 18, 2014

Fans are increasingly willing to pay for digital music through subscription streaming services rather than downloading it illegally for free, according to an upbeat report published on Tuesday.

Reddit co-founder campaigns for power of Internet

Dec 05, 2013

The lanky 18-year-old in a blue mortarboard cap, his shoulders festooned with tassels and other regalia, stepped to the lectern, gave Howard High School's Class of 2001 a nervous snicker and spoke words heard in countless ...

Recommended for you

Privacy groups take 2nd hit on license plate data

Sep 19, 2014

A California judge's ruling against a tech entrepreneur seeking access to records kept secret in government databases detailing the comings and goings of millions of cars in the San Diego area via license plate scans was ...

Scots' inventions are fuel for independence debate

Sep 17, 2014

What has Scotland ever done for us? Plenty, it turns out. The land that gave the world haggis and tartan has produced so much more, from golf and television to Dolly the Sheep and "Grand Theft Auto."

White House backs use of body cameras by police

Sep 16, 2014

Requiring police officers to wear body cameras is one potential solution for bridging deep mistrust between law enforcement and the public, the White House said, weighing in on a national debate sparked by the shooting of ...

Chinese city creates cellphone sidewalk lane

Sep 15, 2014

Taking a cue from an American TV program, the Chinese city of Chongqing has created a smartphone sidewalk lane, offering a path for those too engrossed in messaging and tweeting to watch where they're going.

Coroner: Bitcoin exchange CEO committed suicide

Sep 15, 2014

A Singapore Coroner's Court has found that the American CEO of a virtual currency exchange committed suicide earlier this year in Singapore because of work and personal issues.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Mar 17, 2008
Let me give a personal example of this: A few years ago I (illegally) downloaded an extremely, unbelievably, horribly expensive 3D modelling program called "Maya". It's commonly used by game development companies to create models for their games. It was an interesting program, and I played around with my illegal copy of it for a while before I lost interest. It was neat, but of course I'd never spend thousands of dollars on a hobby product when there is not-quite-as-good open source software that can do much the same thing.

But, when my sister was looking around for a 3D modelling program, guess which one I recommended? Yup, that's right, Maya.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 18, 2008
I think this counts for the music industry as well. It's been several times that I bought a CD or DVD after I first heard it online. I really like to know what I buy and when it's good, I don't care to pay some money for it. But without the great quantity of online music and product experiences, I wouldn't have bought this much as I have now.

And I think much people are alike.
5 / 5 (1) Mar 18, 2008
I thought exactly the same thing once about Photoshop and other expensive professional softwares. I said, PS is so easy to crack compared to games, so why they don't create a better security system? Well probably because they need the buz from amateurs/students which isn't the same case regarding games. Doom 3 created a system to check your key over the web everytime you enter the game, a good system.

For most expensive professional programs you just need to type a serial key and you are done. Wanna see another great example? IE7. Before pirate users had hard time to install it so IE market share got hurted badly by Firefox so they made IE7 free to copy and put it on auto update system without need to check genuine pass.
Nobody needs to be a Ph.D to see crystal clear facts like that. Just open your eyes.