Professor examines vuvuzela craze as World Cup approaches

Jun 11, 2014 by Matt Crum

For the 2014 World Cup soccer matches, Brazilian government officials have banned the percussion instrument known as the caxilora from stadiums where matches will be held. So the world will not experience the same type of culture-specific sound as during the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, where the vuvuzela spurred a wide range of reactions.

Arizona State University communication professor Jeffrey Kassing has written a book chapter about the world's reaction to the vuvuzela, a plastic horn blown by thousands of spectators. The chapter, "Noisemaker or Cultural Symbol: The Vuvuzela Controversy and Expressions of Football Fandom," is included in the forthcoming "African Football, Identity Politics and Global Media Narratives: The Legacy of the FIFA 2010 World Cup." The book will be published July 9 by Palgrave Macmillan.

Kassing specifically looked at reactions to the vuvuzela in the form of postings by fans on the website of the British newspaper The Guardian, which ran a story shortly after the 2010 World Cup began that indicated tournament organizers were considering a ban on the instrument. Fan reactions flooded the website for three days until the comment board was closed.

Negative comments fell into several categories of themes. Some questioned the idea that the vuvuzela is actually a cultural symbol in South Africa. Others said users of the instrument weren't "real" fans, that the sound would be acceptable if it weren't used all the time, that the vuvuzela affected communication among players and coaches, and that the sound overpowered the ebb and flow of the game.

Together these themes led Kassing to a specific conclusion: "People felt very strongly that the vuvuzela disrupted the experience of fans and viewers because it conflicted with their expectations of how fandom should be performed," he said. "In particular, fans felt the vuvuzela interrupted a prescribed soundscape for matches – one characterized by singing, applauding and cheering at very specific moments.

"It was very clear that people felt the vuvuzela was a fundamental threat to a specific Eurocentric version of football," Kassing added. "And therefore it was not seen, at least by most people commenting, as a legitimate or alternative fan tradition."

Those posting in defense of the vuvuzela used humor and irony to make their points. Comments included, "Who let all the locals in, honking their strange instruments, dancing around and having a good time. Football should be watched in silence," along with, "The incessant droning noise completely destroys the pleasure of watching the sport on TV. Please ban Formula 1 immediately."

"This use of humor drew attention to shared conceptions of the shortcomings in the English production and presentation of the World Cup and the English game, while also revealing the illogical and excessive nature of complaints against the vuvuzela," Kassing said.

Other supportive comments pointed to the rights of the host country to follow its own traditions, while others challenged English soccer traditions. One concluded, "Complain about the vuvuzelas if you want but please don't pretend they drown out anything more imaginative."

"This comment and similar ones punched holes in the uniformity of English football fandom, highlighting how the experience had grown dreary and repetitive for some fans," Kassing said.

Ultimately the unique sound of the vuvuzela branded the World Cup of 2010 as distinctively South African. According to Kassing, supporters "reminded readers and participants on the message board that there is no one universal version of football fandom and that banning a symbol associated with African football would undermine this truth."

Kassing is director of ASU's School of Social and Behavioral Sciences. The school is a component of the New College of Interdisciplinary Arts and Sciences, the core college on ASU's West campus. He teaches classes for New College's B.A. and B.S. degrees in communication, as well as the master of arts in communication studies (MACS) degree.

Explore further: What's the sound of a hundred thousand soccer fans?

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

What's the sound of a hundred thousand soccer fans?

Nov 27, 2013

Mention vuvuzela to soccer fans, and they may cringe. The plastic horn rose to prominence during the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, where tens of thousands of those instruments blared in packed stadiums. The loud, buzzing ...

'Anti Vuvuzela Filter' promises quieter World Cup

Jun 15, 2010

An online company has begun marketing an "Anti Vuvuzela Filter" that promises to silence the sound of the controversial plastic trumpets that have become the trademark of South Africa's World Cup.

Is the FIFA World cup qualification a fair game?

Jun 11, 2014

In their new article, "Unfair play in World Cup qualification? An analysis of the 1998–2010 FIFA World Cup performances and the bias in the allocation of tournament berths", Christian Stone and Michel Rod ...

Facebook, Twitter brace for World Cup fever

Jun 10, 2014

This year's World Cup will play out on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and messaging apps like WhatsApp just as it progresses in stadiums from Sao Paulo to Rio De Janeiro.

Recommended for you

Genes play a key part in the recipe for a happy country

18 hours ago

Why are the Danes naturally more cheerful than the Brits, and why are we in turn more upbeat than the French? Research presented as part of this year's ESRC Festival of Social Sciences shows us that the recipe behind a happy ...

Black Republicans put most faith in US government

Oct 29, 2014

Black Republicans trust the United States government more than other political groups, finds a new study from the University of British Columbia, ahead of the mid-term U.S. elections to be held on November ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

COCO
not rated yet Jun 12, 2014
too bad - I loved the sound after I learned it was not huge South African mosquitos invading the stadiums.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.