100% mobile coverage is a pipe dream – even with national roaming

Jun 24, 2014 by Andrew Smith
Keeping dream of reception in the remotest areas. Credit: Subbotina Anna

Mobile phone providers should introduce national roaming, Britain's Culture Secretary, Sajid Javid, has announced. The purpose: to enable full mobile phone coverage across the UK, bringing signal to those black spots where you lose it.

In the same way that you can switch provider when you travel abroad, you would be able to switch to an alternative network when yours is not available. This sounds great, but it won't bring 100% mobile coverage across the UK.

Free roam?

Our phones coupled with the technology provided by mobile networks are continually working to establish which mobile mast offers the best signal, as well as the network availability of each mast (for example, how many other people are using it). If your mobile phone is using a mast that has fewer connections and you travel closer to one with more connections, your phone will remain connected to the original mast, so long as the original signal remains within reasonable bounds, in terms of strength. So, roaming between the masts of your own provider takes place all the time.

When you travel abroad and have your phone's roaming function switched on, you can then switch between the mobile masts of different providers. By flicking the roaming switch on your phone, this informs your phone that it can connect to other networks. But, you must also have this agreed with your mobile phone provider so that they can use their network routing method to find you a network that they have an agreement with.

An interesting example can be found within England, in the idyllic and remote Lake District. If you are on the western side of this geographical area and at a suitable height, your , if it has international roaming, may connect to the on the Isle of Man, which is a separate political entity within the British Isles. Therefore, in principle, the idea of national roaming is sound. Without any technical knowledge you could envisage a system where all mobile telecommunications networks interconnect.

The reality

At many levels all the telecommunications companies do work well together. But they also compete and will not be jumping for joy at the notion that the network they have invested considerable millions in infrastructure in to reach prime customer locations now has to be shared. The call for national roaming requires them to share each others' technology and undermines the competitive nature of their business.

Technologically speaking, it may be possible to connect to other providers, but when connected to an unknown providers network, the network rules are not always in place to make sure we get the best connection or the best deal.

It's possible to control the volume and bandwidth of traffic in any networked system. This means that one provider can limit the service quality available to a customer from another network roaming into their system. So, even if they are forced to cooperate with this measure, companies can maintain their competitive edge this way.

Putting aside the technological and competition issues, what about hills, mountains, valleys and the terrain? Geography remains a barrier to full network coverage. In my car – I use hands free – I have come to know the areas where passing from mast to mast while driving and talking is going to disconnect any call.

Even if no new infrastructure was acquired and all networks joined together without any commercial issues, there would still be unreachable areas. This would then add the next problem of trying to establish who is actually going to pay for a mast to be erected in these areas and which will own this.

We may eventually get 99.5% coverage, just by selecting two well-known providers (O2 and EE), which have comprehensive coverage of the UK between them. Yet you can see where they still have common gaps. You can also see where they only have 2G, which has very limited mobile data capacity.

The reality is that there will always be areas that cannot be reached. All networks being under government guidance will improve what is available, but 100%? Now that is a pipe-dream.

Explore further: How will Inmarsat bring in-flight internet to Europe?

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

UK customers of O2 hit by outage

Jul 12, 2012

(AP) — British mobile phone company O2 said Thursday that thousands of its customers have been affected by outages on its network.

How will Inmarsat bring in-flight internet to Europe?

Jun 11, 2014

The UK-based satellite communications company Inmarsat last week announced plans to build a hybrid satellite/cellular (air-to-ground) network to offer in-flight internet connectivity over mainland Europe. ...

EU proposes end to roaming charges in mobile shake-up

May 30, 2013

Europe's Digital Agenda commissioner Neelie Kroes on Thursday proposed a radical shake-up of the mobile phone services market, including an end to roaming charges long denounced by consumer groups.

EU reform to scrap mobile roaming fees

Apr 03, 2014

The European Parliament on Thursday endorsed a sweeping package of EU telecommunications reforms, including a much-awaited measure to end roaming charges for cross-border mobile phone use.

Recommended for you

Taxi app Uber defies ban in Spain

16 hours ago

Smartphone car-ride service Uber vowed Friday to keep operating in Spain despite a ban following a lawsuit by taxi drivers and said it would fight the case in court.

Sony film mess reflects gadgets-entertainment gap

Dec 26, 2014

Sony's iconic gadgetry and the star appeal of Hollywood may have appeared to be a perfect match when the electronics giant bought Columbia Pictures in 1989. A quarter century later, it's apparent that Sony ...

Streaming release of 'Interview' test for industry

Dec 25, 2014

Sony's "The Interview" has been a hacking target, a punchline and a political lightning rod. Now, with its release online at the same time it debuts in theaters, it has a new role: a test for a new kind of ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Landrew
not rated yet Jun 24, 2014
The internet is clearly the lifeblood of the Information Age, the way the rivers once were.

Those who create toll-castles on the internet the way robber-barons of old created them on the rivers, deserve to be abolished.
ferdbrowne
not rated yet Jun 24, 2014
Good article..Another thing to note is internal coverage..houses with thick walls, K-glass, foil backed insulation, basements, the list goes on and on where there will always be poor coverage. I had rubbish coverage in my house till I installed a Stelladoradus signal booster.
Bit pricey, but it works very well for me...
EWH
not rated yet Jun 24, 2014
Bandwidth allocation is done very badly now, locked into old technologies and giveaways to cell providers. A comprehensive reform to get the most value for the public out of their airwaves by integrating civilian, government, and military radio, TV, Internet, radar, location services and other electromagnetic applications using software-defined broadband radio and dynamic agoric allocation should be pursued.

A network of high-altitude unmanned airships with line-of-sight optical mesh-network backbones and ultra-wideband radio relays/routers/cells would be more robust and cheaper than the current system, while providing 99.9+% outdoor coverage, and nearly as high indoors.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.