Rail privatisation is 'great train robbery', finds UK report

Jun 13, 2013

The privatised rail system relies upon billions of pounds of hidden subsidies and has failed to bring in private investment, according to experts at The University of Manchester.

The TUC commissioned research by the Centre for Research on Socio-Cultural Change (CRESC), finds the policy has artificially boosted private profits of the privately owned Train Operating Companies.

And because they do not figure on any public balance sheet, the huge liabilities of the British tax payer are hidden.

CRESC is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC).

"Network Rail has been inflating the profits of the Train Operating Companies by lowering track access charges from £3.19 billion in 1994 to £1.59bn in 2012," said CRESC Director Professor Karel Williams, from The University of Manchester.

"This hidden sum is nearly twice as large as direct government subsidies and the cost of servicing this growing debt is now larger than the cost of annual maintenance.

"Half the new debt currently being issued by Network Rail covers the cost of servicing existing debt."

Direct public expenditure on rail has more than doubled since privatisation and is currently running at £4 billion a year, says their report published today (7 June), despite fares which are higher than in other major European countries.

And negligible private investment means that the average age of rolling stock, at 18 years, is now two years higher than in 1996, they add.

The CRESC report for the first time tracks the flow of public money through the rail system, documenting how the Train Operating Companies extract huge profits from public subsidy.

Professor Williams added: "The privately owned Train Operating Companies have completely hijacked the 's rail reform agenda, which is about 'getting franchising back on track'.

"Our research shows how the franchising system allows them to distribute profits at low cost from public subsidy.

"So we say it would make sense to abolish the train operating companies. That would cost the taxpayer nothing if it were done as franchises expired.

"Train and track operation could then be integrated under a new not for profit company, National Rail, under cash constraints which enforced operating efficiency."

TUC General Secretary Frances O'Grady said: "This study explodes the myth that rail firms are bringing added value to our railways. In reality they rely upon taxpayers to turn a profit, virtually all of which ends up in shareholders' pockets, rather than being used to improve services.

"Rail privatisation has not brought the improvements its cheerleaders promised – the average age of trains has increased and most new investment is funded by the state.

"The claim that private train operators are responsible for more people using the railways must also be taken with a huge pinch of salt. Passenger growth has mirrored changes in the wider economy and is not the result of creative marketing drives by companies.

"The government must accept that the current model is broken. Its determination to impose franchising across the network – even on the East Coast Mainline which is performing well as a nationalised service – shows ministers are ignoring the evidence of 20 years of failure."

Explore further: Even fraud-savvy investors often look for the wrong red flags, study says

More information: www.cresc.ac.uk/

Related Stories

New 311mph maglev train in Japan passes initial tests

Jun 06, 2013

(Phys.org) —Engineers with Central Japan Railway Co. have put their newest maglev L0 train through initial testing and report the new high-speed train is on course for commercial deployment by 2027. The ...

EU OKs $2.7bn Siemens takeover of UK rail firm

Apr 18, 2013

The European Union's antitrust body has cleared a 1.74 billion pound ($2.7 billion) takeover of a British rail technology company by German industrial conglomerate Siemens.

Rail production that is fast and energy efficient

Mar 25, 2013

A new hardening technology used in the production of heavy duty rails saves energy and increases productivity. The Siemens' IdRHa+technology will now be used commercially for the first time in a production ...

Recommended for you

The true cost of fuelling conflict

Jun 23, 2015

The United States Department of Defense (DOD) is widely reported to be the single largest consumer of petroleum in the world, spending billions of dollars on fuel every year. While the DOD provides Congress ...

Commodity market volatility more perception than reality

Jun 23, 2015

When grain and other commodity prices experienced explosive episodes between 2004 and 2013, the finger pointed toward index traders as the cause. University of Illinois researchers identified and date-stamped both upward ...

Entrepreneurs who manage occupational stress perform better

Jun 22, 2015

Many entrepreneurs work hard, day in, day out. Entrepreneurship causes a lot of stress. How does this impact entrepreneurs? Can training and coaching programs reduce that stress? In her PhD thesis, Josette Dijkhuizen concludes ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.