German court orders changes to Google search hints (Update)

May 14, 2013 by Frank Jordans

Google Inc. must respect requests to remove autocomplete entries from its search bar in Germany if they are defamatory, a German court ruled Tuesday.

The Federal Court of Justice upheld a complaint from an unidentified company selling nutritional supplements and its founder, identified only as "R.S." The plaintiffs claimed that when their names were entered on Google's German-language website, it suggested links to Scientology and fraud.

The search suggestions constituted a form of defamation because they wrongly implied "a factual link between the plaintiff and the terms 'Scientology' and/or 'fraud,' which have negative connotations," the court said. The German branch of the Church of Scientology has long been under observation by domestic intelligence services amid worries—which Scientology strongly rejects—that its work conflicts with Germany's constitution.

Google expressed surprise and disappointment at the decision, noting that the autocomplete function merely reflects what other users have searched for.

The company noted that the court hadn't ordered Google to turn off the autocomplete function or to vet all results in advance. Instead, Google has to ensure that defamatory results are checked, and if necessary removed, as soon as they have been brought to its attention, the court said.

If Google disagrees with a claim that an entry is defamatory, it could have to settle the matter in court.

The verdict overturns a decision by a regional court in the western city of Cologne, which had dismissed the complaint last year. The regional court will now have to reexamine the case and determine if Google failed to meet its duty of care and is liable for damages and legal costs.

The verdict also has implications for Google in the high-profile case of Germany's former first lady, Bettina Wulff, who is suing the company because its autocomplete function suggested searches that included the terms "escort" and "red light past." That case is still pending.

Explore further: Startups offer banking for smartphone users

3 /5 (3 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Japan lawyer calls for Google autocomplete change

Mar 27, 2012

A Japanese lawyer on Tuesday urged Google to makes its "autocomplete" function more flexible, after a court ordered the search giant to modify the feature to prevent embarrassment for his client. ...

European Court hears Spanish case against Google

Feb 26, 2013

The European Court of Justice is hearing a case that pits Spain's data protection agency against search engine giant Google over the thorny issue of "the right to be forgotten" online.

Twitter beefs up search function

Jul 06, 2012

Twitter said Friday it was upgrading its search functions to include "autocomplete" and spelling correction features.

Recommended for you

Startups offer banking for smartphone users

Aug 30, 2014

The latest banks are small enough to fit in the palm of your hand. Startups, such as Moven and Simple, offer banking that's designed specifically for smartphones, enabling users to track their spending on the go. Some things ...

'SwaziLeaks' looks to shake up jet-setting monarchy

Aug 29, 2014

As WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange prepares to end a two-year forced stay at Ecuador's London embassy, he may take comfort in knowing he inspired resistance to secrecy in places as far away as Swaziland.

Ecuador heralds digital currency plans (Update)

Aug 29, 2014

Ecuador is planning to create what it calls the world's first digital currency issued by a central bank, which some analysts believe could be a first step toward abandoning the country's existing currency, ...

WEF unveils 'crowdsourcing' push on how to run the Web

Aug 28, 2014

The World Economic Forum unveiled a project on Thursday aimed at connecting governments, businesses, academia, technicians and civil society worldwide to brainstorm the best ways to govern the Internet.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

baudrunner
not rated yet May 14, 2013
Google's auto-complete feature - yet another example of, "it's possible to do, therefore it should be done" - is far from perfect. In fact, I would say it's been more of an annoyance than a useful feature. However, that being said, I have noticed significant improvements to that feature in just the past few weeks. It used to be that when a search for my name was done, Google would return with, "Did you mean .......?" and return only results pertaining to what it thought I meant. Apparently, my name was too unique for it to process as requested, even though I am all over the web. I thought that to be a stupid thing. I am happy to report that that particular annoyance is now resolved.

Sometimes things that don't work do get fixed, and that's a good thing. Well done, Google.