Romanian PM may have copied his PhD: Nature journal (Update)

June 18, 2012

The science journal Nature reported claims on Monday that Romania's Prime Minister Victor Ponta had plagiarised large parts of his 2003 PhD thesis which he denied, hinting at a political plot against him.

In a news article, Nature said it had seen documents compiled by an anonymous whistle-blower indicating that more than half of Ponta's 432-page law thesis on the International Criminal Court, written in Romanian, "consists of duplicated text".

"Moreover, the thesis was republished with very minor amendments as a Romanian-language book in 2004, and also forms the basis of a 2010 book on liability in international humanitarian law," said the report.

A former PhD student of Ponta's, Daniela Coman, is named as co-author.

Ponta told reporters in Bucharest that he was "ready to submit to any kind of verification".

He hinted that his political rival president Traian Basescu and his team might be at the origin of the allegations.

Ponta and Basescu are fighting to see who will represent Romania at the next European summit.

"I am used to this with Basescu. I guess he was angry at me and so he studied my PhD thesis", Ponta said.

"The fact that my thesis on the International Criminal Court is of interest to Nature is a bit comical", Ponta added. Nature is specialised in science and medicine.

The allegations come just a month after Ponta said his education minister Ioan Mang had resigned over allegations made by foreign researchers that he had copied scientific papers on information technology without attribution.

The prime minister had been forced to drop his first candidate for the education portfolio after she too was accused of plagiarism.

Hungary's president Pal Schmitt resigned in April and Germany's defence minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg in March last year, also over plagiarism allegations.

Nature said much of the text in Ponta's work "seem to be identical, or almost so" to material in papers written in Romanian by two law scholars, and featured "direct Romanian translations of parts of an English-language publication" by another.

"It is very strange to be copying someone who signed your foreword", Ponta countered.

Romanian President Basescu named Ponta, who leads the Social-Liberal Union, to take over from Mihai Razvan Ungureanu whose centre-right government collapsed in April after a no-confidence vote.

Nature said Ponta obtained his PhD from the University of Bucharest while acting as secretary of state in the government of an earlier prime minister, Adrian Nastase, who was his PhD supervisor.

Explore further: Resignation of SA health minister sought

Related Stories

Resignation of SA health minister sought

September 6, 2006

Pressure is mounting on South Africa's Health Minister to resign for suggesting garlic, lemons and African potatoes as alternative HIV treatment.

UK phone-hacking 'targeted ex-premier Brown'

January 23, 2011

Britain's opposition Labour party called Sunday for a fresh police probe into phone-hacking by journalists, amid reports that former prime minister Gordon Brown was among the high-profile figures targeted.

IBM to build center of excellence in Romania

April 20, 2011

US computing giant IBM and the municipality of Targu-Mures on Wednesday signed an agreement on the construction of a center of excellence in the central Romanian city.

Romanian accused of hacking NASA-JPL computers

February 8, 2012

(AP) -- The Los Angeles U.S. attorney's office says a federal grand jury has indicted a Romanian citizen on charges he hacked into 25 climate-research computers at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena.

Recommended for you

Just how good (or bad) is the fossil record of dinosaurs?

August 28, 2015

Everyone is excited by discoveries of new dinosaurs – or indeed any new fossil species. But a key question for palaeontologists is 'just how good is the fossil record?' Do we know fifty per cent of the species of dinosaurs ...

Fractals patterns in a drummer's music

August 28, 2015

Fractal patterns are profoundly human – at least in music. This is one of the findings of a team headed by researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization in Göttingen and Harvard University ...

8 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Nogero
1 / 5 (2) Jun 18, 2012
Spelling error: it's "defense" not defence in, "Hungary's president Pal Schmitt resigned in April and Germany's defence minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg in March last year, also over plagiarism allegations."
Direwolf
5 / 5 (2) Jun 18, 2012
Nogero,
"Defence" is the British spelling, "defense" the American one. It's not an error.
alfie_null
1 / 5 (1) Jun 19, 2012
Has incidence of plagiarism increased concomitant with increased availability of electronic (digital) resources, or are we just getting better at detecting it?
antialias_physorg
3 / 5 (2) Jun 19, 2012
Has incidence of plagiarism increased concomitant with increased availability of electronic (digital) resources

Probably not. The spat of revealed plagiarism cases in germany (all by conservative politicians - go figure) for example were of dissertations that were written when electronic media was not the mainstay of research.

For example wikipedia and other web sources in general are not 'cite-worthy' references (i.e. you may not include them in your reference section)
And you still need at least a hundred references to go into your dissertation for it to be even considered adequate research material.

I would say that with stuff being moved to the digital it just has become easier to detect plagiarism...even accross language boundaries.
TkClick
1 / 5 (1) Jun 19, 2012
A former PhD student of Ponta's, Daniela Coman, is named as co-author.
Can the thesis have a co-authors? I never heard of it...
antialias_physorg
1 / 5 (1) Jun 19, 2012
Can the thesis have a co-authors? I never heard of it...

Sort of. Universities will sometimes accept a publication/publications in high class journal(s) in lieu of a separate dissertation.
The content is basically the same (presentation of state-of-the-art, data, method, results, conclusions)

Co-authorship is also a very fuzzy term. It can mean anything from "has written part of the paper" to "has supplied data" to "has finced the project" to "is head of the department where the paper was written but has never seen the author (or the paper) face-to-face"
ovidiu
not rated yet Jun 20, 2012
A former PhD student of Ponta's, Daniela Coman, is named as co-author.
Can the thesis have a co-authors? I never heard of it...

It refers to the book, not the thesis:
"[...]and also forms the basis of a 2010 book on liability in international humanitarian law."
rsklyar
1 / 5 (1) Jun 20, 2012
But some professor-bandit at Northwestern University with a united italian research gang from the Italian Institute of Technology (IIT) and Joint Research Centre, universities of Ferrara and Genova is still "plagiarizing researching": http://issuu.com/...saivaldi

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.