Does austerity pain actually deliver long-term gain?

Jun 11, 2012

An Oxford University-led study examining the consequences of the ongoing fiscal squeeze in Western economies is looking to the past to inform the present, with two academics from Victoria's School of Government providing a New Zealand perspective.

Headed by Professor Christopher Hood, the Gladstone Professor of Government at All Souls College at Oxford, the study is comparing periods or episodes of 'fiscal squeeze' across countries at different points in history to consider how austerity variously affects constitutional, political and .

from Britain, the , , , and New Zealand  are exploring whether austerity requires a reversal of normal political and bureaucratic routines; what shapes cutback choices when expenditure needs to reined in; how governments shift or avoid blame from voters; and what the medium to long-term effects of such cutbacks are.

Using the "mother of all budgets" in 1991 as the point of departure for a New Zealand case study, Victoria University's Adjunct Professor Robert (Bob) Gregory and Dr Chris Eichbaum will examine the implications of the fiscal constraints in the early 1990s.

Dr Eichbaum says that the research will be of academic significance, but will undoubtedly also speak to issues confronting policymakers in the here and now.

 "We can see from developments in the Eurozone, and in Greece and Spain in particular, that that the policies of austerity have a direct and material impact on the economic and social circumstances of citizens, and also on political stability, sentiment and action.

"A policy prescription which has credibility with finance markets and those that advise them, such as credit rating agencies, may well be a necessary condition when it comes to charting a path to recovery. But it is by no means a sufficient one. Policy credibility needs to be twinned with popular or democratic legitimacy. That doesn’t mean a situation in which no one loses—but it does mean ensuring that there is a mandate and understanding of the need for policies that may involve pain, whether in the short or medium term.

"What we are seeing in Europe is a debate over the relative merits of austerity programmes and those kinds of programmes that seek to re-balance economies (and firms and households) using economic growth as the lever. These are challenges associated with governance."

Dr Eichbaum says that public spending in is clearly under pressure as the Government works towards the target of a modest fiscal surplus by 2014/15.

"The government of the day has an interest in getting value for money in the short-term, but it also has a stewardship interest to maintain and even build capacity for the medium to long-term. One early lesson to be drawn from the case studies already discussed by the researchers is that policy decisions taken in periods of fiscal squeeze may well have long-term and sometimes unanticipated ."

The study is funded by the UK's Economic and Social Research Council and the British Academy, and research findings will be presented at a conference in London in 2013.

Explore further: Why companies don't learn from their mistakes

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

3 Questions: David Singer on the Greek Euro-tragedy

Jun 22, 2011

The economic and fiscal woes of Greece remain at the center of European politics. In recent months, a variety of economists and commentators have asked if Greece should consider the unprecedented move of leaving ...

Greece could be broke by June, economist says

May 08, 2012

( -- If international lenders refuse to renegotiate substantial reductions in Greek public debt, chances are that whatever government emerges in Greece in the next few weeks will run out of cash by ...

Recommended for you

Predicting human crowds with statistical physics

Feb 27, 2015

For the first time researchers have directly measured a general law of how pedestrians interact in a crowd. This law can be used to create realistic crowds in virtual reality games and to make public spaces safer.

Bribery 'hits 1.6 billion people a year'

Feb 27, 2015

A total of 1.6 billion people worldwide – nearly a quarter of the global population – are forced to pay bribes to gain access to everyday public services, according to a new book by academics at the Universities of Birmingham ...

Broken windows thesis springs a leak

Feb 27, 2015

The broken windows theory posits that minor misdemeanors, like littering or graffiti spraying, stimulate more serious anti-social behavior. LMU sociologists now argue that the idea is flawed and does not ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Jun 11, 2012
In lieu of
Bailing-out the banks, as Europe's action with Spain om Monday, at a per capita cost of $27,000 per resident; Taxpayer on the hook for that 'Bail-out!
An alternative method of distribution should be employed: Give each citizen a check for $27,000 and let the Citizens do as they desire with the money/checks!
An instant shot-the-arm for the economy. Some would Bank the funds, some would invest the funds (equities, etc.)
Neither 'Stimulus Plan', 'Tarp' tried by the USA has had any discernible effect on the citizen; banks expanded their 'portfolios', loans are damned near impossible to obtain, people are still losing their houses.
With the 'cost' for each 'Obama job' created hovering near $100,000.
That money, in the hands of the Citizen would, quite kikely resulted in a far better 'bang for the Buck'!
Spain, don't be afraid to entrust funds to people; what is the advantage of short-circuiting available money, by channeling access to the money through the banks!

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.