Mobile Flash can't die soon enough

Nov 22, 2011 By Troy Wolverton

Somewhere Steve Jobs must be smiling. As you may have heard, Adobe last week admitted defeat in its long-running battle with Apple over Adobe's Flash technology. As Apple's CEO, the late Jobs barred Flash from Apple's iPhone and other handheld devices and famously wrote an open letter last year explaining why.

Jobs complained that Flash was a buggy, insecure battery hog that wasn't designed for touch devices like the and - thanks to the advent of new, more open technologies - had outlived its usefulness. Belatedly, Adobe seems to have come to the same conclusion.

The company announced that after an upcoming update, it would cease development of its Flash player software for . Instead it plans to focus on HTML5, the same technology that Jobs touted last year.

This is a big retreat for Adobe. The company is abandoning mobile Flash little more than a year after it released it - and after spending years developing it. And the core of its new mobile strategy is a technology that just last year Kevin Lynch, Adobe's , said wouldn't be able to replace Flash "in the foreseeable future."

I guess we can say unequivocally that Jobs' foresight was a lot keener than that of the folks at Adobe.

For consumers, this is a welcome move because it should mean that the Web browsing experience on mobile devices is going to get a lot better.

The promise of mobile Flash was that users would have the same , regardless of whether they were accessing a Web page from a PC, tablet or .

But the reality of mobile Flash was much different than its promise. Flash-based videos and games are often slow to load on mobile devices. Some of the older Flash content can't be played in the mobile Flash player. And many Flash-based video websites block access to their content from - even if those devices are running Flash. In sum, the experience was much worse than what you'd get on your PC.

I had eagerly anticipated mobile Flash and was disappointed that Apple didn't include the technology on the iPad. But after playing with mobile Flash, I realized I hadn't been missing much.

As any iPhone or iPad user knows, you can do plenty of things without Flash. Most Web videos these days can be viewed without a Flash player, and most of the major websites don't require it. And with all the games available in the Apple App Store, Apple device owners aren't missing Flash games.

Adobe's decision to kill off mobile Flash will push developers to ensure that all websites and content are mobile-friendly.

My biggest quibble with Adobe's move is that it doesn't go far enough. I'd like to see Adobe kill Flash on the desktop also.

Flash was a crucial technology during the past decade. While the browser makers were fighting over Web standards and companies like Apple, Microsoft and RealNetworks were battling over how to deliver streaming audio and video, Flash provided something of a lingua franca.

It allowed users to view dynamic Web pages no matter what browser they were running or operating system they were using. It allowed consumers to play games directly within Web pages. And it became a standard way for delivering streaming media, freeing users from worrying about whether they had the right version of QuickTime or Windows Media Player to listen to a Web broadcast.

But the times have passed Flash by. Web standards have become more sophisticated and more widely supported. Developers can now stream video and audio, and offer sophisticated applications and dynamic menus without resorting to Flash.

Meanwhile, the downsides of Flash have become more and more apparent. In short, Jobs was right. In part because of its ubiquity, Flash has become an inviting target for hackers; the software has become one of the biggest security vulnerabilities on PCs.

What's more frustrating on a daily basis is just how unstable Flash is. Flash crashes my browser nearly every day - and that's on a Windows machine, where the software is supposedly more robust. Anecdotes from other users indicate my experience is not unique.

In defending Flash from Jobs' attack last year, Adobe co-founders John Warnock and Charles Geschke painted the dispute as one about freedom, openness and consumer choice. Adobe's move is a recognition that consumers, platform operators and developers are choosing to flee Flash to embrace an even more open technology and some other important freedoms, such as being liberated from Flash's crashes and security holes.

So I'll be glad to see Flash go away. Somewhere Jobs is saying, "I told you so."

Explore further: Instagram launches time-lapse video app for iPhone

More information: Troy Wolverton is a technology columnist for the San Jose Mercury News.

1 /5 (1 vote)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Adobe pulls plug on Flash for mobile

Nov 09, 2011

US software maker Adobe pulled the plug Wednesday on its Flash player for mobile browsers, which Apple's late chief executive Steve Jobs refused to allow on the iPhone and iPad.

Adobe fires another shot in war with Apple

May 13, 2010

Adobe fired back at Apple on Thursday over the refusal by the maker of the iPod, iPhone and iPad to allow the US software giant's widely used Flash video product to run on the devices.

Adobe to offer Flash to iPhone developers

Oct 05, 2009

(AP) - Adobe Systems says developers for Apple's iPhone will be able to use its video-enabling software, Flash, to create applications for the device for the first time.

Adobe embracing Apple-favored online video format

May 19, 2010

Adobe Systems on Wednesday put aside its tiff with Apple and told thousands of software developers it is embracing the online video format preferred by the maker of iPhones, iPods and iPads.

Recommended for you

Does your computer know how you're feeling?

Aug 22, 2014

Researchers in Bangladesh have designed a computer program that can accurately recognize users' emotional states as much as 87% of the time, depending on the emotion.

Microsoft to unveil new Windows software

Aug 21, 2014

A news report out Thursday indicated that Microsoft is poised to give the world a glimpse at a new-generation computer operating system that will succeed Windows 8.

Unlocking the potential of simulation software

Aug 21, 2014

With a method known as finite element analysis (FEA), engineers can generate 3-D digital models of large structures to simulate how they'll fare under stress, vibrations, heat, and other real-world conditions.

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Temple
4 / 5 (1) Nov 22, 2011
The "long running battle" mentioned was a battle to have Flash run remotely performantly on *any* mobile device.

The moment Adobe released a flash player that didn't suck up tons of CPU cycles and drain batteries like a plug-in space-heater, it would have been on every mobile device, including the Apple ones.

Adobe was never able to achieve this, and they've given up trying.

--

I *loved* Flash. It was one of the most exciting technologies when it came out. It was improving quickly, changing, evolving, getting better and better. But when Adobe bought it from Macromedia, they let it wither on the vine. They killed flash by basically doing almost nothing to improve it for most of a decade.

I had a Flash-blocker installed on my computer for *years* before Jobs said what the whole world was saying "Flash sucks". The terrible performance was only highlighted by the lessened capabilities of mobile devices.

I'm sad that Flash is dead, but Adobe killed it many years ago through neglect.
dirk_bruere
not rated yet Nov 22, 2011
Last update of flash on my XP machine crashed it regularly.
The end.