N. Zealand sceptics defy 'Moonman' quake prophecy

March 14, 2011

A collapsed church is pictured in Christchurch after a 6.3-magnitude earthquake hit the New Zealand city

Enlarge

Geologists, engineers and like-minded sceptics will meet in earthquake-devastated Christchurch Sunday to mock "junk science" predictions another major tremor will hit the city this weekend.

Geologists, engineers and like-minded sceptics will meet in earthquake-devastated Christchurch Sunday to mock "junk science" predictions another major tremor will hit the city this weekend.

Ken Ring, a quasi-mystic known as the "Moonman", claims he predicted last month's 6.3-magnitude quake by studying the moon and has warned another tremor will rock New Zealand's second-largest city on March 20.

So far 166 people have been confirmed killed in February's disaster, although police have said they expect the figure to rise to more than 200.

New Zealand Skeptics spokeswoman Vicki Hyde said many in Christchurch were taking Ring seriously and her organisation had organised a "non-event" lunch on the day to try to set their minds at ease.

"At times like these, we think it's irresponsible to allow anyone to exploit the understandable anxieties of Christchurch residents," she said, accusing Ring of seeking "opportunistic publicity".

Hyde said prominent sceptics, including members of the scientific community who have attacked Ring's theories, would attend the lunch in a historic stone building on a Christchurch hilltop.

Environment Minister Nick Smith, who holds a PhD in geo-technical engineering, described the lunch as a public service event.

"The last thing needed by thousands of traumatised people in Canterbury, including elderly and children, is junk science and made-up predictions of future major quakes," he said.

In response to the attacks, Ring has said will make no public comment until after March 20.

His theories centre on the fact that moon is now unusually close to the Earth, exerting a strong .

(c) 2011 AFP

Filter


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.


Display comments: newest first

Blakut
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Can you imagine the type of people spreading this Moon quake nonsense? How they now eagerly wait for another disaster, just to prove their stupid theory is right?
ScottyM23
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
and yet, if another earthquake were to happen, wouldn't that "stupid theory" be proven right? and that some people might actually be on to things even though they seem unconventional?
ironjustice
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
Quote: Moon quake nonsense
Answer: I would rather have someone tell me to keep my head up and not happen than have somebody tell me NOT to keep my head up and it happens. So I guess you know where I stand with YOUR little 'contribution' to the scheme of things .. eh ..
LariAnn
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
If members of the established scientific club predicted a quake, their prediction would not be considered irresponsible, even if their predictions caused great fear and consternation, and yet did not come to pass. Also, I've seen amazing eagerness for potential disaster coming from mainstream meteorologists when a hurricane is forming, but their misplaced zeal is not derided by the rest of the scientific community. So the real issue is not whether a prediction comes to pass or not, but whether the person and the theory are acceptable as far as established scientific dogma is concerned. I'm with ironjustice and ScottyM23 on this one.
NameIsNotNick
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (3)
and yet, if another earthquake were to happen, wouldn't that "stupid theory" be proven right? and that some people might actually be on to things even though they seem unconventional?

One success would prove little, especially when you consider that aftershocks are hardly a rarity after an earthquake. If they could establish a track record that would be another matter... I'm surprised Moonman didn't warn the Japanese. Seems almost criminally negligent.
undrgrndgirl
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (3)
One success would prove little.


unless it were some "scientist" who's prediction proved correct...
ScottyM23
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1.3 / 5 (3)
when it comes to natural disasters, one of two things will happen. and that's, it either occurs, or it doesn't. but like ironjustice said, i would rather be prepared, thinking something might happen, and possibly be able to save things and lessen the chance of losing valuable property...than to blow it off and then not have anywhere to live and anywhere to eat. it doesn't have to be like an evacuation necessarily, but just preparing.

that's the problem with society, so many people think that we are safe here on Earth, when in reality we have all the chance of being killed every day by thousands of different things. It will only take one to do the job.
Workitout
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 1 / 5 (2)
The Moonman theory is based on the moon being at it's closest point to earth in an 18 year cycle. Using Newton's Law of gravitation, during the full moon of 19 march there will be 7.38% more gravitational force acting between the earth and the moon than exists when the moon is at its average distance from earth. 7.38% is a big number when you look at how much the force is normally.

Perhaps the Moonman is right, perhaps he is wrong. Either way, judging him before the event occurs is doing EXACTLY the same as what he is doing, so perhaps doing one's own research, and sharing the results instead of throwing words may be more beneficial for all of us.

I thank Moonman for sticking his neck out and reputation on the line to warn us. I haven't heard ANY predictions from any of the official Geological Institutions responsible for monitoring earthquake activity prior to the Christchurch and Japanese earthquakes either.
Bog_Mire
Mar 14, 2011

Rank: 5 / 5 (2)
That is because Geological institutions do not make predictions based on quackery. Like astrophysicists do not make astrological personal predictions.
jjoensuu
Mar 15, 2011

Rank: not rated yet
There is this paper written by Lorenzo Iorio, titled "On the anomalous secular increase of the eccentricity of the orbit of the Moon". I do not know how relevant the discussion in the document is to the earthquake, just that there are some anomalies in the moons orbit (not necessarily meaning that the moon would end up any CLOSER because of them). I am not able to vouch for the correctness of the conclusions in the paper but it can be accessed here:

http://arxiv.org/...12v3.pdf
Fitzy
Mar 15, 2011

Rank: not rated yet
Whats Ken Ring and the UN IPCC got in common?
They both make fuzzy predictions using uncertain methods, and both have failed to prove their methods valid.
phuzzydog
Mar 19, 2011

Rank: not rated yet
Hypothesis: Magnitude 5.8 or greater earthquake between 157E and 170W longitude, between 0600-0900 UTC 20 March 2011.
pargy
Mar 30, 2011

Rank: not rated yet
I agree with Workitout. The theory of Earth tides is not novel. If you have a system in delicate balance, only small forces are needed to tip it. Why is it so implausible that an abnormally high gravitational pull (regardless of source) could precipitate tectonic plate movements or fault line slippages? I don't know how there can be precision about the timing, because the 'tipping point' might not occur immediately, but I also don't see why the theory should be derided as junk science.
Rank 5 /5 (3 votes)
Relevant PhysicsForums posts

More news stories

SpaceX capsule has 'new car' smell, astronauts say (Update)

SpaceX's Dragon cargo vessel smells like a new car, said astronauts at the International Space Station after opening the hatches Saturday following the spacecraft's landmark mission to the orbiting lab.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 19 hours ago | popularity 4.5 / 5 (20) | comments 0

Astronomers seize last chance in lifetime for Venus Transit

Astronomers are gearing for one the rarest events in the Solar System: an alignment of Earth, Venus and the Sun that will not be seen for another 105 years.

Space & Earth / Astronomy

created 19 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (3) | comments 2

Australia hails surprise super-telescope decision

Australia has hailed a surprise decision giving it a role in a radio telescope project aimed at revolutionising astronomy, vowing to draw on its decades of experience in space science.

Space & Earth / Astronomy

created 19 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (4) | comments 1

Astronauts enter world's 1st private supply ship

(AP) -- Space station astronauts floated into the Dragon on Saturday, a day after its heralded arrival as the world's first commercial supply ship.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

created 19 hours ago | popularity 5 / 5 (5) | comments 0

Sophisticated simulations predict future warming

The chances of our planet being hit by a global warming of 3 degrees Celsius by 2050 is as likely as it being hit by an increase of 1.4 degrees, new research shows. Presented in the journal Nature Geoscience, the British study ...

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

created May 22, 2012 | popularity 4.4 / 5 (9) | comments 51


Scientist: Evolution debate will soon be history

(AP) -- Richard Leakey predicts skepticism over evolution will soon be history. Not that the avowed atheist has any doubts himself.

Dell tablet leak: 10.1-inch display, two-battery choice

(Phys.org) -- Headline after headline talks about vendors’ tablets in the wings as likely number-one contenders for the iPad. Such claims have justifiably been taken with a grain of salt, considering ...

SpotterRF debuts Radar Backpack Kit (w/ Video)

(Phys.org) -- SpotterRF has announced a special radar backpack kit designed to enhance situational awareness for soldiers on the ground. The company says its special radar is designed for warfighters as part ...

Thousands of shellfish found dead in Peru

Thousands of crustaceans were found dead off the coast of Lima following the mystery mass death of dolphins and pelicans, the Peruvian Navy said Friday.

Keep food safety in mind this memorial day weekend

(HealthDay) -- Picnics, parades and cookouts are as much a part of Memorial Day weekend as tributes to the United States' war veterans.

Family history of Alzheimer's affects functional connectivity

(HealthDay) -- Cognitively normal individuals with a family history of late-onset Alzheimer's disease (AD) may display lower resting state functional connectivity in the default mode network (DMN) of the brain, ...