Urban farming yields small climate gains

October 11, 2010 by Roelof Kleis

Farming in and around cities is sustainable, but the gains in terms of climate are limited. To really make a difference we must change our eating habits. This conclusion was reached by Wageningen University researchers (The Netherlands) from PPO, who calculated for Almere council the likely climate gains from large-scale urban farming in the planned Oosterwold. This 4,000 hectare development with housing, offices and farms is intended to become the vegetable garden of Almere. The study calculates what this urban farming would mean in terms of fossil fuel usage, greenhouse gas emissions and food kilometers.

The starting point for the calculations is Almere's ambition to make sure that by 2030, one euro in five spent on food in the town goes on local produce. This will largely consist of fresh or lightly processed items such as potatoes, vegetables and fruit, which can be grown on relatively small areas.

Over-ambitious

It seems the target is over-ambitious. Even theoretically, it would be a mammoth task to replace twenty percent of the current content of our shopping trolleys with local products, admits Jan-Eelco Jansma of PPO in Lelystad. 'If you insist on sticking to potatoes and fresh fruit and vegetables, it will be difficult.' If you add a good proportion of the eggs and milk consumed, then twenty percent becomes feasible. But to do that you need twice as much land: more than is available in Oosterwold. For this reason, says Jansma, Almere has changed its target to ten percent local produce.

Carting food around

The environmental gains are somewhat disappointing too. The savings that are possible are 'relatively small in proportion to Almere's total energy consumption'. For example, the reduction in CO2 emissions is equivalent to the emissions caused by 2,000 Dutch citizens. But to achieve that, Almere's 350,000 future residents would have to do a fair proportion of their shopping locally. The main climate-related gain would be the reduction in kilometres covered to bring food to consumers. Jansma: 'We had expected that more food was carted around the country than now appears to be the case. You can see that positively though: a lot of food is already produced locally in the Netherlands.'

Kilometres

Local production alone will not solve the problem of the transportation of food, says Jansma. To achieve a real change here we will have to change our drastically. That means: less meat, fewer exotic products and fewer highly processed ones. Anything that comes from far away costs many food kilometres. Another point is that we must stop throwing away so much food. According to Jansma, this will deliver far higher environmental gains. Urban farming can contribute by making consumers more aware of the food they buy and of sustainable consumption. The results are therefore not a reason to abandon urban farming, says Jansma. 'It still makes a considerable contribution. And every little helps. What is more, there are many other arguments in favour of urban farming.

Explore further: Scientists study how climate change impacts food production

Related Stories

Scientists study how climate change impacts food production

April 21, 2008

The old adage, “We are what we eat,’’ may be the latest recipe for success when it comes to curbing the perils of global climate warming. Despite the recent popular attention to the distance that food travels from ...

Fighting global warming — at the dinner table

May 5, 2008

Substituting chicken, fish, or vegetables for red meat just once a week can help combat climate change — even more dramatically than buying locally sourced food, according to scientists in Pennsylvania who studied the environmental ...

Why eating less can help the environment

July 23, 2008

An estimated 19 percent of total energy used in the USA is taken up in the production and supply of food. Currently, this mostly comes from non-renewable energy sources which are in short supply. It is therefore of paramount ...

Cut energy use by eating better, study says

August 12, 2008

(PhysOrg.com) -- How much energy we use to produce food could be cut in half if Americans ate less and ate local foods, wolfed down less meat, dairy and junk food, and used more traditional farming methods, says a new Cornell ...

Recommended for you

Study calculates the speed of ice formation

August 3, 2015

Researchers at Princeton University have for the first time directly calculated the rate at which water crystallizes into ice in a realistic computer model of water molecules. The simulations, which were carried out on supercomputers, ...

'Snowball earth' might be slushy

August 3, 2015

Imagine a world without liquid water—just solid ice in all directions. It would certainly not be a place that most life forms would like to live.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.